We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have several rosewood toted planes, dating back to 1867 patent dates, that have the tips of the horns broken from the totes. I'm presuming that these are made of Brazilian rosewood. It would be good to fix them, but I don't know whether other rosewoods are a close enough match so that the repair wouldn't be so obvious.
A few years ago I picked up a piece of wood at my hardwood supplier. He called it rosewood(no idea of which type). It was a perfect match for some totes I have repaired. The stuff is reddish brown with almost black streaks running through it. Looks kind of like chocolate ice cream with fudge swirled in. I use it for special projects;inlays,tool handles, knobs,etc.. I could probably spare a small piece for a tote repair.Getting a match would be tricky though. Maybe with a picture.---Jack
If you have a lathe, I think it looks better to make a whole new tote and matching knob than to repair a tote. You can always see the seam where the tote is glued and that bothers me I guess; others may see it differently. I like cherry totes and knobs, but you could always buy some cocobolo and make a knob and tote. So far I have never dropped a plane on the floor; I am not sure why you see so many broken totes, but I guess some people are careless about their tools. One nice thing about making a new tote and knob is that you can make it to fit your hands, and be creative about it.
I have discovered that when you paint the tote John Deere green, all glue joints disappear.
Seriously, If you repair your totes with new wood, the repair will most always show. Some will be better than other repairs, but 99% of the time it will be noticeable. I would say, if you can make a repair that is something to be proud of as far as repairs go, then I'd say, definitely do repairs. Stains and dyes can be helpful.
I recently repaired an upper horn on a Disston handle made of Mahogany. It was one of my better repair jobs and one whole lot easier than making a complete new handle.
I do like the idea of making a new tote for a plane to fit your hand though. Making plane totes is much easier then making a saw handle. Usually though, when we are making things like this, we don't give much thought to how one is easier than the other, only the end result for the overall look of the tool.
The upper horn repair in the picture below didn't include any stains or dyes. I was going for exposing the natural grain. It was either that or paint it John Deere green.
Some of the things have helped me in most repairs have been;
To use old wood whenever possible,wood salvaged from other totes or tools that match as closely as I can get.
To prep the joint to get the best and thinnest glue line I can possibly manage.
To treat the repaired part as a totally new piece once assembled.By this I mean the old tote is completely stripped to bare wood and then the entire part is finished with an eye to both blend the two pieces to look as one and to maybe use dye or a light stain to darken or age the wood as needed.
If you look at a lot of old tools you will notice that there is wide variation not only from tool to tool but sometimes between parts in the same tool.
I`ve seen planes where the knob and tote were obviously from different shipments of wood if not different sub-species of wood.Your knob and tote don`t have to exactly match.If you feel the finish must match remember,your can always refinsh the knob to match the repaired tote,etc.
Sometimes if there are pronounced darker streaks running thru a part you may have better luck cutting a part further back to place the glue line in one of those darker areas to help hide it.
I have had the best luck repairing by matching grain direction,density and texture first and then matching color through the finishing stages.When I matched for color,once the final finish was on it sometimes became apparent that the piece was assembled because the grain changed direction at the glue line or the pores/texture were obviously different .
If you decide to go with making your own tote then I will offer one quick tip;
Drill the hole first and start the hole by drilling the counterbore size and depth first.
For me the hardest part (before I bought a milling machine)was getting that hole that runs thru it right.
Starting with a block of wood that can have the base at an angle to allow that hole to be drilled at a right angle to that base will go a long way toward making that difficult step easier.
It will also help avoid the heartbreak of investing hours of shaping just the right piece of wood and having it fit your hand perfectly only to have the nearly finished tote ruined because you put off drilling that hole.
Brazilian is very different from other varieties, part of that is that the best B is actually rotten, a bit like spalted. Anywho, in a plane handle, if it is all a solid colour, you would not notice the substitution. "A man running for his life wouldn't notice..." as the wits in my family used to observe.
Brazillian is still available if one is truly motivated...
Thanks for the generous offer, Jack. I'm going to my hometown over the weekend and called my favorite hardwood guy and learned he has a stash of cocobolo. Nice thing is he'll sell me a foot off the end of a board.
I still owe you a pic of the saw handles I fixed with the apple you sent me a couple months ago.
I like the idea of rolling my own totes and knobs. I've done a couple from walnut. Two of my planes are darn near collectibles, but they're not allowed to sit on the shelf - they get used like anything else. The type 2 Stanley and a #5 Winchester both have the horns broke off and I'd like to keep as much of the original totes as possible.
