Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

Posts

Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#1

Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>I got this old Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw on Ebay as part of another purchase. The handle is butt ugly and just doesn't feel right. It's too big and made the saw feel off balance. I had always had it in the back of my mind to use it as sharpening practice and then sell it. But to be truthful, I want to try my hand at making a new handle for it. I even went as far as to buy a set of new saw nuts (as well as the saw nut driver) from TFWW.

Below you can see the saw next to the template I downloaded from TWFF's website. I printed it out full scale and have glued it to a piece of 1/8" luan. I plan to make at least three handles because I know I'll mess up at least one!

Dovetail Saw project

The blade reads "Keystone" and the saw nuts read "Warranted Superior". So I know this is no real pedigree saw, and therefore I have no fear of messing it up. For those interested, the blade (which I have haven't sharpened yet) looks to have 12tpi. I plan to keep it that way unless I get adventurous.

Here's a photo of the blade on top of the handle template. That'll give you an idea of the way the saw will look when completed. I had printed out the backsaw handle template, but decided to go with the dovetail style because I liked it's lines. I think this configuration looks OK. I'd love to hear what other think about it.

Dovetail Saw project

I have chosen to make the handles from lacewood, apple, and walnut. After getting the template cut to size, I surfaced the various boards in order to get them ready for resawing down to 1" thick. The plans call for 7/8", but I like to live myself some room in case I mess up while resawing.

Dovetail Saw project

Personally, I think that the apple will look the coolest, followed by the lacewood (anyone else here ever use that for a saw handle?). The walnut is nice but from my experience, it will look even better once it's shellaced and waxed.

I can tell you right now that this is going to be a long project. I will be working on this between some home projects that I'm involved with. So progress will be in spurts.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#2

Looks like fun

Bill Houghton

>I've noticed that dovetail saw handles tend to be installed with the hang line - the line 90 degrees from the grip - pointing at the very back corner of the blade, as yours is. Open grips are so very attractive.

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#4

Dominic in Bucks County PA

update: carcasss saw handle

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>After getting some pretty good input from a couple saw makers on another WWing forum, I have decided to use a carcass saw handle template as shown on TFWW's web site. This was recommended due to the 12 TPI tooth filing the saw presently has. It's really not a problem for me since the carcass saw handle is just as cool looking. And I've used Graymercy carcass saws and always liked the style handle.

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#5

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Marv

>Hi Dominic,

This may or may not be relavent. This was posted here on WC sometime last year. I apologize for not remembering the name of who did it. It represents quite an effort.

Marv



Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#6

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Great post, Marv! Looks like the saws were found at Bob Brode's site. But did he do the measurements?

Wiley

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#7

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Marv

>Wiley,

I really don't remember who did the work. Perhaps he who did it will come on and take credit for it. I found it was so interesting, I copied the images to my computer. If I recall, some of the discussion in the thread was about tapered backs. The consensus was, they were made that way.

Marv

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#8

Re: update: carcasss saw handle *LINK*

L. Hanson

>"I really don't remember who did the work. Perhaps he who did it will come on and take credit for it. I found it was so interesting, I copied the images to my computer. If I recall, some of the discussion in the thread was about tapered backs. The consensus was, they were made that way.

Marv"

That would have been Bob Brode, but I've seen nothing from him in several years... His site was members.brandx.net/websites/bbrode, but that's gone away some time ago.

Ray Gardiner has several images available on his site - look for the "Handle Templates" links on the lower right...

Leif


http://backsaw.net/

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#9

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Dean J in MN

>One minor flaw -- the hang angle is relative to the tooth-line, not the back. All of my backsaws have canted blades, and if I were to measure the hang from the back and from the toothline I'd arrive at very different numbers.

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#10

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Ray Gardiner

>I think it's time maybe to rethink hang angles in terms not just of angle to the tooth line, but where a line at right angles to the handle line intersects the tooth line. I suspect we will find a correlation between length of blade and hang angle.

MikeW could explain it better than I, but it has something to do with the arc of the arm while sawing..

Regards

Ray

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#11

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Dean J in MN

>I agree, that intersection is important. It also is tied to effective rake angles, different hangs end up with different usable rake angles.

This is one reason I find saw reviews silly, all you are doing is reviewing how someone decided to file the saw and match the hang and rake to make a smooth (or not so smooth) saw. Put a aggressive near zero rake with a "high" hang, heavy toe, and you are asking for a jumpy/grabby saw. Now, take the same rake and lower the hang or reduce toe weight and it will behave better. This all lies on a continuum, and everyone has their favourite pairing. For instance, I file my saws with rather aggressive rake, and for the most part my rip and panel saws are hung "low." This works very well for me, but in the hands of someone else my saws are very grabby/rough feeling. The difference, I don't put much, or any down-pressure on the saw, where the other sawyer tends to press down (actually more of a slight wrist rotation putting pressure on the top horn of the handle). His saws, which cut fast and smooth for him, feel nearly dull and ineffective in my hands. All of these things, rake, hang, toe weight, how you saw, etc are interlocked, so I may review a factory saw as painfully slow, whereas the next woodworker would claim it was "grabby." Unless you saw just like the reviewer there is no real useful data. And even if you do, and the review claims it is hard to start, or grabby -- fix it, you are going to have to file the saw when it gets dull anyway.

