Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Repair of Replace Blades?

Posts

Repair of Replace Blades?

#1

Repair of Replace Blades?

Steve in Phoenix

I have a Stanley 60 1/2, and a Bailey No 5. The No 5 is pre WWII, not sure abot the 60 1/2.

Anyway, I attempted to sharpen both after I received them with the Scary Sharp method, but unfortunately, both blade edges were out of square with the edge. I was able to cobble together sharp edges, but not as sharp as I would like. I assume that years of sharpening without a jig caused the out of square condition.

I don't have a grinder, but could I use the edge or spindle sander to grind the blades back to square? Or simply repace both with Veritas blades and be done with it?

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#2

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Hank Knight

You should be able to square your edges using the scary sharp method. If not, invest in a good coarse stone. A sharpening jig would help a lot. I sharpen freehand, but I use a jig for regrinding bevels. I don't think I could get a consistent bevel angle or keep the edge square without one.

Hank

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Repair

Jack Guzman from Maine

The only reason to replace would be if the blade was pitted beyond repair .You should be able to find some abrasive to grind it straight.---Jack

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#4

Depends *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Question #1: how much will be left below the slot in the iron if you square them up and sharpen them (notes below on correcting this kind of issue)? Are there other issues, such as the pitting that Jack Guzman mentioned? If a lot of iron remains, and depending on your answer to question #2, go for cleaning these up. If very little iron is left or there are other problems, then buy replacements.

Question #2: is money tight, or are you feeling rich today? The aftermarket cutting irons are really nifty, but if money is tight, generations of workers used the irons like your existing irons, and did just fine. Even if you have the money for new irons, you can take these on as an educational experience, and the learning will be well worth it, but it's also true that every minute spent fussing around with tools is a minute not spent scaring innocent pieces of wood and making furniture and stuff; life is tradeoffs.

Now, then, if you plan to correct these irons: 1) take a Magic Marker and ink over the back of the iron where you'll be scribing a right-angled line soon (this is the poor man's layout fluid, and works well for the price). 2) take a square and mark out a line across the back of the iron. Don't plan to take off more steel than you have to: the line should be at the "lowest" point of the existing bevel. 3) Now grind to the line at close to a 90-degree angle, then slowly create MOST of the bevel, and finish up with hand work on whatever your honing equipment is. With power grinding, especially as a beginner, you don't want to create the whole bevel on power equipment, because it will heat up incredibly faster than you can believe as it approaches an actual edge - this is a testimonial from personal experience. You can tell when you've overheated the iron because it will turn a lovely shade of dark blue, roughly the color the air will turn when you realize what you've just done. No choice then but to grind back to a fresh edge and start over; I have a 3/8" Stanley carpentry chisel that's way shorter than my others because I was busy learning this lesson*.

You don't mention whether you have a jig or whether you're holding the irons in your hands. This is a subject that always brings out a lot of differing opinions - one might even say controversy - so the following is my opinion only: a jig is a useful tool, as it will help you maintain consistency. I love my Veritas Mk II jig, but it's an investment ($63); if money is tight, the Eclipse-type jig has served a lot of folks well for the price ($11 at Lee Valley, available from other suppliers too). Link to Lee Valley below, so you can see both jigs in one place.

The sharpening jig is a question regardless of your decision on to refurbish these irons or buy new ones, by the way. You'll always have to sharpen.

A pitch for mail order buying: if you go to the Marketplace (link up there at the left), and click on a particular company's listing there, and then buy from them after having done so, Wood Central gets some money/credit from the sellers. So it's a way of giving a little support to this forum.

*or, as the saying goes: "Experience: something that would have been very good to have right before you acquire it."


http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=43078&cat=1,43072

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#5

Re: Depends

Steve in Phoenix

There is plenty of iron left, and it is in good shape. The Bailey has an adjustment to mitigate the problem, but I am at the extreme end of it. My main problem is not having grinding equipment. The closest I could come would be the edge sander, or the spindle. I suppose I could use these with quick touches to the abrasive to reduce heat. I do have a vise type jig, but it's use depends on the blade being square.

If using my current equipment is not an option, then buying new blades would be cheaper than new equipment.

