handsaws
kees
http://eccentrictoolworks.blogspot.com/2010/03/ordering-reopened-at-new-prices.html
inflation takes its toll?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
handsaws
kees
http://eccentrictoolworks.blogspot.com/2010/03/ordering-reopened-at-new-prices.html
inflation takes its toll?
Why Not
Jim in Burlington On
Crowded market these days. There are more people making saws and starving than making a living IMO. Perhaps there is a market for ultra high end saws? I know what 20 hours of my time is worth to make one saw not to mention you probably need to make a few hundred to get good at it so the price looks good.
Re: handsaws
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I read his message to say that he's realized that he wasn't calculating or pricing his time correctly at the beginning - probably not uncommon for folks who get started from the making end rather than the business end.
Agree
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Couldn't agree more. Hand work can't be sustained unless it is paid for.
Andrew has determined what it is worth to him to make a saw, and that's the price--the market will decide from here.
For what it's worth, my current favorite (Japanese) sawmaker sells saws for $500-600 at present, but he has to smith kitchen knives to make a living, though he was initially trained in sawsmithing. He had to retrain to make a living. The saws are hand-forged and tempered, but still it gives you some idea of what handwork has to cost to be viable. Perhaps the most famous Japanese sawmaker of modern times has retired with nothing after selling saws for between $550 and $1,500 a piece, year after year after year. It just takes so much time to learn sawmaking, and then to actually make them.
Good for Andrew, and I expect others to follow suit.
Wiley
Re: handsaws
Marv
Knowing how to make the product is only half the job...the other half is marketing, plus doing everything else that isn't hands-on making the product.
No business is easy, but when doing it alone, is even more difficult. So many hiden costs that are not openly apparent. Andrew pays the same amount for a gallon gas and a saw file that we do.
Chris Schwarz paid Andrew the highest compliment possible...Chris owns lots of saws, but among all the saws he owns, no one is allowed to use his two Andrew Lunn saws. Chris mentioned this in his most recent blog a couple days ago.
I've known Andrew back before he started going fulltime saw making. I think he now has ahold of both reins and is doing just great. Anyone starting a business must experience that inevitable learning curve.
Knowing him as I do, if anyone can do it, he can.
Marv
I agree with Marv and wiley
Stuart Hough
From what I've read, andrew has had a large backlog of orders for a long time. He really does make an outstanding product. I doubt that he'll have any problem getting that price, and I'm certain there will be no shortage of buyers. I may not be able to afford one at this time, but one day...who knows! I might just be the guy who opens up a Christmas present from "Mrs Santa" to find one of his shiny beauties in the package!
Intelligent practice
James Watriss
When demand so fully exceeds the amount of time you have to give, then clearly the product is worth more than you thought.
Marketing is a hard thing to learn, but I'd say he does just fine, with the help of PWW. Pricing is VERY hard to figure out, because it's such a moving target.
When I can afford one of his saws, y'all will see me in line.
Absolutely!
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I read on Chris' blog that an Eccentric Toolworks dovetail saw is now $500. Good for Andrew to put a value on his self-esteem. He deserves to be rewarded for the time and skill he provides in each saw he makes.
Most buyers appear to undervalue the time that goes into any handmade or hand worked activity. Andrew's prices will raise the eyebrows of many ...
Message to the Prospective Buyer: How much do you value the seller's hourly wage? Less than or more than paid to your son for babysitting?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Agree
Marc Waldbillig
Totally agree with you, Wiley.
But
A few days ago, I received an usuba made by Heiji. Same price as for the saws. I never held in my hands a better knife making difficult cuts a child's play. Is this a chance? For me it is.
Re: Agree
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Actually, he sold tamehagane (sp?) saws for much, much more, like $10,000 - $20,000. Or should I say he tried? Even Manny, last I heard, didn't buy them.
Of course, when one won't sell to half the population, one often does less well than necessary.
Pam
Not all inflation...
John in NM
As Bill and James pointed out, pricing is very difficult, especially for hand made items. The desire to be making (saws, furniture, etc) can be so strong as to lead the craftsman to under value his work to make the sale. It can take years to acquire the confidence to not do this, especially if one is working part time at it.
Some is bound to be inflation though, materials costs are way up compared to 5 years ago - over 100% with copper compared to 15 years past. I noticed the other day that few things that I buy are less than $5 any more.
Way too rich for me...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I could get 2 or 3 for the price one with a Wenzloff. 
Re: Way too rich for me... However....
