Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Posts

Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#1

Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Jim in N.VA

Fulfilling a long desire, I recently took a Windsor chairmaking class and built a sack back. All done except for the paint.

I'd love to build more chairs and try different styles, but finding/obtaining the green red oak is not as easy as a trip to the lumber yard. What's the easiest way to get started? Does anyone out there sell and ship split billets that I could then shape into spindles, bows, and arms? That would be ideal.

If not, what's the best way to locate, buy, and transport appropriate logs? I have a van, but not a truck and not a chainsaw. Logs for spindle stock wouldn't have to be all that long, but I'd need ones almost 5' long for arms and bows. Also, I understand I need to locate logs with very straight grain and any advice on making sure I do would be appreciated. I live in northern Virginia, in a suburb of Washington, DC.

Thanks in advance from all you Windsor chairmakers /green woodworkers out there,

Jim

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#2

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Bob Hackett

I would contact local turners as they usually deal with green wood and are used to felling and cutting trees to fit certain needs.

You could also talk to local firewood suppliers and tree service companies.If you can explain exactly what you need and be sure they understand that you are willing to make it worth their while to keep an eye out for it then most that I have dealt with are willing to expend the extra energy to see a craftsman use the wood rather than see it burned or brought to a dump.

MB

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#3

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Jim,

For a Virginia resident (and for many others), I think my first call would be to Barbara Gill, long time W/C resident and sawmill owner/operator in eastern Virginia. Check her Profile. She has a flooring business, so definitely would have oak on hand. Maybe you could work something out with her, including sawing to billet sizes that would be handy for you to go get.

I had occasion to call her once, and she was mighty kind to a California resident. She'll definitely work with you.

Wiley

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#4

green wood - really needed or just more work?

GolfSteve in Calgary

I'm confused about the whole use of green wood in chair making. My next project will probably be some Windsor chairs and I've been reading about them for years. I've come to the conclusion that working with green wood makes turning and/or bending the parts easier but makes little or no contribution to the chair's strength. I've decided to make my chairs out of kiln dried wood because it's readily available and I see little downside in joint strength. (I will not be bending a continuous arm, for which I would try to find some air dried wood)

Michael Dunbar's article Windsor Shop Stool in the October 2009 Popular Woodworking #178 has a sidebar "Paying for Past Mistakes" where he says "I described a wet/dry system of construction I had dreamed up [published in 1984]. It was not an historical process...It involved turning the legs and stretchers from green wood. I then dried the tenons in hot sand. The idea was to let the wet joints shrink around the dry tenons. The method sounded good and it was one of those things that really wows other woodworkers...I have since realized how stupid it is...everytime someone else puts it in print, it continues to pursue its cursed life...if you see someone doing it, tell them the idiot who started [this method] begs them to stop...When I die I will spend an eternity in Chairmaker's Hell drying tenons in hot sand. Don't condemn yourself...turn chair parts out of dry wood and put your joints in compression".

Drew Langsner, in his book The Chairmaker's Workshop (1997, reprinted in 2008) highly recommends using green wood. My opinion is that he likes it because it is easy to turn and bend, gives him complete control over wood selection, and he believes the kiln-dry tenon well fitted into an air-dried mortise, with appropriate grain direction selected, is a stronger joint. I don't know if Langsner learned the method of drying tenons from Dunbar or not.

On page 60 Langsner says "At the time of assembly, the strongest chair joinery combines air-dried mortises and kiln-dried tenons." On page 61, he continues "Windsor chair legs should be thoroughly dry (the equivalent of kiln dried) at their tenon ends but air dried in the mortise areas".

"For legs and stretchers, I use uniform specifications for green or dry stock, which are never combined in one set of turnings. Slight differences in dimension of dry and green wood are insignificant. (All assembly will be with dry wood)" (page 182) I disagree about the dimension change of dry and green wood being insignificant (see the last paragraph **)

On page 187, Langser says "The moisture content of the turnings at the time of assembly is important. The mortise area for the side stretchers...should be air dried...Moisture content at the tapered tenons should be equivalent to kiln dried." (page 186) He then continues by describing how to kiln dry the tenons using hot sand a'la Michael Dunbar's "when I die I will spend an eternity in Chairmaker's Hell drying tenons in hot sand".

All of this leaves me confused. I can seem some marginal benefit in joint strength by the kiln-dried tenon/air dried mortise theory, but when green wood or air dried wood is next to impossible to find for a city dweller, I believe there is so little benefit in joint strength, and so many additional ways to screw up by the added complexity of wet/dry joinery that I'm going to go with all kiln dried wood.

