Heiji saw
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi All,
Short version: Got a new saw. It's great. Unusual toothing.
Long version: I shared this info with Mike Wenzloff, sawmaker supremo. And thought maybe a few others would be interested. Incidentally, Mike's take is that what appears to be innovative sawtoothing, is virtually always 'rediscovery'--i.e., nothing new under the sun as far as handtools are concerned. I agree with Mike, but still.....
Couple months ago, my saw itch got to itching, so I contacted So Yamashita (Japan-Tool), and asked him to order a 240mm tatebiki (single edge rip). A while later, he got back to me, to relay a question from the sawmaker, Heiji: Did I want a standard tatebiki, or a diagonal-cutting hybrid version that had gotten a good initial response in Japan? Told him to go with the new one. The vendor, So, and I figured that this saw would involve some fleam, to give it some characteristics of a cross cut saw.
Couple weeks ago, the saw arrives from Japan. I have included a direct scan of a portion of the toothing, so you get the general shape of the teeth. I tried the saw out, rip to start with, and it was extremely smooth, in either a straight rip or a long miter cut (at a small angle to the grain). The maker had said it would be smooth, but at some expense of speed in a straight rip. I didn't notice any loss of speed, but then Heiji is a great sharpener. Just at a glance, the teeth had a lot of fleam, so I tested the saw in an ordinary crosscut, and it left smooth-as-glass faces on the end grain on either side (this was on satinwood cutoffs from a project), with no ragging or splintering. In other words, a fine crosscut.
I took some measurements of the toothing, to figure out what is making this saw work so well for rip, miter, and crosscut. Here is the data:
Basic: 240mm, 14-1/2 ppi
Included angle of tooth (and gullets as well).... 28 degrees
Rake: 11-1/2 to 12 degrees (forward, aggressive)
Fleam: 20 degrees
Top profile: Angle of tooth top, looking down the blade end to end, is 15-20 degrees. This top profile is established by a third facet, where the point of the tooth is filed down until the top slope is 15-20 degrees below horizontal. If this third 'over the shoulder' facet had not been used, the tooth point would have been much steeper, based on the 20 degrees of fleam and the acute included angle of the tooth. It would have been a straight crosscut saw.
The filing required 'sloping gullets', i.e., an upward filing motion. Heiji passed on that the saw is very hard, so be careful.
___
Comment: I pass this info. along to you saw filers out there, for whatever it may be worth to you. This saw's performance is stunning. It is this third facet--the filing on the back of the tooth to independently control the top profile--which makes this saw what it is.
As far as western equivalence, there has been some online discussion by Mike Wenzloff and Andrew Lunn, perhaps others, of unusual toothing styles. Lie Nielsen has gone to a graduated tooth back saw. Before that, Henry Disston's 1907 'Lumberman's Handbook' has some intriguing recommendations on how to modify the backside fleam to customize for hardwood, dry hardwood, etc. (though not in Disston's later editions of the same Handbook).
FYI.
Wiley





