Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

Posts

Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#1

Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

charlie belden

The FWW : PopWood thread got me thinking about the pieces and joinery in woodworking magazines - all based on a EuroCentric point of view. But what about other furniture making traditions and aesthetics - to say nothing of joinery?

Chinese furniture is often about illusions - breaking up a slightly massive structural component into what appears to be several, more delicate, parts. And almost nothing meets at 90 degrees, mitered corners preferred for continuity of visual flow. Triple mitered joints are common and often rounded to eliminate harsh square corners, edges are eased, beads breaking up broad expanses, flat surfaces replaced with subtle, curving inward surfaces.

I inherited a houseful of chinese furniture and have begun to study them, looking inside for hints of how they are put together such that none of the joinery can be seen from outside. Simple mortise and tenon joints are no where to the found. What appears to be an applied panel on a drawer front is in fact an integral part of the drawer front - as is what seems to be cock beading on the drawer front - which is actually in the parts surrounding the drawer opening - where extra structural strength is needed.

With the world getting smaller, and China's LONG woodworking tradition, there's a lot of fertile ground for articles on Chinese joinery and furniture making waiting to be brought to American and European woodworkers.

Attached is a link to a Chinese Sideboard - with line drawings of some of what's not seen. Interesting stuff to think about.


Chinese Sideboard

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#2

Thanks, Charlie, and, for that matter,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

what about other areas - Mideast, Southeast Asia, Africa? I even saw, some years back, some nice work in Australian Wood Review that combined European massing with Aboriginal decoration on a hutch - stunning work (depressingly, the English-ancestry Aussie cabinetmaker was named, his work described, etc., while his aboriginal partner was mentioned kind of in passing; without him, it would have been just another hutch).

FWW did a few articles some years back, but quite some now.

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#3

Re: Thanks, Charlie, and, for that matter,

Bob Hackett

Woodwork magazine also did a few articles on Eastern WWers.Including temple builders and one on an Eastern school for aspiring WWers and their life philosophy.They had students out planting trees as part of the curriculum.

Also more than one showing how Eastern WWers went about making both their tools and their tool totes or toolboxes.

Toward the end of their run they even had an article about collaborative work between East and West and follow on work that was inspired by that collaboration.I remember being particularly taken by one piece that used a riven medallion of,I believe,curly redwood as part of the design.

They also featured many tutorials by Odate` that ran as a series of articles.

MB

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#4

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Charlie,

That is a phenomenal engineering illustration of Chinese traditional joinery! Really a worthy addition to Ecke's book, if only you could get verification of the leg join details. I think it might be worth sending your drawings to Yeung Chan to ask whether you're on the right track.

Congratulations on all that furniture. We have but one Chinese rosewood chest, bought on sale about 40 years ago. Not a particularly high-end piece, just what was being imported at that time. Nevertheless, this little chest very much bears out the points you are making--with the drawer beading worked into the case, dovetailed supports under the top panel, and the triple miter joints done so well that you have to look very closely to make out the join lines.

I wonder if they had jigs set up to shoot those triple miter joints. I don't see how they could have been sawn to such precision.

One particular point on the "drawer beads" being carried in the case work...The well-known western Period furniture maker Al Breed was making a great point yesterday at the SAPFM site regarding the difference in effect between a bead worked into the case, versus a cockbead applied to the drawer front. They have differing effects. They both cast interesting shadow lines, but the bead worked into the case casts its shadow line across the drawer gap, obscuring the gap. It will make the drawer appear to be a closer fit than it really is, which is of benefit particularly in climates where there has to be a moderate drawer gap to prevent binding during humid seasons.

Great post, and I hope you persevere with your drawings. I honestly think you have the makings of an interesting monograph, or book. And encourage you to seek peer review from someone such as Yeung Chan on the hidden details.

Wiley

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#5

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines

charlie belden

Wiley:

Took the attached picture of the inside view of the "leg/aprons/top frame area. Then shone a light behind the top of apron/top frame for the frame and panel. There is a slight gap through which it appeared that the leg had a tenon which extends above the top of the apron and into the underside of the top frame. Then got a strip of mylar and slipped it between the top of apron and the underside of the frame from outside. It hits where the leg's supected top tenon is. Then used the mylar strip in the space coming from the inside towards the leg. Hit something where the leg tenon should be.

