Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Heiji saw

Posts

Heiji saw

#1

Heiji saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Short version: Got a new saw. It's great. Unusual toothing.

Long version: I shared this info with Mike Wenzloff, sawmaker supremo. And thought maybe a few others would be interested. Incidentally, Mike's take is that what appears to be innovative sawtoothing, is virtually always 'rediscovery'--i.e., nothing new under the sun as far as handtools are concerned. I agree with Mike, but still.....

Couple months ago, my saw itch got to itching, so I contacted So Yamashita (Japan-Tool), and asked him to order a 240mm tatebiki (single edge rip). A while later, he got back to me, to relay a question from the sawmaker, Heiji: Did I want a standard tatebiki, or a diagonal-cutting hybrid version that had gotten a good initial response in Japan? Told him to go with the new one. The vendor, So, and I figured that this saw would involve some fleam, to give it some characteristics of a cross cut saw.

Couple weeks ago, the saw arrives from Japan. I have included a direct scan of a portion of the toothing, so you get the general shape of the teeth. I tried the saw out, rip to start with, and it was extremely smooth, in either a straight rip or a long miter cut (at a small angle to the grain). The maker had said it would be smooth, but at some expense of speed in a straight rip. I didn't notice any loss of speed, but then Heiji is a great sharpener. Just at a glance, the teeth had a lot of fleam, so I tested the saw in an ordinary crosscut, and it left smooth-as-glass faces on the end grain on either side (this was on satinwood cutoffs from a project), with no ragging or splintering. In other words, a fine crosscut.

I took some measurements of the toothing, to figure out what is making this saw work so well for rip, miter, and crosscut. Here is the data:

Basic: 240mm, 14-1/2 ppi

Included angle of tooth (and gullets as well).... 28 degrees

Rake: 11-1/2 to 12 degrees (forward, aggressive)

Fleam: 20 degrees

Top profile: Angle of tooth top, looking down the blade end to end, is 15-20 degrees. This top profile is established by a third facet, where the point of the tooth is filed down until the top slope is 15-20 degrees below horizontal. If this third 'over the shoulder' facet had not been used, the tooth point would have been much steeper, based on the 20 degrees of fleam and the acute included angle of the tooth. It would have been a straight crosscut saw.

The filing required 'sloping gullets', i.e., an upward filing motion. Heiji passed on that the saw is very hard, so be careful.

___

Comment: I pass this info. along to you saw filers out there, for whatever it may be worth to you. This saw's performance is stunning. It is this third facet--the filing on the back of the tooth to independently control the top profile--which makes this saw what it is.

As far as western equivalence, there has been some online discussion by Mike Wenzloff and Andrew Lunn, perhaps others, of unusual toothing styles. Lie Nielsen has gone to a graduated tooth back saw. Before that, Henry Disston's 1907 'Lumberman's Handbook' has some intriguing recommendations on how to modify the backside fleam to customize for hardwood, dry hardwood, etc. (though not in Disston's later editions of the same Handbook).

FYI.

Wiley


Re: Heiji saw

#2

Re: Heiji saw

Hank Knight

>Very cool, Wiley. I'll bet Wilbur is drooling on his keyboard. So will hear from him, I'll bet. Thanks for the post and the report.

Hank

Re: Heiji saw

#3

Re: Heiji saw

barryvabeach

>Wiley, what do you intend to use the saw for? It sounds like it does a great job in rip and some crosscut, which could make a great dovetail saw.

Re: Heiji saw

#4

Re: Heiji saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Barry,

I am using it pre-joinery, for sawing out the pieces of a small project, in 4/4 and smaller stock. I had intended to use it for straight ripping, but now that I see what it can do, I can just have the one saw and do everything with it. Cross-cutting wouldn't take anything out of the steel.

Am thinking about a 270mm or 295mm in the same style, when I get some more money saved up.

The thing is--and this is what I'm really trying to convey--the saw is not a compromise that does everything pretty good. It does everything really, really well.

Also, not trying to sell these saws, but it occurred to me that perhaps one of our western saw makers might get interested and trying toothing a panel saw or carcase saw in this style.

Thanks for asking!

