Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

Posts

Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#1

Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

wilbur

>I had brought this up in another forum discussion, in a different context, but I thought it would be good food for thought here.

In Chris Schwarz and Joel Moskowitz's new book, The Joiner and Cabinet Maker, one of my big take home messages was that it shows that relatively few tools are needed to be able to make projects. According to a post on Chris Schwarz's blog, here's a list of the tools that are used in the book, and to put things in perspective, the last project that the apprentice makes is a chest of drawers.

Marking & Measuring Tools

- Try square

- Chalk line

- 2' Folding rule

- Marking gauge

- Panel gauge

- Wooden straightedge

- Marking knife

Saws

- Handsaw

- Sash saw

- Dovetail saw

- Bowsaw

Planes

- Jack plane

- Trying plane

- Smoothing plane

- Rabbet plane

- Plow plane

Other Tools

- Bench chisels

- 1/4" Mortising chisel

- Mallet

- Hammer

- Nailset

- Bradawl

- Brace and bits

- Turnscrew

- File

- Steel plate (for clinching and straightening nails)

You also need a sharpening system of some sort.

Now, of the tools on this list, one could argue that the only ones you need to be high quality are the trying plane (jointer), smoothing plane, rabbet plane, and plow plane. Just as an example, if we get a trying plane, smoother, and a rabbet plane from Clark and Williams, that's a total of $985. The Lee Valley Veritas small plow plane (sorry, Larry and Don) is $225, which brings the total to $1210. You could add sash saw and dovetail saw onto the high end tool list if you're not clever enough to start with an inexpensive Japanese saw. ;) Add in a Wenzloff dovetail and tenon saw, and the Gramercy Tools bow saw for those who insist on using western saws, and that's another $460, for a grand total of $1670 in quality out of the box tools. If you wanted some quality chisels, that might be another $300 for four bench chisels and a 1/4" mortise chisel, which still brings the total to under $2000 in high-falutin' tools. Everything else on the list you can get at the borg, and be fine with it.

Now consider our friends who use electron burning tools. I don't think anyone would argue that a typical power tool setup would look much different than this:

- Table saw

- Bandsaw

- Jointer

- Planer

- Drill press

- Router

- Random orbital sander

If you're shopping for this list of tools, you can easily hit the $2000 mark, even with budget versions of these tools from the Grizzly catalog. And you'll still need some hand tools.

Maybe at this point I've drunk too much of the Kool-Aid, but here's the thing that I've been pondering over. No one ever seems to balk at the idea that spending $2000 on low end power tools is an outrageous sum of money, yet there seems to be this consistent feeling that a similar price for a collection of high end hand tools is out of line. I'm not sure why that is.

What puzzles me lately is that it seems like the typical reaction from the average woodworker goes something like this:

"I need a tablesaw."

"You can get a budget contractor tablesaw from Grizzly for $635, plus shipping."

"Okay. Maybe I'll look at their closeout model cabinet saw which is only about $200 more."

"I need a smoothing plane."

"You can get a completely phenomenal smoother from Larry Williams for $315. It will handle the gnarliest grain without tearout, due to its excellent construction and high bedding angle."

"Are you kidding me?!??!"

========

I want to be clear that I am assuming that one has a couple of thousand dollars in their woodworking start up budget. I am fully aware that if you can't shell out $2000 for tools, you can't shell out $2000 for tools. I am also completely aware that you can get used hand tools for much less as well. And I am also aware that few people don't decide to get into woodworking and spend $2000 right off the bat. I sure didn't do that, but eventually I hit that mark relatively easily, even with buying off of Craigslist and eBay.

But if you are of the mind that it's reasonable to spend $2000 on low end power tools, why does spending the same amount on high end hand tools seem like such an outlandish thing to do?

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#2

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power

Brent Smith in Montreal

>I think there are a few reasons for it.

Our society has become one of 'get it done fast, and get it done cheap'.

We're also quickly becoming comfortable with planned obsolescence......we know that buying cheap items will mean that chances are that in a few years, if not sooner, we'll be shelling out for a replacement or upgrade. Perfect for the person that's not sure how deep he/she wants to get into the hobby.

NYW was many peoples introduction to woodworking, and Norm was a power tool kinda guy. People saw first hand how to operate wwing machines and power tools, so are more comfortable going that route.

Hand tools on the other hand are a mystery to most people, and therefore something that they look at as being a purchase down the road.

Many people's only experiences with hand tools are with low quality Borg purchases. If you've only used a piece of junk plane it would seem extravegent to spend so much on a quality tool thinking 'how much better could it be'.

And then there are some, like a good buddy of mine, who think anything without a tail is some kind of netherworld demon ;) .

