Hand tools: more bang for the buck than power tool
wilbur
>I had brought this up in another forum discussion, in a different context, but I thought it would be good food for thought here.
In Chris Schwarz and Joel Moskowitz's new book, The Joiner and Cabinet Maker, one of my big take home messages was that it shows that relatively few tools are needed to be able to make projects. According to a post on Chris Schwarz's blog, here's a list of the tools that are used in the book, and to put things in perspective, the last project that the apprentice makes is a chest of drawers.
Marking & Measuring Tools
- Try square
- Chalk line
- 2' Folding rule
- Marking gauge
- Panel gauge
- Wooden straightedge
- Marking knife
Saws
- Handsaw
- Sash saw
- Dovetail saw
- Bowsaw
Planes
- Jack plane
- Trying plane
- Smoothing plane
- Rabbet plane
- Plow plane
Other Tools
- Bench chisels
- 1/4" Mortising chisel
- Mallet
- Hammer
- Nailset
- Bradawl
- Brace and bits
- Turnscrew
- File
- Steel plate (for clinching and straightening nails)
You also need a sharpening system of some sort.
Now, of the tools on this list, one could argue that the only ones you need to be high quality are the trying plane (jointer), smoothing plane, rabbet plane, and plow plane. Just as an example, if we get a trying plane, smoother, and a rabbet plane from Clark and Williams, that's a total of $985. The Lee Valley Veritas small plow plane (sorry, Larry and Don) is $225, which brings the total to $1210. You could add sash saw and dovetail saw onto the high end tool list if you're not clever enough to start with an inexpensive Japanese saw.
Add in a Wenzloff dovetail and tenon saw, and the Gramercy Tools bow saw for those who insist on using western saws, and that's another $460, for a grand total of $1670 in quality out of the box tools. If you wanted some quality chisels, that might be another $300 for four bench chisels and a 1/4" mortise chisel, which still brings the total to under $2000 in high-falutin' tools. Everything else on the list you can get at the borg, and be fine with it.
Now consider our friends who use electron burning tools. I don't think anyone would argue that a typical power tool setup would look much different than this:
- Table saw
- Bandsaw
- Jointer
- Planer
- Drill press
- Router
- Random orbital sander
If you're shopping for this list of tools, you can easily hit the $2000 mark, even with budget versions of these tools from the Grizzly catalog. And you'll still need some hand tools.
Maybe at this point I've drunk too much of the Kool-Aid, but here's the thing that I've been pondering over. No one ever seems to balk at the idea that spending $2000 on low end power tools is an outrageous sum of money, yet there seems to be this consistent feeling that a similar price for a collection of high end hand tools is out of line. I'm not sure why that is.
What puzzles me lately is that it seems like the typical reaction from the average woodworker goes something like this:
"I need a tablesaw."
"You can get a budget contractor tablesaw from Grizzly for $635, plus shipping."
"Okay. Maybe I'll look at their closeout model cabinet saw which is only about $200 more."
"I need a smoothing plane."
"You can get a completely phenomenal smoother from Larry Williams for $315. It will handle the gnarliest grain without tearout, due to its excellent construction and high bedding angle."
"Are you kidding me?!??!"
========
I want to be clear that I am assuming that one has a couple of thousand dollars in their woodworking start up budget. I am fully aware that if you can't shell out $2000 for tools, you can't shell out $2000 for tools. I am also completely aware that you can get used hand tools for much less as well. And I am also aware that few people don't decide to get into woodworking and spend $2000 right off the bat. I sure didn't do that, but eventually I hit that mark relatively easily, even with buying off of Craigslist and eBay.
But if you are of the mind that it's reasonable to spend $2000 on low end power tools, why does spending the same amount on high end hand tools seem like such an outlandish thing to do?