Wiley

Re: Heiji saw

#5

Re: Heiji saw

wilbur

>Drool drool drool drool drool. ;)

Wiley, have you seen either the Mitsukawa Hat Trick saw, or the miter cut saw in the Mitsukawa detail 5 saw set? I've never seen either in person, but from descriptions it seems like those saw might have similar teeth to your new Heiji.

Also, it may be true that there's nothing new under the sun like Mike says, but if that's the case, what does he think the historical precedent was for this type of tooth?

Re: Heiji saw

#6

Re: Heiji saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

I haven't seen the Mitsukawa saws. So the similarity may well be there.

However, I have seen Mitsukawa-san's metate compared to Heiji-san's metate. And in that regard, I would say it is no simple feat to file the top profile of each tooth, while preserving the saw's jointing.

Wiley

Re: Heiji saw

#7

Re: Heiji saw

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Hey, what's the poop on the Mitsukawa 5-saw set? I'm thinking of buying a set from Tomonori-san.

Pam

Re: Heiji saw

#8

Re: Heiji saw

MikeW

>Also, it may be true that there's nothing new under the sun like Mike says, but if that's the case, what does he think the historical precedent was for this type of tooth?

Hello Wilbur,

If we excise the phrase "historical precedent" from your question, I think it is a simple answer.

The simple answer is that I believe all filings we find and believe to be innovative, whether they be on Eastern or western saws, has been done before by someone. I think people by nature are fiddlers who seek optimization for given tasks.

In the case of Wiley's wonderful saw, I personally can see advantage of the third facet from a maker's perspective. The third bevel, I am betting, is not perfectly even from tooth to tooth. Wiley?

Whether it is an even shape (length) of third facet or no, it provides an extremely smooth return stroke (I am guessing). It should be as if the saw glides back without attempting to grab in the cut. This would be because of two principles inherent in such a filing. (1) it lessens the back of the tooth shape by lowering the angle present in the bottom of the kerf on the return stroke. (2) it lessens the distance between the tooth tops.

The saw, with its fleam (though it is a rip) is how the long miters can be cut well. The fleam is low enough that the rips will be very smooth because of the slicing of a cross cut *and* excavating action of a rip.

Because of the fleam, the tooth face lean (the rake) can be a bit more aggressive--and it needs to be to make up for the fleam. Both rake and fleam are working in concert on either true rips or long miters.

My guess is that on pure cross cuts, as the thickness rises, is slower than a truly cross ct saw. And perhaps a bit more grabby, a little more waste on the exit side.

So why all the ramble without addressing the "precedent"? This is not an uncommon filing for western saws--save for the third bevel. On a western saw due to the shape of the saw file, the back bevel is fairly low as the tooth face becomes more upright. Point being, on the western saw this similar filing provides great ripping, really good long miters and an aggressive--and slower as the thickness increases--cross cutting.

I cannot fathom that a saw maker or a user in Japan at some point did not alter the traditional shape of a saw tooth to make for great rips and long miters. I could be all wet.

If we add back in the concept of historical precedent, I think I can add that at least for temple builders, this ability to quickly do ripping and long miters makes sense. So again, I think it is unfathomable to me that someone did not have the tooth shape on a saw altered to make a saw have this capability.

Take care, Mike

Re: Heiji saw

#9

Re: Heiji saw--Long

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Mike and all,

I will intersperse with Mike's detailed post (in blue):

The simple answer is that I believe all filings we find and believe to be innovative, whether they be on Eastern or western saws, has been done before by someone. I think people by nature are fiddlers who seek optimization for given tasks.

Yes. And in your own case, Mike, confronted by a world with two kinds of saws--crosscut and rip--you took the lead a few years ago in reintroducing progressive rake and fleam, and other customizations, each designed to optimize your saws for purpose. This level of customization is rare everywhere, including Japan.

In the case of Wiley's wonderful saw, I personally can see advantage of the third facet from a maker's perspective. The third bevel, I am betting, is not perfectly even from tooth to tooth. Wiley?