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#3

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power

David Churnega

>Do not spend money for expensive chisels or saws. Saws maybe later.

Ask for advice on the particular tool your looking for and if available arrive early at local flea markets. I paid $1.00 for a lot of my favorite chisels and $20 for some of my best planes. All the tools on that list are not needed initially.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#4

Can't blame it all on Norm (little long)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My father was working on our house, and some furniture-ish items, pretty well from the time they bought it in 1946. He was an awe-inspiring (and sometimes a little scary) wonder with a skilsaw - it was from him that I learned how to cut a rabbet with a skilsaw - but had very little knowledge of hand tools. A few years before he died, I went down to the house with a little list of projects, one of which was planing down a door that was sticking at the top. He couldn't believe I planned to do it with a hand plane, said it couldn't be done. Three minutes, of course; it almost took me longer to get the iron setting right than to do the planing.

There was a whole trend following World War II toward power tools. There were some market reasons for this, I suspect; the war left a lot of excess production capacity in the companies that were already making or could switch to making power tools. There were technological-evolution reasons. If you've ever hefted a pre-WWII 1/4" drill and compared it with the lightweight drills available after the war, you've seen an example of this evolution. Finally, there was a huge boom in home ownership after the war, which meant home repair; I suspect a lot of people had grown up with insufficient exposure to hand tool knowledge, and power tools promised competence out of the box (falsely, of course - any tool requires skill).

My dad was part of these social factors.

The trends have continued. Norm was an expression of the trend, not the trigger for it, although this sort of social trend consists of interwoven feedback loops, so he did contribute to it.

The counter-trend has been going on just about as long. In addition to the post-war trends above, there was a renewal of the back-to-the-land movement after the war. If you read the literature of the period, you can see it's a combination of nostalgia for a lost time, desire for somewhere peaceful after the horrors of the war, and the same kind of desire to return to physical roots that leads to my screeching stops at every garage sale that might have tools. Many intro to woodworking books in the 50s continued to sing the song that mastery of hand tools was necessary to understanding wood.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#5

Re: Can't blame it all on Norm (little long)

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Interesting post Bill. I hadn't thought of it going that far back. I do remember a show on local TV here in the late sixties, the craftsman being in his 50's to 60's himself, that promoted hand tool use over power tools in it's early years. Later in the seventies the show was taken over by a younger craftsman (Jon Eakes) and it started leaning more towards power tool usuage. This would jive with your thoughts on the matter.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#6

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power

John Aniano in Central NJ

>David and Wilbur,

I can't agree more - if you have access to flea markets, they are the way to go to get old, well-made quality hand tools for not much $$. Yes, I've paid 100's of dollars (each) for a very few hand tools - mostly for some English collectibles. Most of what I use regularly I got for maybe $50 or less each. Wilbur, you have been to the CRAFTS auction - you have seen the prices, maybe a bit more than at a flea market, but often reasonable.

I personally don't really enjoy using newer hand tools. There is something visceral in using an older tool that may have had many owners, many uses, many "lives". I know it sounds corny, but that is how I feel.

I attended a NJ woodworking show a few years back and was convinced to buy a wonderful LN dovetail saw. It was a beauty, cut well, straight, nice handle, etc. I sold it (at a loss) at CRAFTS the next year since it wasn't the saw that I chose to pick up. THAT saw was a ca. 1890 Groves and Sons, English saw that I got and fixed up myself. I think I paid ~$20 for it. (I'll be bringing it to the Somerset show on Saturday.) Both saws cut well, but I preferred the older tool.

I think the process of restoring an old tool to new use also endears it to the current owner. One invests time and effort to bring it back. I once found a boxwood coffin smoother, signed and dated, as part of a "country" lamp someone made from the tool. I took pity on it, fitted a new blade, closed up the throat and fitted the wedge properly. It was resurrected from a potential life as a lamp. A lamp!

I'm just crazy I guess.

John

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#7

More bang, never mind the bucks!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Try this link ...... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p60JKvk97O8 ... and tell me if you feel better or worse about your handtools....

Mmmm .... my scrub plane doesn't do it like this ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgWwpCkyUYI&feature=related

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#8

More bucks for the buck

Bill Tindall

>A bench and associated bench hardware should be added to your cost list.

I quick count of stuff in the house and I came up with 33 pieces of furniture, counting the kitchen cabinets as one item for example, and I didn't counts simple things like cutting boards, wooden ware and stuff made on the lathe. Additionally, there are many items I have made for others. If you are making stuff that you would otherwise need to buy from someone else it is straightforward to justify what is spent on the tools to make stuff.

