How do you stay Sharp?
Dave Tenney
Mentally I rely on Coffee!
I was making a couple of new sharpening stone boxes the other night and was wondering what you all use. I'm an oil stone type of guy, although I've used my Dad's Shaptons and really like them.
For about 20 years all I used was a medium India stone (in the lighter colored curly ash box). My Dad gave this stone and box to me on my 8th birthday (1983). The stone is still dead flat, and cuts reasonable fast. Plenty good for most general work. The box still looks good too! The two curly ash boxes in the picture were made by my Dad at the same time from a piece of firewood. We heated the house with wood back then and we used to buy a semi load of logs every year. I remember splitting that curly ash all into firewood. I wish we would have had it milled!
That darker curly ash box has a #1 Washita in it. According to the Popular Mechanics in August 1948 the only difference between Lily White and #1 Washita is the grading for color. I've not used this stone much because I just got it off of ebay for $25 NOS in the box. It seems to cut a bit faster than the Medium India and leaves a finer finish.
Next is the �mottled� Soft Arkansas and it's new Crab Apple box underneath it. My Dad bought this stone at a gun show in the early 80's. He told me he picked it because he thought it was pretty! It is a very soft stone that cuts fast. I use it exclusively to sharpen knives with and I have to flatten it out about every three or four years because it dishes out. It seems to be very similar to the Washita. This was the first stone I ever had that wasn't a Medium India. Still my favorite Stone.
The wide stone is a course India. It cuts fast and rough, yet stays flat. I think that's the best thing about the Norton India stones; they never get dished out (at least that I have ever seen). It's new box is also made of Crab Apple.
The stone at the far right in the wormy oak box is a Hall's Pro Edge Hard\Soft Arkansas Combo. I bought this after reading a Bob Smalser article. I hated this stone when I first bought it because it had a rough finish on the stone faces. Every time I'd sharpen something it'd get the edge caught in a rough spot on the stone and DE-sharpen it. I was mad as heck that I'd spent $35 on something I couldn't use. I put it in a cabinet in the shop and it sat there for five years until this weekend. Since I had to flatten the mottled Arkansas stone above, I decided to try to clean this stone up and give it another chance. With a little elbow grease and a bunch of 80 grit sandpaper I was able to make both sides of this stone as smooth as glass. And guess what...This is a great stone! I'm not sure if all Hall's stones come this way, or if mine was a fluke. Either way, I'm happy now! By the way, the stone itself is a very fine grade of Arkansas. The soft side is harder than my other �soft� Arkansas stone, the hard side can put a mirror polish on a chisel.
The dirty looking thing to the right of the Medium India as a strop. (A piece of tooling leather glued to a piece of scrap Butternut).
Generally when I sharpen, I try to do as little work as possible. For chisels and planes, I usually use the medium India and the Hard Arkansas followed by a strop. For knives I just use the Soft Arkansas and a strop. I also have a 2x72 belt grinder that I can use to fix things up in a hurry, which is all I usually do to my Carpentry tools.
The fine India is about the same as a Washita stone. I like oil stones the because they stay flat, and that's what I learned on.






