Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Book research... Does anybody remember?

Posts

Book research... Does anybody remember?

#1

Book research... Does anybody remember?

James Watriss

>So, I'm in the middle of writing a section on benches, in a book aimed at new guys. The general message I'm trying to get across is not to get to worked up over your first bench. And I remember some poor guy who came in here years ago and posted a picture of his design for his first bench that was almost C-shaped, with a shoulder vise in the opening, and pretty much one of every other kind of vise on the various corners.

I remember everyone rushing in to try to talk him down, but I can't find the original entry... trying to get my hands on that picture. Does anyone else remember that thread? Or have any suggestions on how to find it? (There are so many bench threads in here...)

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#2

Re: Book research...Thom can help, I think

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Yeah, I remember. The poster was a German fellow who used excellent graphics. I would guess maybe three years ago.

I can't think of unique keywords that would find the thread in the archives. 'Bench' brings up hundreds of pages.

I seem to recall that Thom had a lengthy dialogue in that thread with the poster. The discussion got very detailed. It might be that Thom can recall a keyword or two that would enable a 'rifle shot' into the archives to find that thread.

Wiley

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#3

Re: Book research...Thom can help, I think

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I told the fellow that his bench with four vises reminded me of a car with four steering wheels. I thought it would be easy to search steering wheels, but it was not there. It does appear that July to December 2006 is missing from the archives.

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#4

Dirk Vogel's Bench

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>James, I was not able to find Dirk's original post, but there were some follow up posts on 10/26/2007. There is a link to a picture of his bench.

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#5

Re: Dirk Vogel's Bench *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>You've got a great memory, Warren!

Here is the link Warren is referencing (see below). The thread provides a link to a series of photos on Dieter Schmid's German Woodworking Forum.

Wiley


W/C posting on Dirk Vogel's workbench

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#6

Dirk Vogel's Bench

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>James, I could not find the original posts, but there were some follow up posts on 10/26/2007. Here is a link to a picture of Dirk's bench.

http://www.woodworking.de/cgi-bin/forum/webbbs_config.pl/read/28669

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#7

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

James Watriss

>Hmmm... I'll have to dig around some more when I have time.

The sketch he put up really burned into my mind as a singular example of all of the printed dogma about benches gone horribly awry in the absence of someone who should have provided a more grounded perspective. I remember feeling really bad for him, too... But it looks like the bench he did finish is a really gorgeous thing.

I really appreciate the work, guys... All my best.

James

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#8

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

VLParisian

>James, You must include the quote from Warren "like a car with four steering wheels". Well said.

Victor

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#9

Dirk's original drawing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>James, I think this is the drawing that Dirk first presented to us perhaps just what you are looking for. I hope the link works.


img

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#10

Another variation

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Here is another of Dirk's drawings, this one more "C shaped" as you mentioned. I think the picture of the partly finished bench reflects some of our influence.


img

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#11

Holy Cow! You did it?!

James Watriss

>You're the man, Warren.

And Victor, of course I'm going to quote Warren. (With his permission, of course...) How can I not... he found exactly what I'd been looking for, off and on, for almost a month.

Re: Book research... Does anybody remember?

#12

Re: Another variation

ThomD

>The tragedy is that we will never know how that bench might have turned out. It is a bit reminiscent of early NYW in which wood movement was not fully understood. I am happy that Dirk did come up with a bench he will doubtless enjoy. I also see he snagged a Veritas vice while the going was good.