I will carefully select my pieces to avoid grain run-out (or rive the wood), well fit the joinery, and align the grain direction carefully following Lagnser's advice and I think my chairs will last as long as anyone else's.

**last paragraph re: green wood/dry wood dimension change. I made a Shaker style bench in a course where the instructor provided green elm for us to rive and turn into legs and spindles. We did, turning the legs with 3/4" tenons that were a squeeky tight fit into the 3/4" holes we drilled into the seat blank...we did NOT dry the tenon ends before fine tuning the 3/4" dimension (big mistake). The next day the legs had shrunk about 1/8" in diameter, making the the leg/seat joint absurdely loose, so we made new legs out of kiln dried oak.

From what I can cull from Langser's book, he uses the following woods for his chairs:

Legs are turned from green wood; air dried wood is also suitable (page 144) (BUT he air dries the legs before assembly).

Seats are made from air dried planks. (pg 145)

Seat must be made from air dried or kiln dried wood (page 174)

Bent bows are made from green or air dried wood (pg 153)

Bent bow "from rived, green wood, but ysou can also bend them by resawing a blank from a perfect, air dried board"

Spindles are made from green or air dried wood (pg. 181)

And here's a gratuitous picture of the only seat I've ever made, putting my experience and knowledge in stark contrast to the thousands of chairs that Dunbar and Langser must have made in their careers.


img

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#5

Regarding the chainsaw

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Weren't a lot of Windsor parts traditionally split (as in "riven"), to ensure that you had continuity of grain? It would seem that would be a good way to know that you got a piece of straight-grained wood.

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#6

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Mike Jurnigan in Suffolk, VA

Hello Jim,

I am a Windsor chair maker in the Suffolk area. I have a large amount of �green red oak.� I put it quotations because the oak has been cut about 4 years, but I have kept it green by keeping it stored under water. You do not have to have green red oak for spindles and bows, but it is a heck of a lot easier to work green. Forget about kiln dried wood for the bent parts. It does not work. How many chairs are you attempting to build? I may be willing to let you have some of mine if you are willing to make the drive down. I will also be doing a Windsor Chair demo in April at the Battle of Petersburg Revolutionary War Re-enactment at Battersea Plantation. Maybe you would be interested in picking some up then. Let me know,

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#7

Do you plan to rive a dried log?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#8

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Philip

Jim, Call around to the sawmills out west and south of your location. Red Oak is so common in VA that it is guranteed that one of the local mills will have a log you need. Keeping the rived pieces under water, like Mike suggested, is commonly done among chair makers. Any pond will do but keep a good chain on your log/pieces because some of us will be looking for that nice straight grained log our bought! Phil

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#9

Why green wood?

Bob Hackett

It starts with riving the parts rather than sawing.Riving means you have the strength of continuous grain thru the parts which adds strength and flexibility,especially for bent parts.

Then there`s the ease of working green wood ,it cuts like butter and there`s NO dust.

As far as strength in the joints goes,I would suggest you read "Making a Chair From a Tree" By John Alexander.This book explain the reasoning in moisture content for different chair parts and the TRUE history behind it.I can tell you now that it was not something Mike Dunbar "invented" as it`s been used for centuries by chairmakers on many continents and has research and history to back it up.

The one thing that most folks discount with this kiln vs air dried debate is that wood is a material that is constantly either taking in or giving off moisture.Finishes only slow this down,they don`t stop this.The big differences in air and kiln dried woods is color and workability IME.KD wood has a homogenized color where AD looks like natural wood from a tree.AD also works cleaner with less airborne dust and it especially turns cleaner with less splintering,something to be thought about when making a Windsor chair.Given a choice any experienced tuner will choose AD over KD.

As for availability,What could be more available than green wood?I`ll bet you could walk out in your own yard and put your hand on some!In the city you could still most likely find a source closer than the nearest lumberyard.Our minds have been trained to go the easy route and buy what a supplier has made available for us.

The tools and skills for harvesting green wood from a downed tree are simple.You will need a saw to cut to length,wedges/gluts,a sledge,an axe or large hatchet and most importantly TIME.

Splitting wood is a quick and easy way to break a log down to pieces one person can handle and to also get to know wood as a material better.It opens you up to choices as to strength and grain structure and flow in your work that you`ll never find available in any lunberyard.It will also give you an appreciation for trees and wood that you never had before.All good stuff that`s helpful to know and a real shame to miss.