I think most people buying power tools believe they are buying them to make stuff (although a good fraction never achieve this goal as evidence by the used too market). When you have in your mind that this $3000 saw (lets think first class) is going to enable $10,000 of stuff to be made the purchase become easy to rationalize. And Norm makes the rationalization seductively easy.

Many people's cell phone, TV , and internet costs over time would easily equip a power or hand tool shop.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#9

Re: More bucks for the buck

Tom MacGregor

>I use machinery for most of the grunt work because my arthritic hands (hadn't planned on that while still in my 50's) will only take so much before I've got to stop. My machines are all funky stylized 40's & 50's era pieces, bought at salvage and restored. My hand tools, which I dearly love to use, provide me with a quiet almost meditative experience as I use them for fit & finish work. 95% of them are used/vintage/antique. There are things hand tools do more efficiently, there are things that my loud dusty machines do more efficiently - providing me with the ability to use my hand tools. If you want bang for the buck learn how to fix and tune stuff, powered or not. There's a lot of cheap used hardware out there waiting to go back to work.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#10

envious of those with flea markets

Chris Friesen

>I live in the Canadian prairies. There are no flea markets that sell tools, and no used tools of any sort regularly available. The odd time something shows up it's invariably junk. On the other hand, there is a Lee Valley less than 10 minutes drive away....it's awfully tempting to go new when the alternative is to buy used tools sight unseen and pay often significant shipping costs.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#11

Most are in your position

Bill Tindall

>I get to a few flea markets each year around the country. I see lots of wrenches and the like but I don't see the woodworking tools for sale that others claim to find, or is it has found. If I had to rely on buying used hand tools from flea markets I wouldn't be doing much woodworking.

I suspect it is the same problem common to all things collectible. Almost anything worthwhile gets collected and removed from circulation shortly after it is recognized that XXX is collectible. This stuff now sits amassed in someone's collection of 20 of this and 10 of that.

For the most part people don't collect Delta Unisaws so a good used Unisaw is, in my experience, much easier to find that a quality 1/2" chisel that isn't pitted.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#12

Re: Most are in your position

David Churnega

>I must confess to hoarding some tools found in flea markets. It seems the closer you live to the east coast the more productive flea market shopping is.

I have sold most of my power tools out of economic neccessity and now am forced to use the hand tools I have accumulated.

I made a new awl on the one tool I kept, a 1947 lathe. Will use new one and keep SW one as a collector. But I have way too many planes which I know now can be made to act like the expensive ones.

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#13

I know this is supposed to be about hand tools

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>but that has got to be the best planner guard I've ever seen !!

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#14

Re: I know this is supposed to be about hand tools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>You know Ian, I put that link up because that workshop may be a wet dream to many, but it represents the very opposite of everything I want. That is not to say that I do not recognise that machines have an important role. Handtoolers on the whole enjoy the journey and the personal effort and direct involvement afforded by handtools. The idea that one adds computers to woodworking machines in a hobby shop is just so pointless ... and I suspect that the members of this forum are equally immersed in this culture that they take that thought for granted.

Incidentally, I gather that the (ex-) owner of that shop is a very wealthy man who built a new home and had an brain spasm, deciding that it would be fun to build some of his own cabinets. So he had this workshop built, with only the best tools (all chosen by specialists). By the time it was in he was bored with the idea, and put it up for sale. And you know what? It was purchased lock stock and barrel by another person with the same idea! I wonder if history will repeat itself. Amazing machinery, nevertheless.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#15

Different mind sets

Bob Hackett

>The way I see it is those type of machines are geared toward somebody who wants/needs minimal involvement with both the material and/or the finished product.The focus is speed.

As a person who worked a 40+ hour week using production type machinery only to come home, slow down and work the same material(mostly metal) with simple tools that allowed far more creativity I can say that for me it was about establishing a connection with my chosen medium(wood,metal or stone) and getting to know both the material`s and my own capabilities and limitations.

When under the time clock everything becomes a commodity,the material,time,your skills,etc.I have never been able to understand why someone would want to bring that mind set home with them.

When at the house my focus has always been doing the best job I possibly can and stretching my skills.A long time back I used to have a clock in my shop(for about 2 weeks).It got heaved in the cove once I realized how many times I was looking at it instead of the work.

Now the only connection with time(and efficiency) I have comes from a radio announcer.

MB

Re: Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool

#16

I sort of guessed

Ian in Sydney

it was the jointer's safety fence that impressed me not it's size or power or the speed with which it can turn a very nice piece of bird's eye maple into dust.

I tend to agree with you and Bob Hackart (did I spell that correctly)

far too much pressed steel and cast iron and potential noise for my taste.