The other planes are going to get new totes. They're cracked in the middle, and PO's tried to repair them and botched the job. I particularly like the design that Scott Grandstaff uses on his totes. My hands are a little bigger than average - not as big as his, but the design is great. The idea of having something specifically made to fit is really appealing. And even though a low knob is not appropriate for the type planes I have, tough, because I like the low knobs.
Your handles are part of what has inspired me to undertake repairs that I wasn't sure I could do. Jack G sent me a chunk of apple over the winter that I used to repair the horns on a couple saws, a thumbhole rip Disston and a plain Jane D8. I'm reluctant to replace most of these handles because I'm a sucker for sentimentalism - they were originally my dad's and have his initials either carved or written on them.
However, the one that means the most to me is another plain D23, and it has a replacement dogmeat handle that needs to go. I still remember the day (roughly 45 years ago) my dad gave me that saw and explained it was mine. It was his first one and now was my first one. Unfortunately, someone butchered the last sharpening job and a repair is way beyond my meager sharpening skills.
I learned the hard way that the hole has to be the first order of business. It took roughly a half dozen tries to figure out a way to do it. I finally made a jig that holds the blank in the right position. But the best part is that I have access to a Bridgeport mill at work, and the next ones are going to be drilled with that. I don't have a decent drill press and oddly enough neither does our machine shop. But there is that Bridgeport.
Your advice about matching for color is very timely. I'll take my old totes along when I pick out the new cocobolo this weekend. The lumber store owner is an old friend and he'll let me do that.
Got to admit I don't know for certain that the original totes are really B. rosewood, as opposed to cocobolo or some other rosewood species. It's just an assumption on my part, based on common knowledge on the 'net, and we all know how accurate that is. I'll match for color and grain.
The answer to the species selection of totes is yes.
Yes Brazilian and coco and many of them were Indian rosewood as well.
Then there are color differences between even the same "kind" of wood.
Fortunately, most varieties of rosewood can be dyed or stained to a really close appearance. So if you pick a likely suspect, say Honduras rosewood (superb rosewood available for the least money, in my experience),
it is very easy to simulate the color of whatever kind of rosewood your tote is made from.
Match up the grain direction and the rest is easy.
I did an article on tote repair. I have repaired many of them and even if its possible to squint hard and see the repair many times (only if you are deliberately playing Inspector Defect),
it is still vastly improved over a snaggle tooth broken tote, to me.
Thanks for the pictorial, Scott. That's pretty much the method I've used, but the stain business is particularly useful.
I have dogmeat #4 that is going to get a total makeover. Way back when I was first buying planes (versus inheriting them) I picked up this piece of crap #4 that had been through a fire. The only decent thing about it was the adjusting nut. If I'd had any sense I would have walked away, but it followed me home anyway. I've spent too much money and waaaayyyy too much time on it, but what the heck, it's a plane (of sorts) so it's going to get a tote and get used anyway. Maybe some poor unsuspecting soul will think that s/he can't live without it
And, if you don't mind, I like to use your "widebody" design. Somehow, that really works for me.
Really nice work on that tote, Scott. Doesn't get any better than that!
Thanks for your tutorial.
I use similar methods on saw handles. Flat matching glue sufaces and even clamping, as you point out, is the secret to getting a strong joint. I too have found that Titebond yellow glue works just fine. I've never had a repair break. The clamping doesn't have to be really tight, just enough to make sure the two glue surfaces are flat together. Many times, I remove the clamp after only 3 or 4 hours.
Some repairs on a saw handle will sometimes require some elaborate clamping setups as depicted below. This backsaw handle repair in the was a bit tricky. With this one, the goal was to end up with a functional saw, not so much matching the wood color. There were many more steps in repairing this one than what these pictures show. This is just to show that most any damage, no matter how bad, can be fixed. As bad as this was, it was still less time consuming than making a new handle. In the beginning it was debatable though. Sometimes it's mainly just the challenge. Once you tackle the worst, all the others that come after, are easier.
Marv
This angled cut was made by hand using a 12PPI metal cutting handsaw filed rip with close to zero rake angle on the teeth.
The problem here was gluing at an angle and preventing the new wood from sliding. Ya just cain't have too many clamps.
Thank you for the kudoes....nice to know when someone is inspired to do something they thought they couldn't do. It's usually not just one big job. It's a series of steps and stages that gets it done. No need to worry about screwing it up. It was already screwed up, so if you do screw up, you just back up and do it over. One repair merely becomes two repairs. Been there many times. A true craftsman is one who can fix his/her mistakes so it won't look like a fixed screw up.
When we have sentimental connections with an old tool, the time it takes to make repairs is not an issue.