Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

My purpose

Posts

My purpose

#1

My purpose

WoodburnBob

>I was thinking perhaps the maker might be a WC lurker, or have friends who were, and that he might be drawn out to talk more about his thoughts and choices in this effort of his. The Ebay text is pretty reasonable, as he admits it is a prototype and that he intended to put his own person choices into the design. I think his accomplishment is competently done and admirable.

I think the idea of using press fit, presumably hardened and precision ground, steel pins to join the sides to the sole is a creative and useful idea. It reminds me, in principle, of what SMT was showing us in his "loopy" a few years back. In execution, the loopy in effect had double pins; I never learned, that I recall, whether they were press fit or peened. My guess, being an SMT fan, is they were precision either way.

The Lazarus, I see, has a lateral adjustment and a frog advance screw. I don't think I've seen that degree of effort in too many craftsman made planes. How well they work in this first prototype is kinda irrelevant to me.

Many of my old 'Spiers and others' infills lean, not as severely, but like the Tower of Pizza. I imagine that the forces of the seasonally expanding wooden infill, with a lever arm of the height of the plane side, exceed the resistance of peened double dovetails. How much interference fit one actually gets all the way through a peened dovetail has always been a question in my mind. With a press fit pin, you'd presumably have the entire surface area of each pin holding the sides to the sole. How much calculated interference fit and how many tons of press force it takes to bring things together would be a great question for the maker. I still wouldn't know if wood expansion and contraction over time might exceed even that. Of couse the Lazarus absence of large side to side wedged in infills makes that moot. Was that involved in the maker's reasoning and design. I'm just curious. Yes, I might try it, when I'm messing around. But I have no plans of competing with anyone.

I much prefer the maker's unabashed use of socket screws to the slotted or Philips screws I see. I'd be interested to hear about the idea of a metal frog on top of a wood "infill" behind it. There are other mental/design elements I'd be interested in hearing about from the maker. And I'd like to see him share this with all of us. Sure, I can ping him privately.

The handle-tote does take looking at for awhile. It reminds me of a handgun more than a knife handle. But I've always noticed a similiarity between gripping a toted infill and gripping a big heavy handgun. I think his approach would largely solve the problem of all the breaking totes on infills. It could be adapted to any tote design, of course. It is amazing that so many craftsman and manufactures ran a huge wood screw up the old infill totes from the bottom, which guarantees that expansion and contraction forces will snap the infill tote just were it does always, or almost always, snap.

So, if the maker of the Lazarus is out there and listening, I'm supportive of your first efforts, and don't find your first try at plane making hideous at all. I think you did a very competent job at execution and I would imagine you will inevitably make design modifications if you don't get too put off or demoralized by the marketplace or the critics. Nice shavings, too, by the way.

Bob

Re: My purpose

#2

Re: The Lazarus

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Derek,

Have another look, it's not a refurbished stanley infill mod. (I don't know why Stanley 4 1/2" appears in the description?)

It's a scratch built smoother, some very interesting design details.... looks to be nicely executed.

Regards

Ray

Re: My purpose

#3

Last month

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Last month the same fellow sold a modified Stanley plane. Derek must have seen that one, not the present offering.