Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Door glass installation

Posts

Door glass installation

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Door glass installation

Jack Guzman from Maine

This is slightly OT. I'm rehabbing an old pair of entry doors to install in an old house. The doors are built using wedged through tenons.The wedges are on the outside of the tenons. I disassembled the doors so I could clean out old paint and dirt and tighten them up.There doesn't appear to be any glue at all in any of the joints. The doors came apart easily(with reverse clamping) because everything was dry. I plan on glueing all surfaces with hide glue and tightening up the wedges as well as pegging the joints.I have two questions that I hope someone in this forum can help me with. First,am I wrong in glueing these joints?The dry wedges have been sufficient for years.I'm just concerned that the glue might restrict movement.

The second question is illustrated by the sketch enclosed.The door was stripped of all paint and moldings on one side.There was no glass in the opening. The panels are as shown,7/16" thick floating in 7/16" deep grooves.The opening for the glass has 2 1/8" wide strips in a similar groove. On the one side that has moldings,the molding is flush with the strip in the window opening and there is paint on the top edge. I need to know how to install the glass. In the third sketch is a guess on my part. Any ideas on how to finish the bare side of this door that would also accomodate the installation of 1/4" glass?----Jack


Re: Door glass installation

#2

Re: Door glass installation

Jorge Casta�eda

Good morning Jack,

I did the same thing to an old door about 10 years ago, and epoxied it, wish I didn't because the wood moves and the panels broke, also in my experience, doors with horizontal panels work better indoors, the ones with vertical panes for outdoors.

Jorge

Re: Door glass installation

#3

Re: Door glass installation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Jack,

I have a similar door on my old house, with wooden raised panels below and a beveled glass panel above. The wooden panels are raised both sides. It's a New England style house, though in Calif. Before getting into any details, I have a couple of questions: In your drawings, which side of the door is _without_ moldings as it stands right now, the inside or the outside? Second, are the wooden panels raised both sides?

Wiley

Re: Door glass installation

#4

Some random thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

NOTE: I've had no real contacts with Maine (besides having a "Bert and I" record and picking up a couple of Maine natives hitchhiking when I was younger), so my California North Coast obsession with water may be less relevant where the water comes in solid form, except during mud season (which I understand we in the rest of the country refer to as "summer"). But I offer these thoughts in case they're helpful.

Around here, it's rare for exterior doors of the period of this door to have through-tenons, because of the prospect of water entry leading to rot. Paint's not as fond of staying attached to end grain as to long grain, which exacerbates the problem. You might talk with a good paint person about how to protect those tenons.

Another water issue is that the bottom molding/filler piece on your door is a good place for water to sit, wearing away at your finish job until it can penetrate, where it will rot out the rail. You've got two pieces of wood, which will move against each other. At the least, the bottom one should be modified to slant outward, to encourage runoff.

Have you considered dual-pane glass? Single-pane is a major heat "window" (pun not intended, but I couldn't resist once I realized) from a house. Around here, standard dual-pane assemblies are 1/2" thick - see next paragraph for how you might address this.

I would consider removing those filler pieces and filling the groove, or at least carving them back so the glass can sit against the outer molding (you'd want to reduce their width enough that the glass was resting against a thicker part of the molding). You'll need wider molding at the back to compensate, unless you use dual-pane glass.

Locally, glass shops use flexible caulk - Dap, I think it is, makes a "door and window" caulk specifically for this purpose. It takes, in my experience, a little longer to cure than other caulks, but seems to work well. You'd want to tool it so there's a little caulk visible in the glass/molding joint. When you paint, bring the paint onto the glass slightly past the caulk (we're talking smidgens here, far less than tads). This will give you a couple of layers of defense against water penetration.

Doors like this have lasted for years around here through lots of rainy winters. Cleaned up well, and painted properly, I'd think these could do fine.

Re: Door glass installation

#5

Good question, Wiley

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Stuck moldings - made as part of the rail/stile - should always be on the outside of the door, with the attached moldings on the inside. If both are attached, just be sure the outer one is bedded well in caulk (if you remove it as part of the project) and fastened firmly.

Re: Door glass installation

#6

Re: Some random thoughts

Bob Hackett

I would think the real problem would be dealing with the 11%+ humidity in the wood on the outside of the door and the 6%- on the inside during the winter heating season.That and the difference in temps will combine to be a real bear.

Make sure your weather stripping can handle the warpage.We prefered the brass sheet metal types.

Most of the old wood doors we refinished for folks up here were made of woods like mahogany or 1/4 sawn SYP and we took pains to finish both sides of the door the same,usually with spar varnish or Sherman Williams high grade exterior paint.

If they wanted one side natural and the other painted then both sides got the varnish and one side also got an extra top coat of paint.

I will also say that unless an old door with panels was used under a heavily protected porch with a goodly overhang we offered no guarantees as the finish is bound to crack where the panels meet the frame and rot will set in sooner or later.

The worst ones were those with a brass kick plate installed after we left.

MB

Re: Door glass installation

#7

Mud Season?

Bob Hackett

Must be talking about Southern Maine.

Central Maine and above we have 8 months of winter and 4 months of rough sleddin`.

Mud Season huh? Must be somethin` those folks "from away" thought up,kinda like Black Fly Season maybe? :D

MB

Re: Door glass installation

#8

What I was going to say....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

My door is protected by a deep porch overhang.

The door has two wooden panels below, and a beveled glass panel above (generally similar to Jack's project).