Don't bet, Mike. I checked out in the bright light earlier today. The jointing is perfect, which I expected based on how smooth the saw is. I also checked (as well as I could because you can't really get a magnifier into the desired position) the top profile (angle) on a few randomly selected teeth, and they all look identical, as does the filing. I don't know if I mentioned this, but Heiji-san is a great saw filer.

Whether it is an even shape (length) of third facet or no, it provides an extremely smooth return stroke (I am guessing). It should be as if the saw glides back without attempting to grab in the cut. This would be because of two principles inherent in such a filing. (1) it lessens the back of the tooth shape by lowering the angle present in the bottom of the kerf on the return stroke. (2) it lessens the distance between the tooth tops.

You're right. Though I think the actual purpose of the third facet is to give the saw rip properties, by cutting down the top of the tooth. If you put a 20 degree fleam on a 28-degree included angle tooth, the top profile will fall away steeply, like falling over a cliff, and the saw would be pure crosscut. The third facet controls the top profile to a 15-20 degree slope, preserving some rip properties.

The saw, with its fleam (though it is a rip) is how the long miters can be cut well. The fleam is low enough that the rips will be very smooth because of the slicing of a cross cut *and* excavating action of a rip.

Because of the fleam, the tooth face lean (the rake) can be a bit more aggressive--and it needs to be to make up for the fleam. Both rake and fleam are working in concert on either true rips or long miters.

This all checks.

My guess is that on pure cross cuts, as the thickness rises, is slower than a truly cross ct saw. And perhaps a bit more grabby, a little more waste on the exit side.

Good points. I tested the saw today against a 17-point straight crosscut, of similar size and an aggressive rake. This was on 4/4 cherry, whereas the first tests were on satinwood (current project wood). No backing, cuts were into the air. I didn't get a difference in speed; however, the hybrid saw did leave some fine tagging (little less than 1/32") along maybe one-third of the bottom side of the cut. The straight crosscut, also a high quality saw, left a bit of fine ragging as well, but less than the hybrid. So given my technique, which is no doubt less than perfect, the purpose-built crosscut was cleaner on the exit side. Retested on satinwood, and the two saws were equally clean on the exit side.

So why all the ramble without addressing the "precedent"? This is not an uncommon filing for western saws--save for the third bevel. On a western saw due to the shape of the saw file, the back bevel is fairly low as the tooth face becomes more upright. Point being, on the western saw this similar filing provides great ripping, really good long miters and an aggressive--and slower as the thickness increases--cross cutting.

I cannot fathom that a saw maker or a user in Japan at some point did not alte traditional shape of a saw tooth to make for great rips and long miters. I could be all wet.

If we add back in the concept of historical precedent, I think I can add that at least for temple builders, this ability to quickly do ripping and long miters makes sense. So again, I think it is unfathomable to me that someone did not have the tooth shape on a saw altered to make a saw have this capability.

You're right, they have done this. For boatmakers too. The ibara-me (softwood) and nezumi-ba (hardwood) toothing has facets similar to a western crosscut filing, with the fleams adjusted to match project needs. I believe these filings are in Odate's book. In the case of Yataiki, I have seen his saws with use different fleam front and rear, and I have seen his saws use a third facet along with this type filing, maybe to adjust the top profile for the right rip properties, or maybe to make a less pointy and more durable tooth.

It occurs to me intuitively, though this may not be right, that the third facet would provide a fast way for the sawyers themselves to touch up their saws a couple of times on the fly, before having to go back to the metate for a more complete refiling--but this is just a notion.

Thanks for your very perceptive comments!

Wiley

Re: Heiji saw

#10

Re: Heiji saw

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Wiley, would you have a larger magnification picture? My eyesight isn't what it used to be (I'm seeing an optometrist for the first time tomorrow) :)

Thnx,

DC

Re: Heiji saw

#11

Re: Heiji saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Denis,

That's the best I can do for right now. No digital camera, and can't get the saw plate really flat on the scanner bed.

I was hoping the various angles given would assist. But you're right--seeing is better.

So what's the style in glasses now? I need to see the optometrist also.

Wiley

Re: Heiji saw

#12

Style in glasses

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Gosh, I wouldn't know, my style in glasses is more of the wine type, filled with a good Alsace riesling, vintage Port or Icewine :)

DC