Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Shoulder plane machining advice needed

Posts

Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#1

Shoulder plane machining advice needed

CJ in MPLS

>How would you go about opening the mouth on a shoulder plane casting? I've got access to a mill and have a basic set of end mills at my disposal. I've squared the sides and bottom and have a partial bed milled (my mills are too short to reach all the way through). At present there is about 1/8" between the current sole and the current bed, i.e. they don't intersect.

The question I have is whether I should cut the mouth through the sole of the casting now and then mill off the material until the bed and sole intersect or simple keep removing material until the mouth is exposed. The latter doesn't seem like a very good idea, but I'm not certain about how to go about cutting the mouth. A hacksaw seems to simple but may be the answer.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#2

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

James Watriss

>Do you have a picture or something that would help us visualize?

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#3

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Seems like either one would work, if you've got the material in the body to keep removing sole until the mouth appears.

The other alternative seems to be hacksawing through the body in front of the line of the mouth, then filing the last bit of mouth to be in plane with the milled part. That would test your filing skills, for certain.

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#4

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

Craig D

>A mill or hacksaw both work. When I did my shoulder planes, I used a hacksaw to open the mouth. The trick was to cut on the ramp so that the blade doesn't fit through the mouth (I used a one piece sole). THEN use a needle file to get the opening you want. With a shoulder plane, it should be pretty straight forward to flip it over and mill from the bottom (since you can see the ramp to line things up). Expect a bit of spring when you make the cut.

For the low angle smoothers I've been making, I don't want a split sole, so machining the sole is much like that of a shoulder plane. Here, I've cut the ramp on the mill and then used a 1/16" end mill to cut a slot. Again, being very careful to make sure the mouth opening is less than zero. I'll open it up with a file when the plane has been assembled.


img

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#5

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

CJ in MPLS

>Since I don't have an online repository for the jpg I drew, a work picture will have to suffice. Hopefully I'm up to the task. ;)

I have a St. James Bay bullnose plane bronze casting. I've squared up the sides to the base on the Bridgeport here at work. The problem I'm having is trying to determine how to proceed from here as I don't want to end up with a too-large mouth.

Looking at the side of the casting with the bullnose on the right, the rough surface of the bed forms an angle of about 25* to the flattened sole. A triangle formed by the bed and the sole extends to the edge of the plane formed by the front and the sole of the casting. This triangle extends as far forward as it does because the sole of the casting is about 3/16" too thick. This extra thickness must be removed to get the bed of the casting to intersect the sole at the location where the mouth should be.

I am trying to determine whether I should do one of the following:

1) Cut a slot into the sole of the casting that extends from the sole to the bed. This slot will be perpendicular to the sole. The bed will be cleaned up (file and/or mill) so that the intersection of the slot with the bed is a line that is parallel to the sole of the casting. The overly thick sole of the casting would then be wasted until the blade can protrude from the mouth.

or

2) Clean up the bed and rear surface of the bull nose that intersects with the bed and waste away the overly thick sole until the mouth is exposed.

I had thought of making a cut with a slitting saw to extend the bed, but not only would the cut be difficult to start (would need a perpendicular relief cut I believe), but the dimension of the slitting saw on the perpendicular might be too wide, thereby resulting in an initial mouth that is too large.

I've been having fun with this project, but it galls me to learn just how much of my mechanical engineer's training has been forgotten.

Any thoughts?

CJ

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#6

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've been working on a St James Bay casting for a while now, and I cut the mouth with a series of small drill holes and then filed them out. The raw mouth is smaller than the finished dimensions, so careful filing will take me where I want to go. The infill is wenge, which I won't do again. It is evil, or maybe just the piece I got. Pores too big and all that.

I did all the prep work by hand, including scraping the sole. Just wish I'd had access to a mill at first. It would have been faster and the sides would have been substantially more square.

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#7

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

ThomD

The SJB planes are hard to mill because the sides are already in place and obstruct milling. Home shop machinist or Practical Machinist did a series on how to mill these planes, but I didn't catch it at the time so I don't know what they recommended.

Seems to me the simplest way to expand the mouth is just to put the plane on angle on the table and mill away the ramp with an endmill, this appears to be what they do on the finish machined castings (which are/were a far better value even if you have a mill). The problem with that approach is fixturing the plane at 45 deg. etc..., and getting enough extension on the cutter. It is relatively easy to make one's own long shank cuter if one can silver solder and already has a mill. Just mill a 1/8" slot in the end of some rod and silver solder in a chunk of HSS. Soldering will not affect the temper of the HSS.

Fixturing is going to depend on how much versatility and what size of planes one wants. A blockplane could just be held in a vise...

The second method that occurs is using a cutter a bit liike a countersink to cut the hole with the plane more or less square to the table and the quick in vertical position. More complex toolmaking required.

Another method that might work is to cant the mill head, if your mill head cants. This will make fixturing and body a snap, but after the first cut is taken you will have to re-index the bit for every higher cut on the ramp. Many small shop guys don't like taking the head at an angle since getting it back square takes about an hour with conventional methods.

Another option would be to open the mouth from the underside, then machine the ramp down to mouth hole with a shaper.

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#8

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

CJ in MPLS

Bruce:

I just got my hands on a slotting saw that is about 1/16" wide. Between this and a long mill, I'm hoping to get about 90% of the mouth milled out before I have to clean up with a file.

Wenge looks kind of neat, even with the pores, but it is second to none when it comes kicking off a runny nose and red eyes for me. I have a small box made from it that I've allowed to languish as I cannot bring myself to finish it. Even with the dust foe mask and the air cleaner, I'm streaming in about 10 minutes.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

#9

Re: Shoulder plane machining advice needed

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Great find on the slotting saw. That should ease milling the mouth significantly.

Re the wenge. I'm not a patient kinda guy and Woodcraft was out of rosewood and cocobolo when I was selecting wood for the infill. Wenge was really the only other choice. Since the infill is essentially done except for the final sanding and polishing, I'll just go with that. I guess filling is the key to a successful finish. So first I have to learn to fill. It's always something...

I've not had problems with it so far, but walnut is a huge problem for me. I'm very reactive to it. We'll see.