Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Mallet vs Router *LINK*

Posts

Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#1

Mallet vs Router *LINK*

David Cockey

Peter Follensbee has an entertaining and informative blog comparing the time need to carve a panel for a 17th century style chest with a mallet and carving tools as originally done compared to a 21st century woodworker who starts by using a laminate trimmer (router). Now Peter hasn't started using powertools, rather he saw the 21st century woodworker's video and decided to compare it to how he would do it. Read Peter's blog at http://pfollansbee.wordpress.com/2010/03/08/picked-up-a-mallet-and-a-little-piece-of-oak/

I assume the video Peter watched is of Thomas J MacDonald, who is destined to be the next woodworking guru courtesy of WGBH, carving the panels for a blanket chest. http://www.tchisel.com/blanket-chest-videos.html


Follensbee blog

Re: Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#2

Great blog, David, thanks

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I sure hope you're wrong about Norm's replacement, that guy is unwatchable.

Pam

Re: Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#3

The wrong metric

Bill Tindall

I don't know how the time compares but this is not a metric of any relevance in this comparison. Somebody carving with a router is doing so because they don't have the talent, experience and/or inclination to do it with a mallet and chisel. A more appropriate metric for comparison is how long it took to learn to be able to "carve" using each approach and what inate ability was required. Then someone contemplating each path would have useful information.

I have a friend that likes to make stuff for his grandchildren and personalizes these items with "carvings" by router. These small chests, stools and the like are at the "high end" of this sort of furniture-pretty, durable and highly appreciated by the recipients. To compare such work to that produced by an experienced carver on fine furniture would be silly and no carver secure in their trade would be inclined to do so.

If this example is yet another of the tedious argument of how hand tool work is more noble, or what ever, I would remind persons that most people judge by what is accomplished and not by how it got done. And, secure people don't spend effort justifying what they do.

Re: Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#4

Re: The wrong metric

David Cockey

Looks like this hit a sore spot with you.

Did you happen to read Peter's blog and look at Tommy's video? Peter's conclusion, which you may differ with, is that sometimes hand tools, once the skill is learned, are the best tool to duplicate work which was done with hand tools originally.

In one of the videos Tommy says he has no idea how the carvings were done originally and doesn't seem interested at all. But he is sure his method is much easier and quicker.

Re: Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#5

Re: The wrong argument

Thomd

"I don't know how the time compares but this is not a metric of any relevance in this comparison. Somebody carving with a router is doing so because they don't have the talent, experience and/or inclination to do it with a mallet and chisel. A more appropriate metric for comparison is how long it took to learn to be able to "carve" using each approach and what inate ability was required. Then someone contemplating each path would have useful information."

If one was talking about someone, whether pro or amateur, who has both techniques in the bag, then which is faster could well be relevant. Sometimes hand work is faster, and at other times it is slower. Nobody wants to pay for the training costs so the real race starts once those costs are sunk.

"If this example is yet another of the tedious argument of how hand tool work is more noble, or what ever, I would remind persons that most people judge by what is accomplished and not by how it got done."

Actually that is obviously not true. Whether talking sports, craft, there are many cases where people show enormous preference for hand work, the non-mechanical, either intrinsically, or because of differences in detail. Would you watch machines throw darts? One of my favorite stories in this regard concerns guitar master Segovia, who tried his best to touch many people, and encourage them. This included many builders of fine instruments. Segovia would encourage them by telling them they were the future of the craft etc... words into which many makers read rather too much. Anywho. this led to competitive feelings among some makers. One was driven nearly crazy at the fact that Segovia preferred the instruments of a competitor because of the hand tooly shop he had. The first maker saw the second as virtually a dabbler, but Segovia's sensitive nature was drawn to the romance of the small shop. "Aaarghhh!" to quote the first maker.

We see this appreciation for hand work all the time. It takes many annoying forms like the conviction that real handwork is sloppy and leaves necessary traces of incompetence all over which are to be treasured! May I be allowed an "Aaarghh!" of my own? Aaarghh!!!

Most of the people who don't care about such differences feel that way because they are unaware of them. Hand work can add cost, and people have to decide what objects they can afford to splash out for. But many people have a weakness in one regard or another. The rest largely work in valuations for the IMF...

"And, secure people don't spend effort justifying what they do. "

Either way...

Re: Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#6

Re: The wrong metric

Peter Follansbee

My name is Peter Follansbee, and I am the writer of the blog post mentioned at the beginning of this thread. I read the comments here; and would like to add some clarification if I may, in particular to the post titled �the wrong metric.�

How the time compares is simple, � MacDonald said he took over 4 hours per panel. I carved one in 40 minutes. The panel I carved I would grade as a �B� � if I took an hour, I could easily carve an �A+� panel.

To say that �Somebody carving with a router is doing so because they don't have the talent, experience and/or inclination to do it with a mallet and chisel.� � well, inclination is a stopper, but they aren�t going to develop any talent with gouges & mallet by using a router. How long does it take to learn carving the way I do it, well�you can get off to a good start in a week or so. Then years of practice � much like any �traditional� woodworking technique.

I was right up front about how I feel about machinery versus hand tools. It is clear from any of my writings which camp I fit in. I also said I don�t care what other people do. But I got the idea for the post by watching him with his �teaching� method � wherein he shows how to make a �blanket� chest� I see him as in a totally different category from your friend making pieces for his grandchildren. If your friend starts a web-based curriculum (I didn�t stick around to see if it�s for a fee) and professes to teach people how to make a 17th century chest, then I might have more comments to make.

I was writing to point out that the carvings I do are easy�not noble. That particular motif is actually not carved all that well. For 17th-century New England carvings, it falls about in the middle of the road. But it is easily attainable by a beginner. As to people judging by what is accomplished, now how it got done � my concern is how I spend my days; not where I get in the end. I prefer to spend them learning about furniture history, particularly seventeenth-century style. As for security, I feel fine. I was not justifying what I do. I would do it even if every woodworker on the planet hated it & me. I was trying to point out that carving oak panels with gouges & a mallet is easily attainable, efficient, and a pleasant way to spend some shop time.

Thank you,

Peter Follansbee

Re: Mallet vs Router *LINK*

#7

Don't let Bill see Peter's book, he'll bust a gut.

Chuck Nickerson