Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

Posts

Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#1

Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

Bill Houghton

>Stanley produced two series of planes - numbers starting 180 and 190 - that are simple rabbet planes, roughly equivalent to a No. 78 plane with the iron in its standard position, but with no fence. They started making these the year after they started building the No. 78, and kept building the 190xx series up through 1962.

Other makers did, too (my current tool porn favorites being the older Sargent planes, which are way way more graceful than the Stanleys and just littered with flowerdy embellishments on the castings).

They seem to have been popular - I counted 17 Stanley No. 190/191/192 planes on deBay today plus one No. 181 (not counting parts and one sad little 182 with its nose broken off), vs. 18 No. 78s.

Does anyone know why? Since the No. 78 can do pretty well everything the 180/190 series planes can do, AND it has an adjuster AND a bullnose position for the iron (granted, not useful often, but sure is useful sometimes) AND a fence, why would anyone buy the simpler planes? To actually cut an accurately placed rabbet from scratch with one of the simpler planes, it seems you would need a batten to work against, which would then need to be removed lest it get in the way of the depth stop, slowing the work. Was it purely a cost issue - impoverished carpenters or apprentices bought them and worked around the limitations, pining for the day that they could own a No. 78 - or were there production environments in which the simpler plane was absolutely all that was needed? Or were rabbets laid out by measuring over from the face edge, rather than planing the opposite edge true and gauging from that (second) edge, so that the fence was less useful than we now think it is?


From Patrick Leach's "Blood and Gore"

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#2

Re: Why these rabbet planes?

Kem

>Bill, I was wondering the same thing recently. My guess is price and choice. People like options, like different width irons, and the simpler planes cost a few pennies less.

Kem

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#3

Conjoint economic analysis

David Miller from Iowa

>Although they didn't call it that back then - the study of how people value different features of products. If you went to the store back in the day and wanted a plane for a use that doesn�t require a fence or the bull nose option you might just buy the cheaper one without those features (in 1939, the 190 series was 20% cheaper than the 78). Or the reverse � even if you don�t need the fence that day, many of �us� would buy the best one just because it was.

Just go to the electronics store and see how they price TVs that are about the same, but one has some cooler features. A bunch of people want the cheaper one and a bunch of people want the extra features � some market analyst figure the price spread out statistically.

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#5

Re: Why these rabbet planes?

Paul Dzioba

>Hi Bill,

Probably millions of wooden rabbet planes were made without depth stops or fences; it is the most common wooden plane I see. You simply freehand using your fingers for a fence as you work to your marking gauge lines. You may reverse direction for grain run out. It is very fast and is very accurate with a little practice.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#6

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

Dean J in MN

>Good question, perhaps you can glean some of the answers by interpreting the section from Peter Nicholson's book where he describes the different kinds of rabbet planes. As noted, the non-fenced wooden rabbet plans are very common, but Nicholson makes quite a distinction of the separate uses of the non-fenced rabbet planes and those with fences (fillisters).

What I can't say is if there is a mapping from the wooden planes over to the metal planes. Stanley made all sorts of "interesting" planes that may or may not have been well thought out.

(scroll down a touch on the link to section 18 "Rebate Planes in General")


Peter Nicholson on Rabbet Planes

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#7

scott grandstaff

Re: Why these rabbet planes?

scott grandstaff

>Don't tell anyone but..............I love them!!

At least the 191 and 2

The 78 has a 1 1/2" wide blade! The weight of the plane is not conducive to much heavy cutting at 1 1/2".

The word flimsy springs to mind. Sure you can cut a 1/4" rabbit with ease. But the mass backing up a

1 1/2" wide blade is just not there.

The little 192 is just so handy. I keep a 191 and a 192 handy to my bench at all times.

I don't use them for forming rabbits much.

But I use them for quick cleanup of several kinds of wood joints. That last irritating trim. That offensive little bit to cut.

They are ever ready and nothing to set up. Grab and go.

They made these planes in three configurations.

The plain, block, butt ugly last made ones. ick

The earlier fishscale handle pattern.

And the oldest, floral embossed handle pattern.

In case you were wondering, like many things, they did not improve as they went along the run!

Lighter and flimsier as they went, as is the usual sad story.

The oldest are best.

But don't tell anyone.

Currently they are just about worthless on the market and I would like to see that stay around a while. :)

yours Scott

Re: Why these rabbet planes? *LINK*

#8

You realize, Scott,

Bill Houghton

>that you're going to start an eBay rush on these now.