Hoadley`s books are a good place to start to begin to understand wood from a technical point.If you continue on and read books by Alexander,Langsner,And Underhill plus other lesser known authors then you can begin to develope insights into the best possible use of material and maybe even into the souls of what some Native American tribes used to call "The Standing People".

I highly recommend the trip and the trouble.The payoff is beyond words.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#10

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Jim in N. Va

Hi Mike,

For the immediate future, I'm thinking of just a couple more chairs. I'd like to have another sack back and I'd also really like to try comb back. Maybe following the plans in Jim Rendi's book. At some point, a continuous arm would be on the list. I really appreciate your generous offer. I'll send you an email offline and see what can be arranged. Thanks!

Jim

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#11

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Jim in N. Va

Hi Phil,

Good advice on the sawmills. My only concern right now (and I'm sure it can be overcome with some creativity) is that I don't have any easy way to transport a log(s) of the size that I need. From what I've read, I'm looking for something that is at least 18" in diameter and about 5' long. Does that seem about right?

Thanks,

Jim

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#12

Re: Regarding the chainsaw

Jim in N. Va

I was thinking more of cutting to length. But of course, there are non-powered ways to do that!

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#13

Re: Do you plan to rive a dried log?

GolfSteve in Calgary

Nope :D

I have lots of 8/4 lying around, so I can use that if I need to rive any parts. Mostly I think I'll saw the wood on the bandsaw, following the grain.

My chair seats will be made from an air dried 12/4 engelman spruce plank (except for the parts of the plank that I'm reserving for guitar tops).

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#14

Re: Why green wood?

GolfSteve in Calgary

Hi Bob, thanks for the comments.

I agree that green or air dried wood is MUCH easier to turn. Riving the parts is also better (but sawing with the grain is almost as good)...but you understate the problems of obtaining green wood for someone such as me, a city dweller living in an area that has very few hardwood trees.

What is a huge problem is obtaining green logs (not as easy as it sounds). First of all, around here we predominantly have pine and poplar....not much else. The pine tree I planted in my back yard 30 years ago grew to be 12' tall and 6" in diameter before I cut it down to build my shop. There is very little hard-wood that is strong enough for legs growing around here. Some elm; everything else is poplar, manitoba maple, aspen, spruce/pine/fir, small amount of apple, acacia, and other "exotics". I admit I haven't chased any tree pruning companies to see what wood I could score from them. The local turning club does have a group that alerts people to trees that have come down.

I live in a semi-arid area. No ponds in my back yard to store green wood. The nearest "lake" is a two hour drive away. No swimming pools in our neighbourhood either. I guess I could cut some pieces and store them in the bathtub, but my wife wouldn't like that. No doubt I could cut the wood into slabs and air dry it if I wanted to.

I drive a volkswagen. Even with going to the gym once a week, I doubt I could toss a log onto the top of the volkswagen to get it home. I don't own a truck or a trailer. I don't have space to store either.

If I could obtain green wood in a somewhat convenient manner, I would use it. Since I can't, I don't think I'm losing much quality by using KD or AD wood.

Thanks for the info on the history of green/dry construction. I thought Dunbar's claim that he invented it was suspicious (maybe he did dream it up, but it had been done by others before?).

"As for availability,What could be more available than green wood?I`ll bet you could walk out in your own yard and put your hand on some!" Yes, I have one large pine tree (12" diameter) and one large Manitoba maple (12" diameter), both around 40 years old. No way am I cutting those down. It really hurt me when I cut down that 12' tall pine that I planted in first grade.

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#15

Ah.  That's true

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

you will work up a serious sweat bucking logs by hand.

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#16

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Philip

Sure thing on the size. But, why not quarter the log and then you could haul it in a pickup truck, or a van, to the local pond, hide it there until one piece is needed? Friends of mine do that all the time and it works for long periods of time. A log does not need to be kept in one piece to be useful for Windsor turnings/bendings. Good luck!

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#17

"simple" solution

Bill Tindall

All the woods needed for these chairs grows in your area. These trees are harvested for lumber, firewood or tree removal. Any person in the business of harvesting trees for these purposes will be willing to sell you a log or log cut into lengths if you are willing to pay more than they otherwise would get for the wood. To that end contact tree removal services, fire wood suppliers, logging companies and saw mills for your needs.

