Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Japanese scribing gouge...

Posts

Japanese scribing gouge...

#1

Japanese scribing gouge...

John Aniano in central NJ

>Hello All,

I wish to purchase a second Japanese scribing gouge - the ~1-1/4" wide version. It has a bevel on the inside (ground straight across) and is basically a short in-cannel gouge. The Japan Woodworker was where I got my last one - are there any other vendors out there that might have a less expensive version?

Thanks,

John

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#2

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi John,

Here is what a quick check reveals. These chisels are also called "sotomaru-nomi":

JWW....Iyoroi 1-1/4" scribing gouge ........ $ 68.50

Hida Tool...Imai 30mm sotomaru.............$140.70

You might check with Harrelson at JapaneseTools, as his website doesn't show many of his offerings.

Suggest check with Joel, at Tools for Working Wood. Joel carries Japanese tools, but his website doesn't show scribing gouges. But he is always worth a call, as he might be able to obtain one for you.

In my experience, JWW is usually the low-cost option, so you are unlikely to beat their deal at $68.50 for a new tool. There were no scribing gouges on ebay.

What are you using these tools to do?? I'm really interested.

Wiley

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#3

Re: Japanese scribing gouge... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Depends on how you define cheaper. I use Takahashi carving chisels, which are available from Tomohito-san at Iida Tools; but I also use the old English carving tools like Addis and Herring, available everywhere (32 Addis auctions on ebay right now), as well as Dastra. I truly don't think you can go wrong, even if you pay for a custom chisel through Tomohito-san.

Pam


Iida tools

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#4

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

John Aniano in central NJ...

>Wiley and Pam,

I use an incannel gouge to scallop out the sides of bow frogs, the ebony piece near the player's hand. The frog sides are roughed out with a gouge and finished shaped with a file and sanded/polished with abrasive paper, etc.

I have a set of #3, #4, and #5 gouges of various makers that I also use for this purpose, so yes, Pam, I do like the English and American gouges made by firms such as Addis and Buck Bros. I usually sharpen them with an ~35 degree bevel and pushing this through ebony is a challenge. You can only take small bites, so...

I wish to try something different and put the chisel tang, without a handle, in a non-spinning drill press as the downward motive force to more quickly rough out ~2.5" long frog blanks, and still call it "by hand". Some makers rough out using a router-type tool, some use a sanding drum to achieve the same effect. I thought that a Japanese scribing chisel, being shorter and with a round tang, might be the best kind of chisel with which to try this idea. Certainly a conventional "tanged" gouge would work, but the tang would have to be modified in some fashion in order to fit well into the drill press chuck.

I'll eventually find a solution - I just don't want to ruin a good tool trying an idea that might not prove useful.

Thanks,

John

John

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#5

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>That sounds like a great experiment, bet it will work fine if you can hold the ebony firmly.

Pam

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#6

Another notion

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi John,

I was mulling over Pam's thought about the problem of holding the frog against the pressure....

What about using a spinning drill press, with a 1-1/4" sawtooth or Forstner bit. You would need a fixture consisting of a hardwood block, 2-1/2" deep, which would be clamped to the drill press table. Take this block and drill a 1-1/4" hole right through it--you use that hole for registering the fixture each time.

Then right adjacent to the 1-1/4" hole, you drill/chisel a slot into the block to hold the frog blank. This slot is situated so that the frog blank intersects the 1-1/4" hole by just the amount needed for the bit to come down and rough out the frog side. Drill one side; flip the frog blank around in the slot; drill the other side.

As I think more about it, the best way to do this would be in reverse order to that given above: make the slot first (the frog-blank holder), then drill the 1-1/4" registration hole so that it slightly overlaps the slot. If the frogs are not all the same dimension, the slot could be made variable by having a 'half slot', and using a horizontal clamp to hold the frog blank against the drilling pressure. That would enable the same roughing cut on blanks of slightly different dimension.

Could this work?

Wiley

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#7

Or, and I haven't thought this through

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>mount the work piece in a 4-jawed chuck (like a Nova chuck) on a lathe and lock it in place. Mount the chisel with a modified shank in a Jacobs chuck on the tailstock and advance it with the tailstock screw. A lot slower, to be sure...

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#8

Re: Another notion--Correction

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Wouldn't be a 1-1/4" drill--undoubtedly something larger. The drill radius would be whatever corresponds to the radius of the scribing gouge we were discussing.

Wiley

Re: Japanese scribing gouge...

#9

Many variables

Bob Hackett

>If I understand correctly we`re talking about a chord,which is a straight line thru two points in an arc.

If this is correct then the diameter of the drill would depend on things like the width and sweep of the chisel wouldn`t it?

A 1-1/4" chisel could correspond to any number of diameter drills depending on the sweep.

MB