Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Searching the forum

Posts

Searching the forum

#1

Searching the forum

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Last evening I spent 30 minutes trying to find a post made on the Hand Tool Forum by Les Winter in mid August 2005. The results were a mishmash. They were not sorted either by forum or by date and they contained only text references to Les, not any of the posts he made.

Two weeks ago I could have found this information in 30 seconds by searching specifically for Hand Tool messages posted by Les Winter and specifically for August 2005. Frankly, it was an effort for me to learn to do efficient searches. Now this skill is rendered useless.

I was also unsuccessful at searching for a discussion about having registered members on the forum. This occurred around November 2007. Now there is a euphemism for registering.

Re: Searching the forum

#2

Ellis Walentine

Another tradeoff

Ellis Walentine

>You're right, Warren, sometimes you know just whose post you're looking for and in which month/year. In those cases, the old search dialog was more useful than the comprehensive keyword search. I'm putting together a wish list for the developer of the new search package about some possible downstream changes. Sorry to disappoint yet again. It's all these binary choices I'm having to make: I'm wondering if there is any change that will not disappoint someone, or what it might cost to have everything everyone wants.

Meanwhile, I managed to go to the Hand Tools Archives link in the top navbar, click on the Hand Tools Archives 2005 link, and navigate to the three or so pages of August posts. I found a couple Les Winter posts for you. Sorry, you didn't mention which topic you were looking for...

Handcut Dovetails in Softer Woods

Handsaw Sharpening

Would either of these be the ones you're looking for?

Re: Searching the forum

#3

Ellis Walentine

Keyword search

Ellis Walentine

>If you know the subject, it's worth trying that first, Warren. I still don't know if handsaw sharpening was the topic, but when I typed "handsaw sharpen" into the Keyword search box, Les's August 2005 post showed up #7 in the list.

Ellis

Re: Searching the forum

#4

Browsing by date

wilbur

>Hi Warren,

Although you can't search directly by date right now, it's pretty easy to navigate through the archives to get to the date range you want. The archives are broken down by year, and each page in the archive is one week. So to get to November 2007, you can go to the 2007 Hand Tool archive, which puts you at the week of December 31, and skip over to page 4, which should be beginning of December/end of November, and browse from there.

If you want to jump back several weeks, you can even manipulate the http address by changing the number at the end of it. So to go back 26 weeks in the 2007 Hand Tool archive, change the address in your browser to http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3107/md/index/page/26

Re: Searching the forum

#5

Ellis Walentine

Browsable archives!

Ellis Walentine

>I mentioned your plight to our developer and he suggested I remind you of another new feature of our updated boards, and that is that the archives are now fully browsable. Before, you couldn't do that. The only way to access previously posted and archived information was to come up with a combination of date range, search terms and/or poster's name. Now, all messages are there for you to browse at your leisure. (You still can't reply to archived messages, though.)

Click the Hand Tools Archives link, choose a year, and browse through the date range you want. Use your browser's Edit > Find function to locate a poster's name. It only took me a couple tries to find the pages from August 2005.

Ellis, who really needs to find time to update the FAQs with all this new stuff so I don't have to spend so much time answering and re-answering your perfectly understandable concerns....

Re: Searching the forum

#6

Re: Keyword search

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thank you, Ellis. I had wanted to see what people wrote to Les's question about dovetails. I did not wade through the 4100 keyword responses to see if his was there. Also last evening I was unable to get the Hand Tool Archive 2005, which now has appeared.

I looked over the two minute "profile " instructions, but not much was intelligible to me past the second sentence. I will wait until one of my children can help me. This stuff is rough on a guy who hasn't taken a computer course since 1967. I was still able to understand Catharine's Latin; Latin has not changed much in the last 40 years.

Re: Searching the forum

#7

Re: Browsing by date

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes, I see that now, Wilbur. Yesterday the old archives were listed but not at all complete. Some years had nothing in them.

Re: Searching the forum

#8

Re: Keyword search

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>You understood serra secavi? Now that's pretty amazing. There was really nothing to understand in Catherine's post; whereas Ellis' post explained how to set up a profile. While I think this unnecessarily complicated, it's a clear set of instructions. Why not try copying that message text into a text/word processor and simply following instructions? Or maybe even printing it out.

As to searching, I was almost never able to find anything useful in the old search function, and while I haven't tried the new one yet, I don't see how it could be any worse.

Pam

Re: Searching the forum

#9

David Barnett

NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

David Barnett

>'Search' is, to me, the most important feature, and not being able to search on the author/poster is stunningly inconceivable and ill-considered. It's amazing such software is even on the market. I'm not usually a big complainer and am quite grateful for WC and all the effort that has gone into it, but I simply can't imagine migrating to a system where users can't look up Bob Hackett's or Bill Houghton's or Bill Tindall's posts. To me, this oversight diminishes this forum's usefulness and functionality dramatically. What has been gained (SPAM control and forum management) pales to what has been sacrificed (again, to me, as a user). It is a saddening loss. Although I'm sorry for the public gnashing of teeth and rending of garments, I must speak with candor and let it out. Pleeease offer some hope of a timely fix and I'll just double up on my Prozac. Otherwise, I'll crawl atop a cinder block and jump to my death.

Re: Searching the forum

#10

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Marv

>David,

I just now did a search on my own name for the year 2008 and got 1421 messages pertaining to messages either I wrote or people referenced my name. :\

Marv

Re: Searching the forum

#11

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Marv, there are 1422 under your name now because of the one you have just written. It helps that you sometimes sign your name because only the text is searched, not the name of the poster. The search does not distinguish different years. I added one, make that 1423.