Marv
Hi Scott, 
Six, in-new-condition, Wenzloff saws just now sold on eBay for $900.00
It is true when you say that you can buy 2 or 3 Wenzloff saws for the price of one Andrew Lunn saw. It's not only money that is at play here. Each of us have our own personal reasons and motivations when it comes to spending our pennies. While we have similarities, we are no two alike when it comes to deciding what to buy and how much we are willing to open our wallets. Everything is relative. When we make that final decision to buy something, we are most always comparing to something else. Everything falls within a certain spectrum from the lowest to the highest, from the cheapest to the most expensive and from the lowest quality to the highest. We each have our points of reference when considering all these factors.
Wenzloff saws, LN saws, Andrew lunn saws, Gramercy saws, Edwin saws, and all the rest fall somewhere within that spectrum of new, present day western style saws. All those saws are being purchased by someone. All of the saw makers seem to be selling enough product to justify continuing to make their saws.
In the overall scheme of things, the cost factor is only one consideration. It's a major one for a lot of us, but not everyone. There are so many variables when it comes to making a buying decision, it would be diffcult to list them all.
So, when I see a price, whether high or low by my standards, I have to know that few, if any, will look at it in exactly the same manner. From my point of view, Andrew's new price schedule is still within that spectrum. If he had raised his prices to say, $2000, by my standards he would be, in a general sense, outside the high end of the spectrum.
Marv.... 
My cusom Wenzloff's @ 23 months and waiting.
Chuck Nickerson
Re: Agree
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Marc,
Beautiful knife! Heiji-san only has one quality level, which is high, whether he is forging saws or knives!
It is a vegetable knife, right? Beveled on one side only? I can't tell what is happening with the forging, but it appears complex.
Is that an antler handle?
Thanks for showing!
Wiley
Update: just got in line
James Watriss
So, it may be a year and a half or more, but I just wrote Andrew to reserve my place in line for a pair of his saws. My reasoning is faulty, at best... I'm somewhere between morbid, gotta see what the fuss is about, and wanting to send the money to an up-and coming saw maker, in the hopes that he continues to flourish and grow. Either way, I'll get back to you all in 2 years about that...
In the meantime, Lie-Nielsen, Gramercy, and Cherubini are treating me very well.
Strange
Todd Hughes
Strange looking saws and in my opinion plenty ugly....to busy and full of stuff going on but to lots of people I am sure it looks different, classy and beautiful
Good marketing esp. with the thing about making it to fit your hand ,[custom knife makers have been using that one for years !] and also with raising the prices.I imagine anyone that would pay $100 for a saw like this would be more then happy to pay $500 and probably many people that would pay $500 wouldn't buy one if it was priced at just $100. What you have to understand lots of people like to pay more money for thier stuff because that is how they judge the quality and they enjoy owning something that is "exclusive" that most people might not be able to afford....Aston Martin and Purdey Shotguns come to mind [and I have a Purdey double by the way] Few people have gone broke selling overpriced stuff to rich folks they have convinced into thinking they need it or that it is worth the price or that they will be able to impress thier friends with it
If a saw like this is worth $500 a nice old originaal 1800's Disston or classic English saw I can easly buy for less then $10 should sell for about $2,000 at least I figure....
In the end it's the people's money to spend as they want and if they are happy spending it on a saw like this then god bless them I'm happy for them and the saw maker that sells them.
....OH if I had one of these I wouldn't let anyone use them either... those handles look like they would break if you looked at them real hard ! .....Todd
Re: handsaws
ThomD
That obviously isn't inflation taking it's toll...
There are at least three things that determine the value of a saw (etc...):
One is the overall reputation of the maker. In this case we are dealing with a media name so that takes you well up there. But this can include a CV with every talk you ever made. Articles. Shows, you name it.
Next is the value of the saw as a saw, in which, for me, I don't see anything terribly worthy at this point... Except the person who bought the first one was obviously really onto something.
Third is the willingness to support the market over time. and again we shall see. I know lots of successful makers who spend way too much a year advertising, going to shows, mostly it has no direct economic justification but they have decided to be in it for the long haul and support their clients. About which we shall see.
Obviously on the basis of the name alone, 500 dollars is cheap. Imagine what some Japanese tools could be worth if any of the makers had followed Odate's path to the US. What we have instead, to some extent is prices that have been stagnant since the 70s (as far back as my buying goes).
Re: Agree
Marc Waldbillig
Wiley,
Thanks for your interest. Yes, it is a vegetable knife, carbon steel one bevel, hollow grind on the back. The handle ist burnt chestnut.
I'll write you soon, Wiley, cheers,
Marc