So for the triple miter - apron/leg/apron - the tenon on the leg that extends up above the top of the apron jives with my illustration. And if you look closely at the bottom the the "side" apron there's what appears to be on overcut of a mortise in the leg - which also jives with my guess at what the joint looks like.


Yeung lives here in the SF Bay Area and a friend knows him. Will print the drawing and the annotated photo and see what Yeung thinks - as you suggested.

The drawers on this sideboard are each unique to their drawer opening - as I discovered when I took them out and mixed them up. Checking the openings I noticed a simple, elegant method of identifying each opening and its corresponding drawer - a shallow set of saw cuts on the underside of each each drawer front - on the bottom inside edge. One saw cut for drawer 1, two for drawer 2, three for drawer 3 and four for drawer 4. Same saw cuts on the bottom inside edge to link drawer to opening. Nothing noticable, unless you're looking, or feeling for them.

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#6

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines

ThomD

It was really a disappointment to me when Yeung Chan finally did a book that is was all about power tools. I wish he had done a book that expanded on his excellent article on Chinese Chairs. Also took me by surprise given all the coverage he had received for his oddball hand tools. Realistically the market for a power tool book is probably bigger.

There has been a lot of interest in Japanese style woodworking, but relatively little stuff on projects, aside from a few shoji books, and the demand for shoji is not all that great in the real NA world. Sorta odd. Lots of articles in mags over the years some oddball joinery book kinda like the Kama Sutra, not much to really justify the tools. Possibly as a result I am finally edging closer to western woodworking roots these days, not that it makes all that much difference what kind of chisel one uses for what, but the long tease with no tickle has kinda gotten to me.

Jason Beebe did a couple of excellent FWW articles about Chinese woodworking, including a few projects he made with Chinese inspired joinery. Sadly that was it, and I don't know what he is doing these days. Is he the JB of Medford Oregon fame?

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#7

Re: Thanks, Charlie, and, for that matter,

charlie belden

Bob wrote:

"I remember being particularly taken by one piece that used a riven medallion of,I believe,curly redwood as part of the design"

I recall that piece. He used curly redwood and used a mallet and a froe to split a cord's worth of it to get the two pieces he used for the medallions for the cabinet doors. In the black lacquered cabinet on a stand, the piece were stunning. Open the cabinet and the inside was gold leafed - quite striking,

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#8

More thanks

Frank D. in Montreal

Thanks for the work you put into that page, Charlie. I've been looking for this kind of analysis for the last 10 years or so. I'm very interested in Chinese furniture, but don't have access to many pieces or info. I've picked up some museum books on stuff like Ming exhibits that offer a few brief pages of analysis of construction and technique, but nothing close to that amount of detail. Keep it coming!

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#9

What'd You Like To Know More About w This Piece?

charlie belden

Interesting that the frame and panel doors use scissor/knife hinges - and bullet catches.

I've got a dining chair that the rear joinery has opened up that I've begun examining. The rear legs have a modified triple miter joint - in place of a tenon on the inside top of the leg is the chair back's upright. In place of a mortise in the underside of the mitered frame for the frame and panel seat, there's a round hole for the leg's upright to go through.

I've taken some shots of the chair's rear leg,frame & panel and apron joint opened up a bit. May do some line drawings of what I find if there's an interest.

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#10

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I was amazed when Mark Grable told me a few years ago that his wonderful cloud chair never sold, even after knocking its price down to $3000 or so.

What payoff did you expect from using one set of tools or other? My payoff for Japanese tools is simply the pleasure of use, and the thought of replacing half or 2/3 of my shop with western tools is formidable, especially the saws. Of course, it does allow one to continue buying tools forever, not an inconsequential mental health benefit. Please let me know when you start getting rid of your eastern tools. :)

Pam

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#11

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines

wilbur

Thanks for all this info, Charlie! I am interested in Asian furniture myself, and there seems to be little information out there on construction techniques, so your efforts are greatly appreciated.