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#6

scott grandstaff

Re: Depends

scott grandstaff

I suggest you buy new blades and when you can't get those sharp either, just throw them away and buy some more.

Sounds to me like a clear case of.......................

The Cadillac is out of gas.

Should I fill up, or abandon it on the side of the road??

Every swap meet on the planet will have an old 6" grinder for under 10 bucks.

I suggest you go for the 8" size as more beef in a grinder is a good thing

So figure 25.

Of course you -should- run to the maul and happily spend 25 times that (please do, keeps the economy alive!!)

and don't forget to buy buy buy some kind of expensive jig so you never have to learn the skill of grinding steel.

Don't you need some $500 waterstones or something? That's sure to help.

Of course you "could" look around a little and find the facts of generations of guys sharpening anything they cared to, and for about free.

But nobody makes any money on that.

Naaaa, safer to start buying things.

Hey, you can pay me $500 a weekend, and I'll teach you? As long as you bring 10 more friends at the same price, that is.

yours Scott

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#7

Re: Repair of Replace Blades? *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Steve,

Does your edge sander look like what I linked to below? If so, it will do very well for regrinding your edges. Give it a try.

The main thing is what Bill H. said--mark a square line across the blade back using Bill's technique, or else just use a Sanford sharpie (cause the ink will stick). Then grind to that line. My suggestion would be to grind the blades blunt to just short of the line you make--then start the beveling as a second step. The sander will grind cooler than a high speed grinder, but take it easy and as soon as the warm creeps back as far as your finger hold, then stick it in water and cool it. This will happen in a matter of seconds. You want to cool it _before_ it gets hot; if it gets hot, then rapid cooling can cause microfracturing (I'm told). Pick a place on the belt where you get a hollow grind rather than a convex grind. The hollow grind will make honing a snap.

Wiley


Edge sanders

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#8

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Steve in Phoenix

Thanks. I have the G0564 (3HP Oscillating). It sounds like I should be able to get it done with the miter gauge, and a gentle touch. What grit would you suggest I use for this operation?

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#9

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd use 120 and a light touch. Take your time and cool the blade in some water if it gets more than warm to the touch. Hone using whatever stone you have and you'll like the resulting edge.

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#10

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Steve in Phoenix

Thanks Bruce.

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#11

Now, now, Scott

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We're all beginners at some point, and questions that seem silly later don't at the beginning.

Steve, you can do the rough grinding with your sander, and you don't NEED a jig for the blades - it just takes a little more practice to get a consistent hold on them to maintain the angle.

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#12

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Dave Tenney

I would square up the end with a stone. Then bring the bevel back in shape with a 100 grit stone or paper. I like to use a course India. If it were me I would fix the old blades instead of replacing them. That way you'll learn a new skill, which is worth much more than the money you'd spend on new blades ;)

A jig like this might help: http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2003114/576/Honing-Guide.aspx

Dave

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#13

Incidentally (homework) *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There are some good books out there on planes - setup, use, etc. Garret Hack's "The Hand Plane Book" is one; your local library may have it. I like "Planecraft," available from Woodcraft (link below) or from places like Half.com at nearly the same price. It has a lot of around-World-War-II British phrasing, which takes some getting used to if you're not already familiar with it; but it's filled with good information on the basic set of bench planes and some specialty planes (it was originally written as an adjunct to the products of the Marples/Record, Stanley's biggest English competitor, so it won't list anything Record didn't offer, but you'll get good information on the most frequently used planes).

Your local library will surely have some books on basic hand tool use -it's well worth checking out every one you can find and reading through them all. They'll conflict with each other here and there - this is a normal demonstration that there are often multiple roads up the mountain, and you can try out different techniques as you learn.


http://www.woodcraft.com/Catalog/ProductPage.aspx?prodid=10327

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#14

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

one more thing you can do to maintain a consistent grind is to clamp a 2" something on the table of that sander and set it at a 30 degree angle to the belt. Grind on the trailing edge, not the leading edge, so the blade doesn't get trapped and do something nasty to your machine and you.

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#15

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

Steve in Phoenix

I agree. Safety first.

Re: Repair of Replace Blades?

#16

Re: Incidentally (homework)

Steve in Phoenix

Thanks Bill.

And Scott, thank you sir, may I have another!