Re: another perspective
Dan Donaldson
I will let you know, if I ever score a 55 
(one of the things on my bucket list )
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: another perspective
Dan Donaldson
I will let you know, if I ever score a 55 
(one of the things on my bucket list )
My take
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
I liked this issue a lot. Read every article, which is very unusual for me. No complaints with the paper or with staples (which I didn't see until prompted). I don't complain about paper until the pages are fiddly to turn, or ink comes off on my fingers--now that's cheap.
The comments so far are very thoughtful and interesting. I come down closest to Bill Tindall--that magazines are essentially entertainment. But entertainment is a big category. I would break it down further, along these lines....
1. Momentary stimulation... New tools, router shootouts, planeoffs. Of passing interest, but I'm still going to use what I've got instead of the latest commodity toy. But still, I want to know which thing won. If I disagree, I may be motivated to critique the testing as inadequate, of course.
2. Human interest and connections.... Like the Clark & Williams piece, and Jerome Bias' Thomas Day article. The highest goal here is to achieve a gestalt, where the content goes beyond a momentary 'that's interesting', and couches the present in historic context, or shows a familiar object in relation to its cultural roots--so that you have an 'aha moment'. For me, I look at Clark & Williams planes, especially their molding planes, and time stands still--there is a direct line back to Robt. Wooding, and it's as though in one instant, we are all standing in a single long room, and Mr. Wooding is at the far end, yet in clear view. I get that feeling about Thomas Day, from Jerome Bias' article, because I was born and raised in North Carolina, and can appreciate that Thomas Day could have overcome such a cultural impossibility. I would like to see more of his work. And indeed, would like to know more about free blacks in the days when slavery was still the rule.
3. Ideas that stick (and may be pursued).... Charles Bender wrote a fine survey, aptly illustrated, about the William & Mary period. It wouldn't be possible, short of a book, for him to write a 'how to make' one of those pieces. But something stuck in my head: The technique of sticking moldings right onto the front edges of the sides and drawer blades of case goods. i want to see more of that--cockbeading is easier, but the molded cases are stunning.
The availability of actual Cuban mahogany also stuck in my head. At $25-35 per bd. ft. it's a long shot--but the point is, it's not impossible, it's a matter of money now.
4. Inspiration ...... Where you get an immediate conviction "I have to do that." George Walker's article shows a chest of drawers that is absolutely stunning, and makes me really want to pursue it, if a large piece is to be in my future. I believe Bill Tindall actually made this piece last year, or one very similar, so he must have had the same inspiration from some source. I would note that Bill's inspirations actually result in projects
, with no woulda/coulda's about it.
This issue referenced a 'how to' video by Rob Millard, on making a particular killer cuff banding, that I will do.
Bottom line: Chris Schwarz and his small band of brothers and sisters succeeded in bringing forth a magazine which scores in the high-degree-of-difficulty categories of 'aha' human interest, ideas that stick, and inspiration that will result in a small but meaningful change in my life. I'm sure this small team sweats blood to make this happen, and I appreciate it very much. My hat is off to them.
Wiley
WOW!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Well thanks for the explanation Megan 
I can only wonder why that this wasn't brought up when the change in the mag was first announced.
Anyway, thanks for the explanation I really appreciate you answering my post.
Thank you.
BTW, I like your bench.
Cheers,
Scott
I got a nice card...
awleonard
Maybe yours got lost in the mail, but I got a nice card in the mail explaining the situation and that my two subscriptions would be combined and they were.
I'm not going to argue about the magazine. That's very subjective. One thing I will point out though is that I really like the accessibility of the folks at the magazine. Other mag's seem to put their folks on a pedestal and it is a one way communication. I think everybody on their staff has posted here and other sites (where do they find the time?!?) and I have received answers from Megan and Chris rather promptly.
Tony
Re: One more log on the fire...
ThomD
I agree with you James, they need to point the way to something more than the same old Mission bookcases. That is what the old FWW did, it opened the door to the best of the best. Even as entertainment I want something new, not the same old same old.
Also, the general mags have dropped off whole huge areas of woodcraft. There was a time when Fine woodworking covered canoes, skis, wood turning. Now all these small areas are covered in other publications. There is a ton of stuff on wood bows alone. Not sure what it means but it seems to be the case that there is more interest out there than is being currently served. I guess the issue is whether there are advertisers to support it. I remember a time when FWW was mostly about natural finishes, for better or worse. Nice thing about mission furniture is that it is normal for it to be coloured, brings in advertising you don't get for the Saker stuff.
Does a 45 Count?
charlie belden