Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT - screw fastening into granite

Posts

OT - screw fastening into granite

#1

OT - screw fastening into granite

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm slowly working my way toward installing a bronze hook and eye to hold the back gate open (the original magnetic hold-open isn't enough in high winds). The hook will be fastened to a stone in the dry stone wall next to the gate. Someone at the hardware store discouraged me from using the plastic screw anchors, which leaves me thinking about lead anchors - actually, what appear to be aluminum inserts in lead anchors. Questions:

1. Will plastic screw anchors in fact be insufficient? They seem to me like modern versions of the rawl plugs of my youth, which worked fine.

2. If they will, I have some lead anchors with machine-screw-threaded aluminum inserts. If I'm using bronze screws, is there an issue with galvanic corrosion over time?

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#2

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

wilbur

Warning: I have little experience with screwing things into rock. But I don't see why a plastic screw anchor wouldn't work, except that maybe the back and forth tugging from the gate as it's pushed by the wind would make it work loose over time. In which case, adding some epoxy when you install it should go a long way.

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#3

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

steve mackay

Don't know about granite but I tried the plastic anchors in our rock wall (I think its just sand stone.) and they didn't hold a month. Too much "give" in the soft plastic and they just "ground down" in the hole. With over-kill in my mind (as always now days) I drilled four inch holes and put in long bolts useing that concrete patch stuff that comes in a margarine sized tub. I think it's got epoxy and goodies in it. I made sure I put a nut on the bolt (close to the head) before hand so I could cut the bolt head off and restore the threads by removing the nut. Now use the same nut to bolt on the hinges. Everything is still rock (sic) solid after three years. (and it DOES get a work-out !)

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#4

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

Hank Knight

Bill,

I'm not familiar with lead anchors with aluminum inserts. I have, however, used a lot of plain lead anchors for both screws and lag bolts. My shop walls are poured concrete and I've hung just about evertyhing imaginable from them using lead anchors. They hold very well, much better than plastic anchors, which I find practically useless.

I think Steve Mackey's solution would work well also. One advantage of lead anchors over Steve's approach is that you can remove screws from lead anchors and you can remove the anchors and fill the holes if you are so inclined.

Galvanic corrosion is a much more serious problem in salt water than fresh (rain) water. Even so, I would avoid aluminum inserts with your bronze screws because bronze and aluminum are not particularly compatible electrically. I think plain lead would be fine. Lead is much less reactive than aluminum.

My $.02

Hank

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#5

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

R.J. Whelan

Bill,

I was faced with almost the exact same need a few years ago.

I first tried lead anchors: these worked for a while, but the constant pounding of the gate closing and wind shake cause the anchors to become deformed and the screws came out.

I found some stainless steel inserts that were about 1.5" long, with a hole drilled through the center and tapped for 1/4-20 machine screws. I drilled the holes out (7/16" I think) and installed the inserts with epoxy (the kind that comes in a tube and is used to set foundation hardware).

This arrangement has been solid for about two years.

One caution: be sure to block the end of the insert that faces in (toward the bottom of the hole) or the epoxy can be forced into the treaded hole making it necessary to retap the hole .... DAMHIKT - :(

Good luck .... rj

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#6

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

Alexandre Grigoriev

Indeed, when in contact with either brass or lead, aluminum will corrode in no time.

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#7

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

ThomD

I use hardware bonding for stuff like this. I would bond threaded rod, for instance,into an oversized hole using WEST epoxy or similar. The oversized hole enlarges the bond are which is usually positive. Doing it on a vertical surface involves casting the metal in the epoxy then gluing that assembly into the hole. Nice thing about hardware bonding is the holes do not need to be precise since one can use a jig to align the metal and just pour the epoxy around it. Works great in wood too.

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#8

Same here

Frank D. in Montreal

For bonding threaded rod into stone or concrete nothing beats structural acrylic adhesive. Very easy to use, and both of the following products come in tubes that fit regular calking guns. A $25 tube anchors 4-6 5/8" rods, 6" deep. Use stainless steel rods.

http://www.itw-redhead.com/a7prod01.asp

http://www.sikaconstruction.com/con-prod-app-aac.htm

Re: OT - screw fastening into granite

#9

Anchors or epoxy...

John in NM

There are lots of anchors that get tighter when pulled on, the more expensive versions of those might work well for you. I've used several that just spin in the hole at some point though, usually they have a very cursory "tooth" on the part that expands. I don't think lead or similar anchors will last for you, they don't do well under intermittent and impact loads, though they work really well for dead loads like holding up shelves.

I also like Thom's suggestion with epoxies, if you have an appropriate product available it'll be hard to beat what he's describing.