Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

Posts

A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#1

A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

wilbur

One of the last things I needed to do before flipping my workbench over is to make the groove to receive the upper tenon on the sliding deadman. Originally I thought about this in terms of being a deep groove, as it is 5/8" wide and needs to be 1-1/2" deep. So I thought about using some sort of plow plane, except that none of the planes that I have that would be suitable for this task will make a groove that deep. Then I started thinking of this less as a groove, and more like a really long mortise.

I used my Japanese plow plane to establish the sides of the groove. The groove is 5/8" wide, and the plane cuts a groove 1/4" wide, so I did one side and then the other.

After the sides were established, the groove was about 1/4" deep. It needs to be 1-1/2" deep when its done. To do the rest, I tried a few approaches, but the most efficient seemed to be to use a 1/4" mortise chisel to continue the grooves that the plane left. I chopped down at the far end of the groove so that it was at final width and depth, and then started working back along the tracks left by the Japanese plow plane, first one side, and then the other. There was one section of the groove where I tried drilling out the waste with a 1/2" brad point bit and cleaning up the sides, but this seemed to be easier overall, and not much slower.

Here's an in-progress shot of the groove.


This may sound like a lot of work, but it's actually not as bad as it may seem. The key, I think, is that by establishing the end of the groove, I gave the chips someplace to go as I chopped, which makes mortising go much faster. As a result, I can work back going about 1/4" at a time, and it takes me about 5-10 seconds of chopping to drive the mortise chisel down to the depth that I want. This goes by much more quickly than it sounds.

Of course, a router would be faster, but what's the fun in using that? In the end, it will be way cooler to say that I made this groove by hand. Stupider, maybe, but still cooler.

Plus, I don't have a router. Not the electric kind, anyway.

After finishing the chopping. I used a router plane to finish leveling out the bottom of the groove, checked the groove with a straightedge and square, and pared the sides of the groove to make sure that they are the correct width and square.

Here's the final result, along with the tools that I used during this process.


Between this and making the 1" wide mortise and tenon joints for the stretchers and leg-to-benchtop joints, I've done a lot of mortise making. This is what I learned while doing all this chopping:

-- Again, I think the key to making the mortise chopping easy is to first give the waste somewhere to go. Either work on one end and make it full width and depth, or simply drill out a hole at the end of the mortise to give you clearance. It's surprising how much faster the chopping goes.

-- When chopping, many light hammer blows is easier, and not really that much slower, than a few big hammer blows.

-- It seems that the conventional wisdom is that chopping the mortise takes a lot of time. Actually, the final paring and checking the sides of the mortise for square probably takes up just as much time.

-- Whenever I was having trouble with making the mortise, without a doubt the problem was either a tool that could be sharper, or I thought something is square when it really was not.

-- It's unbelievable how useful a big wide 2" chisel is. I've put a 2" wide paring chisel on my shopping list.

Now that this groove is finally done, I think I've cleared a major milestone, because now I can turn this bench over and use the top. After flattening it, of course. ;) Then I can use the bench to make the other parts: the deadman, and the leg vise assembly.

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#2

Way cool

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Neat, Wilbur. You're going to wind up with arms like Popeye, and a lot of useful skills and experience.

Yes to the wide paring chisel. I've got a western paring chisel, about 1-3/4" if I recall (it's been raining here, and I don't feel like walking out to the shop to measure it), that has been vital more than once for deep long-grain paring. Even when it's not as sharp as it should be - it's often about as sharp as I am, which, on the continuum, is just the far side of the edge you can get on sedimentary rock* - it will pare long grain and keep it square and smooth.

*or, as a coworker of mine used to say, "sharp as a button."

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#3

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mort

Stuart Hough

Looks good Wilbur! I understand where you're coming from about the hand tool method. Thanx for your advice on the cambered iron for flattening the high sides of my workbench. I spent about 3 hours on mine today, and I believe I've got it where it needs to be. I stood back and thought about how all the scalloped edges had been knocked down and replaced with flat, even areas. And when I got out the straight edge and checked, I got a sense of pride in the fact that "I did that"! Now I can use the top to start building the base. I might even get mine done by Memorial day! Good luck with the rest of your build!

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#4

That looks great, Wilbur!

Hank Knight

I can't wait for you to turn that big sucker over and begin enjoying the fruits of your many labors. :)

Hank

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#5

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mort

Greg B�tit, Vergennes, VT

Tne sliding deadman has the groove on my bench. Underneith the top of the bench the deadman runs on a 5/8" X 3/4" strip that was screwed on. The same for the bottom.

The deadman is made from 5/4" stock. The bench was made some time in the 1800's, and the dimensions I'm quoting are from memory. I'd post a pic but I'm not familiar with how one does that with this new format.

greg

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#6

Greg: sent you an e-mail on the pictures

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#7

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mort

wilbur

Having the notch in the top of the deadman and attaching a strip to the underside of the benchtop certainly would be easier. The advantage of having the groove in the underside of the benchtop is that I never have to worry about clamping issues.

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#8

2" chisel you say?

Bob Hackett

I see mostly Asian handtools in your pics.Does the 2" paring chisel have to be Asian too or would something like a Whitherby be of interest?

MB

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#9

Re: 2" chisel you say?

wilbur

I mainly use Japanese tools, but when I was going on about the benefits of having a wide chisel, it really could be either western or Japanese. The main thing is that the thickness of the chisel be thin enough so you can get it into the spot where you need it.

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#10

Too subtle I guess

Bob Hackett

What I was asking was if you personally would consider a western chisel as I have a few.I sometimes set them up as mini slicks.

They are,in fact,socket type paring chisels and have the thin beveled blades that set them apart from the registered or timber framing chisels with the thicker,flat sided blades that Whitherby also offered with a crowned face(I have those too).

Just a hint if you might be looking for a laminated chisel made on a nearer shore.

MB

Re: A big groove, or maybe it�s a really long mortise

#11

Re: Too subtle I guess

wilbur

Ah, I see. I just happen to like Japanese chisels over western chisels, even the laminated ones, mainly because I think they look cool. ;)

I do think that a well made Japanese chisel has some advantages in ease of sharpening and edge retention, but that these differences probably aren't enough to really say that one is better than the other. Probably a much bigger factor in whether one likes to use a Japanese or western chisel is the balance and size of the chisel, and how it feels in use.