Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Carving chisels/sets

Posts

Carving chisels/sets

#1

Carving chisels/sets

Gary Smyth

Way back when I was in school some thirty years ago. One or another of the woodworking/school art catalogs carried a set of, I believe, two cherries carving chisels. I think the sets came in two versions, 12 and 24 chisels and were targeted at college kids in art classes. At the time each of the chisels averaged about $7.00 each--a set equal to about the price of some text books. Does anyone remember this? Is there a steel carving chisel that will hold an edge out there now that doesn't cost $30 each? Flex chisels fit some of that bill and some engravers too, but I'm looking for a decent brand that will last a (more than my) lifetime in full size, wood handle wood carving chisels.

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#2

Not Two Cherries but...

Neal in San Jose

Wood Carver's Supply "woodcarverssupply.com" carries a line called Master Carvers or something like that. They are made in China (natch), but in the sets they are only about $10 per. I have a few (from a different source) but I've been pretty happy with them. They hold an edge well and they feel pretty good in the hand. The handles are round, so they will roll off the bench and land on the cutting edge, DAMHIKT, but other than that, they are very servicable.

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#3

scott grandstaff

Re: Carving chisels/sets

scott grandstaff

7 dollars 30 years ago is not much less than 30 per today.

It might be less, who is the team economist??

But regardless, sets are for chumps. They are for pretenders who aren't really going to carve anything. Nobody really uses "set" chisels, is my point.

Good carvers are enamored of a few chisels and all the others only come out of the roll once in a blue moon.

I am personally addicted to a goofy thing I made from an old drill shank in an hour one time. But its shallow and thin at the end and a slight fishtail.

Well, it just works for me.

Probably wouldn't work for you, but that is how it goes.

My advise is to round up some old random chisels. Slightly rusty, negleted carving chisels, with marginal battered to missing handles, can be picked up for 2-3 dollars a stem. Ebay if you have to, but some pavement pounding will pay off better in most cases.

Real chisels, veterans of proven performance. (if they were that bad, they'd have been thrown away by now.)

Regrind them to suit and try several different handle patterns until you come up with one that suits your personal grip and style.

I can assure you the first handle pattern you try will not be your final preferred choice.

Give these a try for a while and add other chisels one at a time to fill in for missing patterns you need.

If you want to try just a couple of chisels, get about 1/2" shallow gouge and a medium sized V gouge.

These two, along with an ordinary bench chisel, will take you very far.

Next, try some Millers Falls or other similar hobby tools.

Mushroom handles or little straight handles, your choice.

These are dinky things meant for linoleum block printing really. But they work fine for fine detail work. Don't pay over 20 for a handful these.

yours Scott

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#4

Re: Carving chisels/sets

Dan Donaldson

Here is a post I copied from the WC archives from 2004 by Lee Grindinger. It has a list of what he considers the most useful carving tools to start with.

Hand Tools Archive 2004

Subject:

Lee Grindinger's list

Posted By:

Dan Donaldson

Date:

3/27/2004, 1:33 pm

Response To:

Can you help me choose a carving set? (Matt Woodworth)

Lee Grindinger posted a list of his "dirty dozen" first chisels that he would suggest getting. Many of the sets have tools in them that you will never use. I would suggest starting with the ones the school required and Lee's list, then buying them as you need them. Here is Lee's post:

I've been asked to post my "Deadly Dozen" carving chisels. These chisels do 95% of my work and the work I do is traditional furniture ornamentation.

Carving chisels are sized in two different systems, the Swiss system and the Sheffield system. English chisels fall into the Sheffield system and German and Swiss chisels use the Swiss System.

Chisels sizes are described with two values. The first number is the sweep or radius of the cutting edge and the second number is the width from corner to corner of the cutting edge.

Here is the set in Sheffield sizes;

#1-1/2", #3-3/8", #4-1/4", #4-1/4" long bent, #5-1/2", #5-5/8", #7-1/2", #8-1/4", #9-1/4"

a 60 degree straight parting and a 60 degree long bent parting tool, and a 1/4" undercutting tool.