The problem will be what to do with these log sections once you get them. The logs will have to be split into billets before they begin to dry out. Our local famous chair maker (Curtis Buchannan) then freezes these billets until needed. That is not a handy solution to the problem but the only one that comes to mind.

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#18

Underwater storage

Bob Hackett

Short billets in a plastic garbage can or plastic 55 gallon drum with top.

Longer billets in either an old watering trough(bought at auction or off Craig`s list, or inside a water filled PVC pipe capped on one end with a regular cap glued on and the other end with one just set on top.Buy at scrap prices from industrial plumbing supply contractors.

PS-the PVC pipe can also double as a steam box when the time comes.

MB

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#19

Re: Underwater storage

Paul M.

My local junior college has a woodworking program, and offers a chair making class. The instructor drives his truck+trailer out to Virginia every summer to get the green oak needed for two semesters of chair classes here in San Diego CA. He breaks the logs down into billets and uses them quickly for the fall classes, and stores the lumber submerged in his hot-tub for the spring class to keep it wet. It's quite an undertaking to get materials for two classes at ~25 students each.

I've never successfully gotten to take that class. There's a waiting list a mile long to get into it and the trolls in the registration department seem steadfastly determined to keep me out of that class.

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#20

scott grandstaff

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

scott grandstaff

Windsor chair making was a country thing.

There is no way in the world you are getting 1 X 16" X 10' sawed planks with a froe and a drawknife. Its just not going to happen. That was always a city thing.

Occasionally pit sawed planks were made for bridges and such, but mostly it was ax and froe work in the country.

The big sideboards and tall case clocks were predominantly city work where people could and would pay for sawed lumber.

Straight splitting wood is not something you just waltz in and get.

Its not like every log has it. Its more the kind of thing you stumble across as you are cutting and splitting a lot of wood anyway. You save back the cream as you run across it.

It is no accident that violins and all their parts can be neatly made from the very cream of 2' long stovewood.

Trying to split, shave and then bend a 6' long 1" square piece of wood into the looping spaghetti continuous armchair, and then drill 17 holes in it???

Well there are only a few woods in the world that will take that, and very very very few candidates from even those kinds of woods.

Buying a single log blind, and hoping??

Well the odds aren't very good you are going to be happy.

At best only one 1/2 of any likely log is going to be knot free enough for splitting anyway.

With every log there is a "light side" that once faced the sun, which will be full of knots (old branch stubs) and only the shade side is clear enough.

I took down a large red alder from my yard a couple years ago. Out of a full sized alder log, I kept 2, 3' billets, or 1/2 trunk sections, as suitable for splitting and working. The rest went into the stove. A whole tree!!!

The working green wood parts thing was another country trick. Split out a lot of green billets, whittle or turn them while they're still green and soft to remove most of the waste, and stack them in the attic for months or years to dry wholesale, finishing them as the occasion arose.

The warpers and splitters go into the stove.

There is tremendous waste, but then in the country logs are cheap and you need the rest of the unsuitable wood as firewood anyway.

With the very best stock its possible to get away with using some wood green straight away, and I know people have done it, but its not how it was done in centuries past.

Do the majority of work when its green and wait for the finish, much later.

If you took a full time job handling wood in the city. Tree surgeon, landscaping, power line work, etc, you would run across enough wood to select some working stock. Otherwise you would be better served taking advantage of things you can only get in the city.

Imported rare wood and veneers, big sawed planks by the thousand BF lot, stuff like that. You can't get that kind of stuff in the country.

Or you can just get off on the lonely freeway exit nearly everyone merely drives on past, going from city to city.

And take that road 50 more miles away from the highway, and settle down there.

You can have all the green wood you want, anytime.

But you will never sell your best split billets to a stranger.

You won't sell your best to your brother, they don't come that easy.

yours Scott

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#21

OK Scott.

Bob Hackett

Now that you`ve tried to scare them all away,tell them if all the trouble and learned skills are worth the effort in the long run and if they`ve changed the way you look at woodworking for the better or not.:^)

The question originated from a person who has been thru a class and built a chair from the log,I`m assuming(that`s how it`s done up here).Now,he asked where to get green wood suitable for the next chair so once again I`m assuming he learned how to tell trash from treasure when looking at the log.Maybe I`m assuming too much but John Alexander was able to do just that while living in Baltimore Maryland and working full time as a lawyer.

