Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

shoulder vs bullnose plane

Posts

shoulder vs bullnose plane

#1

shoulder vs bullnose plane

Rick Snyder

>Hello,

What is the difference between a shoulder plane and a bullnose plane with regard to their use. I know on the bullnose plane the front can be removed to get into corners. If you have one of them, do you need the other generally speaking?

Thanks, Rick

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#2

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

Neal in San Jose

>As always when choosing a tool, it depends on what you are going to do, what results are you looking for, and what methods are you comfortable/adept at. I have several shoulder planes, most of which are convertable to bullnose, and I have only taken the noses off a few of times, and generally that was only to see if it worked! If I'm working into a corner, I will reach for a chisel. Much handier than a bullnose plane IMHO is a cranked chisel. I think the proof is on ebay. See how much a Stanley #90 bullnose goes for compared to a #92 shoulder.

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

>You can clean up shoulders with a bullnose plane but the shoulder plane is much better at it. I can't remember the last time I used a bullnose plane,while I use my shoulder plane almost every day.---Jack

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#4

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>A shoulder plane is used for surfacing the shoulder of a tenon. It differs from the bullnose plane in that it has a long nose that ensures that the plane lies (registers) flat/parallel to the surface.



A bullnose plane may resemble a shoulder plane (without a nose) but it has nothing to do with shoulders at all. It should not go anywhere near a shoulder ... unless you have a death wish for the joint since it cannot register parallel with the surface since it lacks a nose (it sort-of can be use on a tenon shoulder by planing from the inside out ... but then you run the risk of creating breakout at the ends).


A bullnose plane is used for planing as near to the edge of a rebate end as you can get.

But do not confuse the bullnose plane (as some do ;) ) with a chisel plane. A chisel plane has no nose or mouth, just a bare blade. It can plane right up against the end of a rebate (or anything else), but the complete lack of a mouth increases the risk of the blade digging into the work surface.



The bullnose is a bit of a compromise here - it cannot get as close, but it does have a mouth to prevent digging in.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#5

Followup question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Derek,

Excellent post, especially the part about registration, which the shoulder plane has and the bullnose doesn't.

Followup Question: What is your experience in using the Veritas bullnose as a chisel plane? I have tried removing the nosepiece from the Stanley 90-93 series and using them as a chisel plane, and it worked in a marginal way, but didn't have enough length of sole behind the blade to be very satisfactory. But the Veritas appears to be a far better piece of machining than my Stanley 90 series.

I don't have a bullnose anymore, and am not missing it. From time to time, however, I do need my 97.5 chisel plane (as in your last photo), for planing right up to an obstruction--doesn't happen much but was essential for me a couple of times. For example, in making a Krenov type case with the projecting V door(s), planing the backside of the rails that establish the V required a chisel plane with a good length of sole behind the blade. Like Neal, I prefer to use a cranked chisel, but in that case the plane was more effective.

Wiley

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#6

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

David Churnega

>Get both.

Get the No 92 first

Stanley No 90's generally go for $30 on ebay.

Just my .02

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#7

Re: Followup question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Followup Question: What is your experience in using the Veritas bullnose as a chisel plane? I have tried removing the nosepiece from the Stanley 90-93 series and using them as a chisel plane, and it worked in a marginal way, but didn't have enough length of sole behind the blade to be very satisfactory. But the Veritas appears to be a far better piece of machining than my Stanley 90 series.

Hi Wiley

I do not have a bullnose plane! I had a Stanley #90 but, after it had lain unused on a shelf for about 5 years, I sold it. I still have a Stanley #93 shoulder plane, and have tried this in chisel plane mode, but it is very uncomfortable in the hand, so that also does not get used. I have not used the Veritas Bullnose plane, so cannot comment.

For the type of use a bullnose may offer, I have tended to use chisels, often a large one held bevel down. Or a router plane.

There is an update to the bullnose situation. About a year (or more) ago I had some input on one of a set of Veritas Detail Rabbet Planes. These are now in the LV catalogue.


A set arrived yesterday. My first impression of the finished planes is that they are beautifully made (the catalogue picture does not dothem justice) and in useful sizes (1/4",5/16", 3/8"). I could really have used these when building the armoire. I anticipate their getting good use. I will write up my experience after I have enough time under the belt.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#8

Re: Followup question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Those are beautiful, Derek and Rob; but why would anyone need more than one of them?

Pam

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#9

Re: Followup question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Pam

Clifton make a similar plane, the 400, which is based on the Preston ...


This is 3/8" wide.

The plane I received from LV for evaluation was also 3/8" wide. One of my comments was that I would have found more use for a 1/4" version, since this could fit inside a 1/4" groove (and larger), the most frequently-used groove size for drawers and boxes. A year went by and, lo-and-behold, there is a set in different sizes. Clearly LV had a master plan and I unwittingly ticked one of the boxes. The sizes chosen do represent the common sizes for grooves/dados.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#10

Can't speak to the Veritas

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I have a Record bullnose, have tried using it as a chisel plane once, and have gone back to using an actual chisel, bevel down, when I need it. The Record nosedived like mad, even in sweet grain, and is too small for pressure on the back end to overcome the tendency.

This is, by the way, wandering a bit off topic, a moderately late model of plane, and I wouldn't have bought it if I could time-travel and point out to my earlier self that the mouth is huge, even with the shims taken out. It is an improvement on my modified Stanley 75, but I wish Record had built it with a smaller mouth.

It may be that the earlier Record bullnose planes are better - this is the first such plane I'd ever actually held in my hand.

I don't find I've used it enough to motivate me to go buy a Veritas, although, money no limit, that does seem to be the best design out there.

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#11

Re: Followup question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I see, using them for grooving. Well, why not? Think I'll stick with the 043/044 since I already have them.

I have the LN original small shoulder plane that looks a lot like the Clifton/Preston, use it fairly often. Only problem is the wedge is very sensitive to humidity, plain won't seat properly in summer.

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#12

Re: Followup question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I see, using them for grooving. Well, why not? Think I'll stick with the 043/044 since I already have them.

I have the LN original small shoulder plane that looks a lot like the Clifton/Preston, use it fairly often. Only problem is the wedge is very sensitive to humidity, plain won't seat properly in summer.

Hi Pam

I may have conveyed the wrong impression. The detail rabbet planes are not to create grooves or dados, but to tune them. I'd include rebates here as well - which is why I thought of them. There were a number of instances I could have used a plane like these on the armoire.I did have the Veritas Small Shoulder plane (1/2" blade), which was a great help. I have a couple of other projects to do first, but I will aim to create a review/pictorial of how these planes may be used.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: shoulder vs bullnose plane

#13

Re: Followup question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, I understood that, guess I find the grooves created with the 043/044 are sufficiently tuned, probably have lower standards than you. :)

Pam