The outside of my door has bolection moldings, all identical, around both wooden panels and the glass panel. They need to be bolection, or else they would be crowding the field of the raised panels.

On the inside of the door, only the beveled glass panel has a molding. This inside molding is inset, not bolection, but is styled to 'look like' the outer bolection molding. The outer molding on the glass is about 3/16" proud of the inside molding--don't know why this is so, but mention it because Jack is showing his modified bolection molding a bit proud.

The wooden raised panels inside have no molding--don't know why, the other doors from the same era (ca. 1900) have inset (stuck) square ovolo moldings around the raised panels on both sides. Cheap door maybe, but I mention it because Jack's project door has no moldings on one side.

Wiley

Re: Door glass installation

#9

I remember mud...

John in NM

I had a knack for getting Dad's truck stuck in it! :D

Re: Door glass installation

#10

Re: What I was going to say....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm not sure using exterior moldings is the most secure way to build an external door. Why would that choice have been made?

Pam

Re: Door glass installation

#11

Re: What I was going to say....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Pam,

Well, what I don't know about doormaking would fill many books on doormaking. What I generally understand is that you don't want a plain (inset) molding on the exterior side of a door, as Bill Houghton said, because it invites moisture into the seam between the molding and the panel.

Rather, a bolection molding is used to cover panels on the exterior side. This is because the bolection molding shrouds the entire joint and throws water away from the joint. Caveat: This is what I have read. There are undoubtedly many practical factors involved in making a sound applied molding in an exterior situation. For example, the details of sealing would be all-important, right on the face of it.

Perhaps someone more knowledgeable could elaborate. I do know that exterior bolection molding is not uncommon, and was quite common in Edwardian times.

Wiley

Re: Door glass installation

#12

I didn't think so either...

John in NM

The construction around the glass seems very strange to me, but then the idea of glass in a door that old seems strange too. I would guess it was some kind of retro fit. I still like glazier's points and putty for windows, that stuff is hard to beat. I've tried professional butyl tape and had it leak on wood frames. Must work better on those aluminum frames.

I would not glue the joints myself, if the joint is tight, it doesn't need the glue and gluing it just limits later options for repair.

Re: Door glass installation

#13

Re: I didn't think so either...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, I'd forgo the glue, too, got to love those pegs. My guess on the glass is that 100 years ago it was a better time, no thieves with hand held battering rams cruising the neighborhoods...

Pam

Re: Door glass installation

#14

Tempering

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You didn't mention this issue - but it would be a really really good idea to go with tempered glass (entirely aside from code requirements).

Bill, who has vivid memories of closing a glass door on his brother while we were fooling around - fortunately, he escaped injury.

Re: Door glass installation

#15

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Door glass installation

Jack Guzman from Maine

Wiley,

The outside is the side without moldings and the panels are flat. 7/16" boards in 7/16" grooves. The panels have all split so I'm replacing them with plywood.---Jack

Re: Door glass installation

#16

Jack Guzman from Maine

Some more info

Jack Guzman from Maine

To answer some of your comments, These doors are typically mounted on the inside of the frame,hinged inward with some sort of exterior storm door. Some use verticle boards,usually t&g held together with cross braces screwed or nailed on. I plan on either building glazed storm doors or buying some ready made. Also,the doorway is protected by a full roof. This is on a farmers porch.So no water issues here.

What I was asking was what the moldings that hold the glass in should be shaped like. All the exterior moldings were lost by whoever stripped this door some time in the unknown past.---Jack

Re: Door glass installation

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

also

Jack Guzman from Maine

The reason I had the prospective molding in sketch 3 wider than the existing moldings is because the shading on the panels from where moldings used to be are wider than on the inside. This is starting to sound confusing.---Jack

Re: Door glass installation

#18

Re: also

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Jack,

That slightly 'tall' molding on the outside checks with the original molding on my ca. 1900 entry door. The exterior mold is about 3/16" proud of the interior mold--dunno why, but it is so, and all around.

On mine, the exterior molds on both of the wood panels and the glass panel are bolection type. Bolection would be a correct installation (though maybe not the only style) for your door. In short, I think the bolection mold you have drawn in #3 of your first post is pretty close to what would have been there originally. The only real mystery is how they mounted the glass against that 2-1/8" stub that is left. If I were you, I think I would consider rebating the glass into that stub, so that you could make (or buy!) all of the exterior moldings identical.

Incidentally, do you see signs of any other moldings surrounding the glass panel? On my door, the glass panel has crown molds above and below the bolection molding that holds the glass in, and a dental mold section below the lower crown mold. I just mention that in case you're looking at 'shadows' that are difficult to interpret.

Wiley

Re: Door glass installation

#19

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: also

Jack Guzman from Maine

No sign of any other details. These doors are really plain. I like the idea of rebating the stub. I'll probably make my own molding.I already checked my local sources and they have nothing that will work. thanks---Jack

Re: Door glass installation

#20

Re: Door glass installation

bill mccarthy

As far as installing glass in your door, the previous method by which your door glass was installed I had never seen in 30 years of business [ restoration millwork] Often times in the past a 6 or 4 panel door had the upper panels removed along with the center "stile" creating one large opening above. The sides of the groove were cut out on one side creating a rabbet for the glass. The glass was then held in with a stop mld. I suppose this happened when in the latter part of the 19th century and early 20th century large pcs. of glass became much less expensive.

Bill McCarthy