Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

overlapping holes

Posts

overlapping holes

#1

overlapping holes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In the recent thread on Wilbur's workbench, he commented on having had difficulty drilling overlapping holes with a Forstner bit. I'm in the midst of* replacing the old, single-pane, drafty sash in our old wood double-hung windows with some drop-in inserts, which involves pulling the sash, stops, and pulleys to make room for the inserts. When I pulled the pulleys on the most recent window, yesterday, I noticed the hole-drilling work that had created the through mortises for the pulleys and thought it was worth bringing forward.


The mortises are 1" wide and 2-1/2" long, and clearly drilled with three holes. This means the center hole overlaps each end hole by 1/4". They give the impression of being drilled in the field, based on the grain blowout I can feel behind the holes; had they been drilled on a drill press, I think the back of the boards would have been in better shape. I have no idea what kind of bit was used. I do know, from experience, that even an auger bit with a screw center will wander if one side is unsupported in the hole.

While I'm speculating here, I'm inclined to think that the two end holes were drilled first, followed by the center hole. The center hole would be symmetrically unsupported - 1/4" of air on each side.

A couple of side notes:

1. There's about 1/8" of wood between the mortise for the upper sash (unpainted wood, left) and the parting strip groove. I am in awe of those carpenters - I can imagine what a hash I'd make of a drilling job in such close quarters. The wood damage visible at the margins of the mortises is a combination of the damage done by the pulley carrier flange when it was driven in and damage done by my prybars taking it out.

2. The pulleys were fabricated from sheet steel, and shaped to fit around the extra wood at the margins of each hole - that is, where the 1" round hole no longer intersects the sides of the mortise. I caulked plugs into these holes to reduce air infiltration, and removing those nubbins took me perhaps 15 seconds per mortise, but the pulley manufacturers had made that unnecessary. Production efficiencies are not a new issue.

*This is code for "over the next few months, in between other things..."

Re: overlapping holes

#2

Re: overlapping holes

wilbur

Thanks for the post, Bill! After reading this, I tried this out last night while working on some of those benchtop mortises. I drilled two holes with a brace and bit and then a third between the two, like in your picture. I still wound up having the bit drift into one hole or the other.

My conclusion, and this is something I've known for a while, is that I just suck at using a brace and bit. ;)

Re: overlapping holes

#3

Re: overlapping holes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Avoiding the drift might be somewhat easier with an auger bit which has a screw spur to keep the bit in line. I think I have at times drilled a small pilot hole, like 3/32, to help keep the bit from wandering into one of the other holes.

Re: overlapping holes

#4

Re: overlapping holes

wilbur

I was using an auger bit, but I wasn't using a pilot hole. I'll give the pilot hole technique a try. That sounds like a great idea.

Re: overlapping holes

#5

Re: overlapping holes

D. Tardiff

I'd bet these holes were made with a special gadget designed and made by the company that made

the pulleys, in order to simplify installation (and sales) of those pulleys. I may have one around, it's similar

to modern gang-drill heads, in that it has a single drive shaft and gears to drive 3 cutters/drills, which

make the actual hole. I think mine uses winged cutters such that all 3 can rotate at the same time, making

overlapping holes, without the cutters intersecting. Your pictures look like all 3 holes are pretty much at

the same depth...that'd be easy with such a gadget, harder with 3 separately-drilled holes. The gadget

also keeps them in line, you'd expect more variation if done by hand, and then the pulley would not fit as

well.

Re: overlapping holes

#6

Re: overlapping holes

R.J. Whelan

Bill,

Several years ago I had to hang some doors in a house I was renovating. Some of the doors required mortises for lock-sets that were 1" wide by 7" high by 5" deep.

The first one was done with a router (with a tail) and scared me enough to check my trousers.

The rest were done by drilling overlapping holes with an auger. There was so little wood left on either face side of the door that I built a jig out of a piece of hardwood that was about 4" thick. To this I attached an adjustable fence (to center the bit on the door) and then clamped the jig to the door, inserted the auger bit and drilled away. The combination of lead screw and jig to start and hold the bit in alignment proved easy and fast.

Some arrangement like this will probably work in a lot of applications.

Good luck ...... rj

Re: overlapping holes

#7

I've done it the same sort of way,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but higher-risk, just using a bit smaller than the mortise, and shaving the sides. I have to confess that I haven't tried overlapping holes - I just muscle the wood between holes out of the way. A wide chisel - I happen to have picked up a 1-3/4" paring chisel in my travels - shaves the sides in a few seconds.

Yes - putting a mortise lock in an interior historic-size frame and panel door, about 1-3/8" thick, does not leave a whole lot of wood on either side. It's kind of impressive that they'll hold up to normal wear and tear, which I would define as "forces less than an angry teenager slamming the door."

Our own angry teenager broke his bedroom door three times, at the lock mortise. I repaired it the first two times, but the third time, I left it until he moved out.

Re: overlapping holes

#8

Re: I've done it the same sort of way,

R.J. Whelan

Bill,

Boy does the "angry teenager" sound familiar. Mine is 34 now and he can't believe he did some of things I'm fond of reminding him about.

The absolute best was when he asked if he could paint his room in colors of his own choice. Sure, says I. He painted the walls a medium to dark gray (to match his mood I guess - >( ) and the ceiling black. When he moved out we found white walls behind the bed, dresser and amoire. I was laughing too hard to get mad :D .

RJ

Re: overlapping holes

#9

Re: I've done it the same sort of way,

Marv

Bill,

When my teenage daughters slammed their bedroom door, I removed the door. Didn't take them long to learn the proper way to close a door.

Marv

Re: overlapping holes

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

I agree

Jack Guzman from Maine

I don't think this has anything to do with your brace skills Wilbur. I don't really know but I've seen some pretty neat gadjets. I have a door knob/latch installation tool. It's in a nifty carrying case and contains a bunch of various brace bits and guides to easily drill the latch hole and doorknob hole flawlessly.I never use it. It takes way too much time to set it up. Also I've seen alot of different brace bits.Undoubtedly they used a tool suited for that particular task.If not a fancy gadjet they could have used a brace driven forstner bit or some other bit better suited to the job.Those guys weren't more skilled particularly,they just had access to different tools and methods.---Jack