Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

Posts

Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#1

Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I got the bronze strap eye today that will serve as the eye for my gate latch (great boat supplier called Green Boat Stuff - no affiliation except as a customer with whom they spent WAY more time than the profit they made from my purchase). Somehow, I failed to order eight bronze screws (for both hook and eye), getting just four instead; I suspect the cause is general dumbness.

My hardware store carries brass but not bronze. I'm not sure which brass (nor which bronze I have), but the two materials are pretty close on the scale of metals. Am I likely to have a galvanic corrosion issue if I use brass screws instead of bronze?

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#2

I would say no.

Roy Anderson

They are so close on the electrical potential scale, there's just not going to be that many electrons flowing across. You can look up galvanic corrosion in Wikipedia and they have an anodic index in which they list brasses and bronzes as having the same electrical potential and are compatible. I doubt they are exactly the same, but they're so close that the scale doesn't bother to differentiate them.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#3

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

ThomD

The other thing I might think about, depending on fastener sizing, is that brass screws are often rather weak.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#4

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

Bob Hackett

Maybe you might think about using stainless screws.

Shouldn`t be a problem as long as you`re not in a salt water area.Many folks even here mix bronze and stainless for things like garden gates and such.

Don`t know if I`d do it but some mix hardware on boats above waterline if it`s a fresh water boat.

MB

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#5

What size are you using?

John in NM

I have some #8 x 1" flathead bronze screws, left over from Dad's boat building days in the 50's.

As to your actual question, I wouldn't worry about substituting brass, except perhaps from an aesthetic point of view. Once they both oxidize a bit you may still be able to tell the difference, but I don't think it'll look out of place.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#6

Re: What size are you using?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I sent you an e-mail, John.

Yes, it's probably an exceptionally anal and fussy desire - but this hook and eye are going on a gate that's (a) highly visible and (b) way fancy. We gave our contractor son free rein, and he made an artwork, so I want to give it full respect.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#7

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Industrial Supply house

Jim in Burlington On

You might get lucky at an industrial supply house and find bronze screws. The brass will look different than the bronze.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#8

Re: What size are you using?

John in NM

Sounds good Bill, glad I could help out.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#9

tin and zinc

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Bill,

Brass = copper plus zinc,

Bronze = copper plus tin.

If it does corrode, the weather will corrode the zinc out of the brass screws first, producing a white, powdery residue. Corrosion depends upon how industrial your climate is (sulphur and chloride traces,) as well as how much the water will stay in contact with the screws

Easy to spot and easy to fix if it does occur (change the screws,) but I my gut feel is that corrosion will not be a major issue here.

Cheers,

Andrew F

(a metallurgist.)

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#10

Re: tin and zinc

Alexandre Grigoriev

Zink and copper themselves make a galvanic pair. Under water, with time, zink leeches out of brass, leaving copper as porous mass. I saw such in the toilet reservoir. But it takes quite a few years to deteriorate one mm deep.

Re: Galvanic corrosion, brass and bronze

#11

correct

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Alexandre,

Correct - that's what I was referring to.

In the presence of chlorides (salt air) or industrial pollution, it may happen quicker, but it does need pooled water to work.

They do sell a dezincification resistant brass for water fittings, sounds as though your fitting wasn't one of them.

Cheers,

Andrew