-Dean

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#12

Right on....Well stated.

Marv

>Hi Dean,

What you have explained in your post surely indicates that you have done a lot of saw filing, experimenting and using handsaws.

When discussing the issues you have covered, there are so many variables, it is difficult and sometimes even useless to talk specifics. Because of that, I completely agree with you regarding reviews of handsaws.

For someone like yourself with lots of saw experience and knowledge, you can make a saw perform to it's max and make it respond to your own personal needs.

For the present day saw maker, however, though most of them try their best, they just can't satisfy everyone. As you say, one sawyer thinks a saw cuts just fine, the next guy says it is grabby, the next guy says it cuts too slow. When filing a saw, it's all about angles. The angles we can control, but the variables among human beings is another issue.

I'm not sure how relevant this discussion is for Dominic and the handle he is making but if he files that saw perhaps it will be. As for the hang of his handle, it is best to error on the low side, not the high side. :)

Marv

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#13

Re: update: carcasss saw handle

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Marv,

Yeah, that's TOTALLY relevant! Thanks a ton for posting this!

Dominic

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#14

Can you explain alittle more

Bob Hackett

>You said it was better to be lower than higher in hanging if I read correctly.

Could you explain the mechanics more in depth and especially why it would be better to be a little too low rather than a little too high.

I thought you could correct either way thru modified filing is why I ask.

MB

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#15

Hang Angles

Ray Gardiner

>There are a lot a of variables in play here, but trying to simplify things, it seems to me that the hang angle, should be such that your index finger points towards somewhere around middle of the tooth line, if you follow this general argument then it seems logical that shorter saws will have higher hang angles, and longer saws would have lower hang angles, (I'm measuring the hang angle as angle between the line of the grip to a line at right angles to the tooth line) So a high hang angle is typically a small dovetail saw, and a low hang angle is typical of a normal handsaw. This is opposite to the way Bob Brode measured his angles.

The height of the workbench comes into it somewhere as well. With the natural arc of the arm and the wrong hang angle it's possible to get a kind of "overcenter" lock part way through the stroke.

I think for the most part all this stuff was understood and appreciated back in at least the early 1800's probably earlier, as time has passed a lot of knowledge has been lost.

Finally, I suspect that we tend to over analyse this stuff, it's more productive to work from the successful designs of the past.

Regards

Ray

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#16

Re: Can you explain alittle more

Marv

>Hi Bob,

Well, lets see, how can I explain too high or too low a hang...

Two main things effect hang....location of the handle up and down in relation to the toothedge and the angle of the hand grip, also in relation to the toothedge.

A third important issue, but not directly related to hang is, the height at which the work is in relation to one's body size and shape. I doubt very much that anyone would want to saw while reaching above their head or down at their knees. So somewhere in between is the sweet spot.

To demonstrate a handle that is too high, lets use some extremes.... imagine a handle that would locate the grip, say, 6" above the top of a 12" tenon saw, as an example. As you push forward, it easy to see in your mind's eye that the toe would nosedive and dig in no matter how the teeth are filed. Now imagine the handle located 6" below the bottom of the saw. The saw wouldn't feel right for sure, but you could, to some degree make it cut. When you consider these two extremes, you can see why it is better to error on a lower hanged handle.

On a regular handsaw, the hang is quite low compared to most backsaws. The hang is determined by having your forefinger pointing toward the center of the toe when your forefinger is on the side of the handle.

Ray is saying to point your forefinger toward the middle of the toothedge, halfway between the back end and the toe. This makes good sense because thats the general area of the toothedge that does most of the serious cutting and strikes a pretty good balance.

I agree with Ray, lets not be reinventing the wheel and just duplicate what the oldtimers no doubt spent many hours of trial and error to obtain a design that would be good for the average sawyer.

The pictures I posted in an above post, show how much the angle of the hand grip on different backsaws vary and compares those variences between an open handle and a closed handle. The angles are only valid if the back is parallel to the toothedge. If the back is tapered, the angle should be referenced off the toothedge. It would have been better to have measured all the saws off the toothedge.

Marv

Re: Disston/Keystone Dovetail saw project

#17

Thanks Marv and Ray

Bob Hackett

>I picked up a few back saws that had trashed or missing handles and after roughing the blanks I got to thinking about proper hang.

My first thought was to just match the hang to one of my better saws but then I overthought things(imagine that) and wondered if there was a way to improve the saw`s action by altering the hang angle depending on if the saw was filed rip or crosscut.

The quick tip of using the index finger to help set the hang was exactly what I had hoped for.I`ll see how that compares to my favorite saw and go from there.

Thanks again for the tip.

MB