Here is closest the Swiss system comes to the above set;

#1-12mm, #3-6mm, #3-10mm, #5-12mm, #5-14mm, #7-4mm, #7-6mm long bent, #8-13mm, #9-10mm, #12-6mm long bent, #17-6mm, and a 4mm undercutting tool.

You'll notice that numerically some of these chisels seem awfully close but the sweeps change a lot when the width changes. Also, I favor long bent chisels as opposed to short bents because you can use a mallet with the long bents. In addition to chisels you'll need a set of slips, a nice flat fine stone and a mallet. I know almost nothing of the Japanese sets so I'll reserve comment except to say that I've heard good things about them. Also, I use a router for most of my grounding but before the router I used a #9-1/2" for hogging out waste.

This will get you started...

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#5

Re: Carving chisels/sets

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I got my first carving tools in 1978. Their average cost was 6.50 per tool. Those exact tools are available today. I looked them up and the average cost is $31. Serious carving tools are usually in the 25 to 40 dollar range. And if there are not more than a hundred different tools of a certain brand, you can be sure serious carvers are not buying them.

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#6

Sets and other stuff

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Agree with Scott about sets--they're not a deal. What you need is generally what is found in Lee Grindinger's selection--sweeps 3 through 7, and mostly small.

Also agree with Neal--for new chisels with decent steel and low price, the choice is China.

Scott's approach of picking up vintage gouges and rehandling them, is the low dollar/high quality way to go. But it's not low price if you count your own time--because to blunt-grind a set of old gouges back to square shoulders and then start over bevelling and honing them is real work.

I looked around the web--the value proposition on new/western made is Pfeil at Woodcraft--provided you can get free shipping-- because you will pay tax. I checked prices on 3sweep/6-8mm, results as follows:

Pfeil (Swiss Made)..........$26.10 (Woodcraft, sole source), but note my comment above on tax + shipping.

Lamp (German brand).... 34.00 (Woodcarver's Supply)

Ashley Iles.................... 34.95 (TFWW)

Two Cherries................. 38.64 (TFWW)

NOTE: Joel at TFWW has a pretty good proposition on Ashley Iles, where you can pick your own set (6 or more) and get 10% off. That's a way better deal than buying a set, for reasons Scott stated. You end up at $30 per gouge, so that is second best on price, but Joel's customer service is absolutely great. Woodcraft says their free shipping deal ends tomorrow, but maybe they could be reasoned with on the phone.

Wiley

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#7

Listen to Scott,he nailed it!!

Bob Hackett

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#8

Round handles you say?

Bob Hackett

So carve a flat on one(or more) face to keep them from rolling.

MB

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#9

Re: Carving chisels/sets

Kevin Adams

Warren, just out of curiosity, what carving tools do you have? When you say the exact ones are available today, do you know if the quality is the same? Of course, you may not have had any need to look at any new tools since you strike me as someone who can do a lot more with a lot less than many of us...

Thanks.

Kevin

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#10

Re: Carving chisels/sets

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use Henry Taylor tools and I have bought them at various times over the last thirty years, most recently in 2008. They seem just the same. The steel has that same feel on the stone. I would be pretty sick if they changed the steel. It could be that the finish work (grinding) is nicer than formerly.

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#11

Thanks, Warren.

Kevin Adams

Re: Carving chisels/sets

#13

Sets can be good if you don't get carried away *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Some sets are great, usually smaller sets. For example, the set from Takahashi that I bought on ebay at great savings. I use every one of this set to great advantage, and knew I would the moment I saw it; and while they are available individually (I've bought several additional chisels from Takahashi one at a time), I'd never have known his work without that first small set on ebay.

I guess I'm willing to admit being a chump sometimes and that it depends on who's making the set and the selection. When I started carving, I bought a very small set of Pfeil's from the local Woodcraft. I thought it well comprised for shallow reliefs on furniture, a good price, and recommended by a salesperson who carved a lot.

Most of my chisels did not arrive in sets, and I made one huge mistake buying a set of bench chisels, so you must be careful; but don't not buy a set because you think it's not cool. If necessary, you can hide the boxes and mix up the sets when another woodworker comes to visit. :)

Pam


Takahashi carving chisel set