BTW he used logs far less in diameter than is being called for here and even with allowing for waste a well selected red oak or hickory tree 12" in diameter will yield at least 3 ladder back chairs.Don`t know what that would equal in Windsors but hey,you could always use the non-windsor pieces to build ladder backs or post and rung stools.No need to throw it in the stove just cause you can`t use it for windsors.There`s still hammer and hatchet handles,chisel handles,garden tool handles,etc.

I`ll grant that most urban trees may not be equal to their country cousins,too many lower branches and not enough clear straight trunk,the consequences of growing alone and in the sun as opposed to in the competition of the forest where you get tall trees with high crowns early on.

Those urban trees can still be used for front legs and spindles though and the experience of riving a tree,even an urban tree,teaches you every time you do it.After you do it enough you get to where you can read the bark and know which ones will rive clean and which ones to walk away from.The only way to learn it is to do it,like most things.

The one thing I didn`t mention,as I figured most of you were tried of hearing it, was to contact the local WWing club or guild.If there`s not a green WWer as a member then they most likely will know where one can be found.

As you might have guessed,busting a chair from a tree is work and most folks who do it and don`t mind visitors would be glad of some help and willing to share good material in return for that help.I can`t think of a better excuse to get out of the city and breath a little fresh air than to do something like that and then come home with exactly what you and your new chairmaking buddy both needed.

I stand by my suggestions and still feel you`ll get a far stronger chair and a bigger and better skill set by riving green than if you use KD sawn stock.Hard to get some folks out beyond their comfort zones though.

MB

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#22

scott grandstaff

Re: OK Scott.

scott grandstaff

Ummm ok, I'm sorry. Didn't mean to sound harsh.

Its just that Windsor chairs were born out of enormous amounts of wood waste laying around with nothing else to do with it. That was my point.

Anyone that can get three chairs from a log, you are way ahead of me. I only see a tiny portion of wood that I consider suitable and I handle it every single day. I burn wood for my primary heat source and have these past 30 and more years.

John Alexander was a truly remarkable individual. He could pull off incredible things and there are a few who can do that as well,

but it wasn't downhill for him, I can assure you that. He spent a lot of time driving out into the country, I guarantee it.

Meanwhile it is 3 hours drive at minimum for me to get to somewhere I can even hope to buy a scrap of veneer or kiln dried planed planks of any kind.

Rosewood etc. I have to mail order in. In tiny pieces and high postage!

Is it a surprise I make miniatures as much as anything else?

Taking the best of what you can just waltz in and get, and making the best you can out of it?

This seems by far the most reasonable.

Play around some with what you cannot really have for fun sometimes, of course play around with a bit of green wood, its fun,

but mainly stick to what you can easily get the best of.

Everyplace has their treasures.

I try not to be --painful-- jealous of you city guys with sand cast fancy brass hardware and planks of everything and thensome, as much as you want, all you have to do is walk in.

My woodshed, where I keep rough wood, and firewood, and my forest where logs the size of schoolbusses in diameter grow all around me, is what I got.

You can't have everything.

yours Scott

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#23

Peace,Scott.

Bob Hackett

Don`t you feel better now?I promise,nobody`s gonna come over there and cut your forest down to make chairs out of.;^)

Hey,wait a minute,You`re a metalhead and live ouside the city and beyond the grasp of the HOAs!

Why for are you not casting your own brass hardware mon?Your furnace broke?

MB

PS-as for exotics out in the country.You`re on the wrong coast is all.Come on up to Maine,we`ll hop in the truck and I`ll take you to Yarmouth(a relatively small town) and Fat Andy`s where they saw real Cuban mahogany,snakewood,figured purpleheart,etc.After that we can drive over to NH(the middle of nowhere) and Goosebay Lumber to watch them sawing up cocobolo and rosewood.

On the way back home we can stop in to pick up some offcuts of birdseye and tiger maple veneer logs.Maybe some flame birch and a few burls too.

Yeah,we got wicked cold winters but we got good wood too.

MB-Who`d be willing to trade homegrown AD Maine hardwood for green madrone burl if you got any Scott.

PPS-I got bronze,Starrett tool steel and real wrought iron to trade too.:^)

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#24

WOW!!

Bob Hackett

That`s one dedicated teacher!

If it were me I`d just go as far as MO. and load up with some of that fine blackjack oak I saw at Ft Leonard Wood.Burls out by the demo range the size of VWs too.

The instructor for your class has family on the "Other coast" I`m bettin`.

MB

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

#25

Re: Need help finding Windsor chair materials

Michael Fontane

Jim,

Check Elia Bizzarri's website: www.handtoolwoodworking.com. He sells chair parts.