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#12

How About SketchUp 3D Models of Joints?

charlie belden

Since Google's SketchUp 3D modeling software is available for most operating systems - and is FREE - what say you to starting a SketchUp Models Of Joinery Library? For each type of joint there'd be two copies - one and exploded view version and one an assembled view version. You could then play with the exploded view, showing dimensions if you want, scaling off of parts, view from all different angles, assemble and reassemble.

Now the problem with hidden joinery is - that the joinery is hidden! When the parts are assembled - you can't SEE the joinery. BUT - SketchUp has an "x-ray" option for viewing models.

So here's a screen shot of a Mitered Corner of a Mortise & Tenoned Frame & Panel chair seat. Then mortise on the underside for the chair leg's tenon to go into is not shown (hey, I had to start somewhere).


And here's the assembled parts - in XRay view mode


It's hard to show a single view that gives you a good feel for the joint. In SketchUp you can rotate and pan and zoom to see the model anyway you want to.

I think I'll put this SketchUp model file on my site and post the url to it here so interested folks can download it and play around with it.

Imagine having, rather than a set of drawings of a piece - having a full scale 3D model to work from.

Interested?

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#13

Re: How About SketchUp 3D Models of Joints? *LINK*

wilbur

That would be really great!

There is a website with joints used in Japanese carpentry with similar 3D models, but they use a 3D format that isn't as easy to use as Sketchup. But in case anyone's interested, here's the link:


3D models of Japanese carpentry joints

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#15

I really like that idea!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#16

Re: How About SketchUp 3D Models of Joints?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

That would be cool, and probably a lot of work. Why not make them components so you could reference a library, perhaps even sell them.

Pam

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#17

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines

ThomD

The downside is they aren't really used for the same kind of work. It may be as simply as what importers are giving us, but a lot of it is not really designed for the kind of work we do. For instance tools for lutherie, boatbuilding, and architectural molding work.

I don't intend to get rid of the Japanese Tools, see threadwith Valhalla plans. :) I just may not use them as much. More and more I reach for the other tools, and it is not entirely clear why, except as mentioned they seem to fit particular tasks. Increasingly specific tools are being built for particular tasks, so it tends to accumulate.

For instance my 30 Days of Planemaking challenge. Was working on the grips for the bench planes, the best tools I had for the purpose where microplanes, and various LV spokeshaves, including the original Boggs . I am making some floats for the planemaking part of the job. Good chance the Japanese chisels may get used for parts of the mortising and clean-up. I have western mortising chisels also, and they can take greater abuse, though I don't really roll that way.

Interesting point about YC's chair not selling. My stargazing would be that he needs to make chairs for that market, and books for our market. I am not entirely sure that the power tool book has to outsell the hand tool book. Whether a Chinese chair book would have a hope is another speculation...

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#18

Chris Scholz

Re: How About SketchUp 3D Models of Joints?

Chris Scholz

We've got a few in the works...

The conversation I had on the topic (why do we hear so little about high-end Chinese woodworking in the "main-stream" media) I think the problem is that we in the US have become somewhat comfortable with low-quality stuff coming out of China and we are ok with it as long as it says "designed in California" or some such nonsense.

It will change in due course.

Chris

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#19

Re: How About SketchUp 3D Models of Joints? *LINK*

charlie belden

Chris:

I suspect you're right - IKEA seems to be "the standard" - looks "modern" and the price point drives the purchasing decision - quality and aesthetics ranks VERY low in that decision. Used to be that many would purchase - or make - an "heirloom" piece, have the pleasure of living with it for years, then pass it on to the next generation. And because the pieces had a timeless classic look it didn't "go out of style" in a decade or less - or come apart or wear out - Coco Chanel clothes NEVER go out of style - and hod up - because they were made from good materials and put together well.

ps: I've put up what I hope will be a Table of Content web page of SketchUp models of Chinese Joinery (see attached link)

And thanks for contributing Chris.


SketchUp Models of Chinese Joinery

Re: Why Chinese Pieces In Magazines *LINK*

#20

It was Mark Grable's cloud chair, not YC.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX