Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

Posts

Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#1

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

Jim in Burlington On

>I need a reccomendation on a japanese hammer for chisels. Also input from someone who has gone to rosewood and where they stayed. Is it better than a carribean vacation? I was thinking of starting with the handtool one or machinery to get my feet wet. Thanks Jim

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#2

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'd suggest your local community college for machine based woodworking, much cheaper and probably similar quality.

I thought Rosewood went out of business. What happened?

Pam

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Thanks

Jim in Burlington On

>Looking at this for the vacation aspect really. Way past the college stuff. I need to unplug, unwind and smell the wood for a week or two. Might even give up tv for a few weeks.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#4

Hammer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jim,

The short, plump 'daruma' style hammers have a very good balance for chisel striking. They cost around $30, although you can spend as much money as you want to on a Japanese hammer, because there is 'art forging' in hammers, just as in chisels and plane blades.

For basic hammers, you might consider Japan Woodworker,

http://www.japanwoodworker.com/search.asp

or Hida Tool,

http://www.hidatool.com/shop/shop.html

Search on 'hammer'; I can't get you directly to the hammer page.

For weight, use whatever you're using now. Some like heavier and some like lighter. I would say most people are going to use a chisel hammer on the order of 375g (13oz) to 450g (16oz), though some might prefer a lighter hammer than these for dovetailing and a heavier hammer than these for mortising. It's all personal preference.

The basic hammers are going to come with a handle, made of Japanese white oak, which is great handle material. It's more like a live oak than our domestic white oak, though it does have fleck in it. These handles are often just stuck into the head without much concern for fit, and a wedge hammered in--it's mainly for effect, because the head so affixed will come loose in your first hammering session (IME).

What you might want to do is back the handle out, saw off the split end, and refit the handle to the hammer head. Get the handle real dry. Start with a tight fit, slightly oversize in fact, and hammer the handle into the head a little at a time. The hammer eye will be slightly smaller than the opening at top or bottom. Just force the handle through, and forget the wedge. Can give more details if you're interested in this.

Perhaps Bob Le, if he stops by, or others such as Pam or Wilbur or Dave Burnard, might want to give you their experience and methods.

To me, one of the most fun things about a new hammer is fitting the handle. Incidentally, you don't have a shoulder under the hammer head. The shaft should be ever so slightly tapered, so that you can just keep hammering the handle in tighter over time, if need be.

Congratulations on the Rosewood Studio vacation! I've heard nothing but great things about them.

Wiley

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#5

Re: Hammer

wilbur

>I use a 375g daruma style hammer for just about everything. For the one time I did a lot of major mortise chopping, I used a 16 oz. Sears framing hammer. :O

I can attest to the wedge coming out over time, but it did take a while to do so. I had just been banging the wedge back into place, but I'm going to try Wiley's suggestion. If you have more details, Wiley, I'd love to hear them.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#8

the vacation aspect

Bill Tindall

>There may be classes that proceed at a "vacation" pace but I suspect they will be rare. The typical person willing to shell out hundreds of dollars for a class is going to be highly motivated to accomplish as much as possible to get their money's worth. Figure that this person will be your typical class mate and the class will be geared toward their needs.

I have friends that take woodworking classes and they don't sound like vacation to me. The class objective is to get something made using new skills and techniques. There always seems to be a struggle to keep up with the class plan for completing the project in the time available. In other words it sounds like long hours work and possibly stressful work if you are stretching your experience on the project.

Different work can be a vacation but from what I have experienced a woodworking class is not like a day on the beach. Bottom line-research the class by talking with the instructor and former students to be sure it will meet your objectives.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#9

Re: the vacation aspect

wilbur

>My wife and I took an anniversary vacation that was a tour through Italy.

We needed to be up at 6 AM pretty much every morning to eat breakfast and get on the bus in time to get to the next destination.

Still, it was a great experience, and I wouldn't have traded it for anything.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#10

Re: the vacation aspect

Hank Knight

>I've taken two week-long vacation woodworking classes at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in Maine. Much of what Bill says is true: Start early, stay late, long days on your feet in the shop. But that's what I went for. I don't get week-long stints in the shop at home - I have a day job that requires my attention. The classes were very relaxing, mentally, if not physically, and I enjoyed every minute of them.

Hank

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#11

Me too

Tony - Memphis

>I've taken a couple of week long classes and one two weeker (my 40th birthday present). Worked my tail off and loved every minute of it. A great vacation in my book. Just do soeme research and make sure you are going to get what you expect and that the instructor is, well, not a jerk. I've had one or two of those too! Some classes seem to go for quantity of students instead of quality of experience. Also make sure that yo will be taught what you expect. I took a chair class once and built a nice chair, bit I didn't learn how to build a chair. Actualy, we didn't even get close to finishing the chair. I had plenty of work left to do at home.

One day, I was taking a breather and drinking some water out on the shipping dock at Phil Lowe's school. Phil walked out and said, "This ain't no union job - get back to work!" Ha!

Tony

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#12

I'm a heretic, and I did take a class at Rosewood

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Now, the two are unrelated :)

Heretic because I use a round mallet with all my chisels, western or Japanese...

I took a class at Rosewood about six years ago if my memory serves me right. At the time It was owned and run by Ted Brown, a CR alumni. Krenov's influence was strong. Now that it is run and operated by Ron Barter, the Krenov connection is less evident, but commitment to workmanship hasn't changed.

I had a grand week at RS, not because I learned so much, but because for a whole week I did nothing but live and breathe woodworking, and, equally important to me, did so with a group of like-minded people. For many amateurs woodworking is a solitary endeavor, and the connection with fellow woodworkers is a fantastic experience.

Now, I live close enough to RS that I commuted from home for my course. For out of town students, there are a couple of bed and breakfast houses in Almonte and probably some other accommodation available nearby. Rosewood's site used to provide links to these, but I haven't checked recently.

Hope you enjoy your course, I know I did for mine...

DC

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#13

Thanks, David.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#14

It better...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>at that price. :O

I use 3 Daruma hammers 300g for DT and mortises in thin wood. A 375g for 3/4-1" thick wood and a 450g for large mortises. All three of mine still didn't set me back that much.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#15

It Does......

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Actually Scott, I was just using that link as an example. The hammer I have cost a bit more than that ;) . I have used barrell headed hammers and find the one I have gives me quite a bit more feedback along with delivering more oomph per blow. Like chisels and plane blades, some Japanese hammers are made by excellent Smithes that can produce some really interesting tools. Striking a chisel with my hammer is kinda like dropping a beanbag on grass...no tendancy to rebound and a solid feeling of the wood removed.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#16

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Many Thanks

Jim in Burlington On

>Well any time away from work is a vacation. I have been to Italy a few times and would agree it's a fantastic place to go and relax for a month or two. I get up early and usually out of the house for 12-14 hours a day so spending long hours in the shop is just a distant dream these days. Thanks to all who responded.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#17

Re: I'm a heretic, and I did take a class at Rosew

Kevin H.

>I look at Rosewood from a different angle than others. I have been there a few times but never taken a course. My impression of the place is positive. I have seen the change in others, including Denis, after having spent time there. I would have to say that the change is in a positive direction. The change usually involves several aspects of woodworking including methodology, technique, selection and utilization.

I have personally learnt from folks that have attended Rosewood and would love to take a holiday there sometime. My idea of a holiday is different than most though. I'm not an R&R kinda guy.

If I were you, I'd pick up the phone and call Ron. Talk to him, he'll discuss whether his gig will meet your expectations.

...and I use a round mallet for striking my chisels. The face is always the same regardless of the rotation of the handle in my hand.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#18

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

Thomd

>Or, come by on your way to Rosewood, and you can try out 10 or so japanese hammers, and my 2 rubber mallets etc... I am about 2 minutes from BB, and 10 minutes from LV.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#19

Re: Japanese tool hammer

Thomd

>I have a bunch of Japanese hammers. I used to use them for every thing, but 15 years ago I switched to better US hammers for framing and such. For chisels I moved to th rubber mallets LV and Busy Bee sell. They are just a lot better than the metal hammers for everything other than tool box storage. Most importantily they are quieter, but the blow is also better. I don't like wooden carvers hammers, but the rubber ones are awesom. I have Japanese hammer of many different types, cheap to fairly expensive. They are just pieces of metal on the end of a wooden stick, nothing all that special. The LV Japanese hammers were good, but they seem to have dropped them. I like both the 8 oz and the 14 oz. For the rubber mallets I use the 20 oz for all cabinet stuff, and the 30 oz for the heavy stuff. The 20 0z has the swing weight of the 14 oz hammer.

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=30003&cat=1,41504,43688.

The BB version is I got in 30 oz and it seems equal in quality to the LV, though all the heads are loose, it doesn't affect feel or use as far as I can tell...

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#20

Coupla details--LONG

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur and all,

Wilbur asked about handling a Japanese hammer, without a wedge. It's low-tech stuff. Short version: you bash a slightly oversize handle through the eye of the hammer, and never mind the wedge.

Longer version: Just like it takes a bench to make a bench, it takes a hammer to handle a hammer, so it helps to have a decent-size bashing tool with enough momentum so that you don't have to use a lot of head speed to persuade the handle as it moves millimeter by millimeter. Also have a card scraper on hand.

The other preliminary is to be aware that the eye of the hammer has shape. They are slightly restricted toward the center of the eye, from a few thousandths to several thousandths. I like to mic them before I start, to know how tight the restriction is. You want the handle to be tight on the inlet side, tight in the middle, and tight on the outlet side--but how can that be if there is a restriction in the middle??

The key is to take your time. Allow a few days for the fitting. More on this below. Start with a handle blank of wood that is tough but compressible and resilient. All the usual handling woods are good--I've used a So. American version of osage orange (hedge), white oak, and even satinwood, though the latter is probably not the best choice. Am sure hickory is great for the purpose. And ash. Or one of the locusts. Any known handle wood. My favorite is Japanese white oak (kashi), which is a live oak.

By the way, it will occur to you: Wonder if I'm going to blow out the cheeks of the hammer, driving this handle through. You won't. The handle will just absolutely stall in the eye before that happens. Now what if the handle blank is a bit too oversize to drive further, and it just stalls in the eye. You can back out the handle that you've started driving, by punching it out from the top side. But what I recommend if the fit is close, is to take a card scraper, and scrape just below the hammer. You will leave a little ring of fuzz just below the hammer, but that will shear off on the next hammer blow. Scrape off just enough that the handle will move once again.

You don't want a shoulder on the hammer handle below the hammer. Just look at any of the commercial handles for a Japanese hammer. They'll be maybe a foot long. The business end of the handle blank will be a smooth taper for about 3 inches or so. Take a spoke shave and shape the insertion end so that there is a a very gentle expanding taper--for example, if the point of insertion measures, say, 3/8" x 1", then shave the taper so that it expands to, say, 1/64" oversize over a three-inch taper. I'm making this sound more quantitative than it really is, in an effort not to be abstract. I like to make the insertion end a tight, ever-so-slightly oversize fit, and then lightly rasp the very end so it will start. Some extra length is good, so that if and when you mung up the driving end, that'll be gone when you cut to final size.

You're going to drive the handle blank right through the restriction, and let it expand on the other side, the exit side. This may take a while, and experts like So Yamashita will proceed a couple of millimeters per day once the handle has reached the restriction, and pour a little oil into the 'cup' above the restriction, so that the insertion end grain can drink up the oil and expand. Just mark off a string of 1/8" marks below the hammer, once the handle has gotten as far as the restriction. And every day, hammer it down one mark--1/8". This is assuming a pretty tight restriction--several thousandths. You can make faster progress if the restriction is more slight.

What do you hammer on? You want to hammer on an absolutely dead place--so the blows are going straight to ground. That's why I like a tree stump, or rock on the ground, better than anything else. You can do it on your bench, right over a leg, if the leverage is right. But you want the driving end of the hammer no higher than waist high, so you have gravity on your side and a good angle.

I'm making this sound like more of a chore than it really is. I enjoy it a lot. And when you're done, the hammer will not even think about moving on the handle.

Wiley

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#21

Re: Coupla details--LONG

wilbur

>Thanks for the writeup, Wiley. Between the page I found on So's site and the description in Odate's book, I've been doing pretty much what you've described in your post.

The handle on my hammer is binding up. I bang on it, and it's not going forward at all. The thing is, I think it's binding up in the middle of the hammer head, where the restriction is, not at the bottom hole. I don't see the handle binding up at the bottom hole of the hammer head where scraping it would do any good. Based on your description of the narrowing of the eye being a few thousandths of an inch, I think that the issue is that the narrowing in the middle of my hammer head is too much to allow the handle to compress and then go forward.

That's not much of a surprise, I don't think -- my hammer is a cheap one from JWW -- nothing special. My plan is to take a file and file down the narrowing and try again. It looks to me like most of the narrowing is on the short walls of the eye, and the long walls of the eye are pretty straight. Is that the case for your hammers? And is the narrowing really just a few thousandths of an inch? That would make the narrowing less than 1/64", and from my bashing around it seems like the Japanese white oak handle I'm using will easily compress more than that.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#22

Re: Coupla details--LONG, and an APOLOGY

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

I've handled about 10 Japanese hammers from different makers with different prices.

What I find is that the more expensive hammers are more precise in the way the eye is formed. I just checked three 'good' hammers--a Hishikan 375 mokume daruma, a 450 flared 4-sided one from a friend of Kayoko's, and a Masayuki 450 of a modified 4-sided type. When I measure the inlet side (the marked side) versus the outlet side, the variation is less than 1/64", on the order of 1/100", and in the case of the Masayuki it is as close as I can make out to being the same. Now the restriction on the Masayuki, which is not handled, is just about 1/64" in both dimensions. I recall that the restriction in the eye of the other two good hammers was likewise on the order of 10 thousandths, give or take a little. Certainly not enough that you can't drive kashi through it.

I also just checked two commodity hammers, of the type you describe. Entirely different story. One is an octagonal 300g plane adjusting hammer, and one is a 375g daruma. Both of these narrow markedly from the inlet side--the marked side--to the outlet side. The plane adjusting hammer is (in 64ths) 23 x 56 on the inlet side and 21 x 56 on the outlet side. So the narrow dimension is 1/32" less at the outlet side--the top of the hammer.

Likewise, the 375g daruma is 23 x 58 on the inlet side, and 21 x 56 on the outlet side. I double checked this to see if I'm making a mistake--nope, it's 1/32" narrower on the small dimension, and 3/64" smaller on the long dimension, almost a sixteenth.

Now I truly regret having been so glib, because I haven't fitted a handle to a basic commodity hammer in several years. I forgot what they're like. The procedure I gave, and So-san's more detailed description, will work for the well-smithed hammers, but we need another strategy for the less expensive hammers, where you're not paying for careful smithing.

What I suggest, if you haven't already done this, is measure the inlet and outlet side of your hammer. See what you're up against. It may be that yours, like the latter two I mentioned, is significantly narrower in one or both dimensions at the outlet side--the marked side being the inlet side. If this is the case, then clearly you have to start with enough taper that the handle will drive through.

I don't think the handle is hanging up on the restriction per se--I've never had this happen. Instead, I suspect that the eye is narrowing steadily from inlet to outlet, and the handle is going to hit an impasse somewhere in the eye. However, you can find that out for yourself, and I agree that if the restriction itself is the problem, then filing is the answer. But if taper is the problem, you can flip a coin between filing and just tapering the handle you're driving.

Please let me know what you find out. And my sincere apologies to all for being too quick to prescribe what to do, without specifying the degree to which hammers of differing quality may vary, and how that will affect the handling strategy. I honestly had forgotten, and spoke too quickly without going back and checking.

Wiley

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#23

Re: Coupla details--LONG

Bill Houghton

>Some western hammers have an hourglass shape in the eye that require, when fitting, tapering the handle to fit the lower hourglass shape, then wedging it above to fill the upper hourglass. When properly fitted, the handle is solid and slow to loosen.

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#24

Re: Coupla details--LONG, and an APOLOGY

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

No apology needed as far as I'm concerned. Here's the stats on my cheapie Japanese hammer.

Inside opening, where the "375" is stamped: 0.874" x 0.342"

Outside opening: 0.863" x 0.345". So one dimension is smaller than the inside, and one dimension is larger.

In the middle of the eye, there's a considerable narrowing: 0.813" x 0.296". That's close to a 1/16" narrowing along the longer dimension, and 3/64" narrowing along the short dimension before it flares out again.

I did shave down my hammer handle some more to make sure it was within 0.874" x 0.345". It inserts further into the hammer head, but still binds up at the narrowing. I think I may just have to file away that part of the hammer if the handle doesn't budge over the next few days.

Or this will give me an excuse to order a fancy hammer. ;)

Re: Japanese tool hammer and Rosewood Studio

#25

Re: Coupla details--LONG, and an APOLOGY

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>"No apology needed as far as I'm concerned."

I was more chagrined about giving Jim Nardi bad advice (without further explanation of the issues and uncertainties of buying an inexpensive hammer).

" Or this will give me an excuse to order a fancy hammer. "

Bingo!! Some motivation: What's the most-used tool in the workshop? Answer: Hammer comes pretty close. I thought Brent Smith's advice was good. Might check with Harrelson to see how much he is charging for a differentially-hardened Masayuki (if it's got laminated end caps, it'll be somewhere north of ~$400 depending on size and whether there is mokume or somesuch).

Thanks for the measurements. I think what your data and mine are showing is that the cheapie hammers are designed for a wedge, so therefore they aren't particular about the eye. Whereas the fancy hammers are forged more carefully so they can be handled without a wedge--which is what the Japanese carpenters do (at least, the ones that taught Blauvelt and Harrelson, for example).

Wiley