Re: Searching the forum

#12

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Ace Karner

>This is not a reply to any one in particular just to the forum in general.

STFU, anyone who has their panties in a bunch over all the changes is more than free to start their own forum. So do it if you don't like what Ellis is doing.

We all come here and learn more than we could possibly have imagined a few years ago, we interact and instruct an learn. Sometimes we are just entertained but whatever we come by it for little or no investment other than our own time.

Ellis has put himself out from day one and everyone that has the smallest problem has whined from day one.

I am so discouraged by the pettiness and smallness of the few self important loud mouths on this forum that I can hardly believe it.

Thank you Ellis for all you have done, for what you are doing now, and for what we can look forward to in the future.

Re: Searching the forum

#13

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>This is a reply specifically to Ace: "Love it or leave it" is so over. Adults do their best to amend things that don't seem right. No one here has been disrespectful to Ellis nor made any unreasonable demands, except, of course, the love-it-or-leave-it consortium.

Pam

Re: Searching the forum

#14

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Ace and all,

Ace, you're right. Ellis has paid for what we have in blood, sweat, and tears. I have worked with the man at pretty close range for a couple years now, and he is a magnificent person. Extremely industrious, but always has time for the concerns and feelings of others.

Now I respectfully disagree with you that there should be no negative comment, or instructions to others to STFU. Warren's and David's remarks were candid, but were motivated by a true feeling of loss. These guys have been with us a long time, and both have been major contributors to the Archive, and I have personally searched both their names more than once.

My guess is that Ellis will take note of all the comments, and will do his very best to make WoodCentral the best that it can be. Not to cater to any particular person's opinion, but to make the site, including the Archives, as strong as possible.

Please let's be respectful of each other.

Wiley

Re: Searching the forum

#15

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Ace Karner

>I will agree that constructive criticism may have it's place, but whining and bitching does not.

This is not a pay as you go site, Ellis provides it with no strings attached and he deserves much better than the carping that has been going on.

Re: Searching the forum

#16

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, Ellis provides the platform; but it's all of us who contribute the content, freely, btw. So if primary content providers were to desert the platform, there would be no wood central. Most any ditz knows that.

I truly think that the decision to move to another platform should be much more democratic, with everyone having the option to review the proposed platform before implementation. I also know that you guys have the basic attitude that it's better to ask forgiveness than permission, but we can all see how far that's gotten us over the last decade.

But I don't have much hope that this approach will change in my lifetime.

Pam

[some editing by moderator]

Re: Searching the forum

#17

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Thomd

>Speaking of which why do boards move to new platforms from time to time? Sometimes it is blazingly obvious, with masses of new features and payment options. Just as often nothing changes that would seem to be worth the trouble. The same could be said about moving relentlessly onward from XP to Win 7, but if I don

Re: Searching the forum

#18

Something I found out, Warren

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Warren,

I asked similar questions - see post a few below and replies from Ellis

What I found out.

The 'new' archive search works only on the text of the post, and uses the subject line to set relevance ratings of the text. If the subject line and the text of the post match, then the subject line will also be referred to in the search results. If there's a word in the subject that is not in the post, then that post is ignored and not published in the archive search.

Ellis' description here:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/144676/sbj/here-s-what-it-does/

You can use quotation marks to search for phrases, and the minus sign to exclude search terms.

eg: baseball +"home run" -"babe ruth"

Trust that this may be of help.

Cheers,

Andrew F

Re: Searching the forum

#19

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!  *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>Sometimes changes are not totally voluntary. The old versions may not be supported anymore, or may not play well with standards that change through no fault or desire of your own. A site as large and complex as Woodcentral, cannot afford to run long term with code that has no support. You could run Windows 98 with no support and lack of many features and applications, but most probably choose not to do that. You can stay with Vista and not go to Windows 7 if you like, but at some point, there will be no future support for it.

This version of forum software is about as close as you can get to the original look and feel that has a future support path with active developers. From what I have seen, the original version that was used here at Woodcentral is now an orphan with no development or support. The version used here now is from a group of developers that took over the old code, updated, and released it. I am attaching a link to a bit of history about it.


History of Web BBS

Re: Searching the forum

#20

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

>Interesting discussion, and thanks to all who have posted their feedback. As someone noted, it all counts, and I understand how passionate a lot of people can get about this stuff. I do too, but I'm a designer. I relate to problems. Clearly this is a problem for many people and there will be a solution. All I can ask is patience.

As Warren noted, the keyword search only finds names in the text of searches, and some of the names may even be on our "stop words" list, which allows the engine to pass over words that are irrelevant when indexing the messages. We don't have the option of going back to the old search by poster/keyword/date range regime, but I'm working with the developer to find a way to achieve the result we want. One possibility is to write a script that will add the poster's name to the bottom of each message, so it will show up in the keyword search. It would mean we'd have to then index all the messages again, but that was more time consuming than painful.

There are other possibilities as well. The important thing is for you to believe me when I tell you that this move wasn't undertaken lightly, nor was it unnecessary. Also, I think we can modify it to everyone's satisfaction, and I'm trying very hard behind the scenes to do just that. For now, we'll have to live with the keyword search, which is really quite powerful.

Ellis

Re: Searching the forum

#21

Civility reminder

Bill Houghton

>Change can be upsetting, and everyone reacts differently.

It's not necessary to insult each other in order to make a point. Passion is good; but not when it tips over into attacks or insults. Everyone, please take a deep breath and remember that we come here for the community of folks, each of whom deserves respect, even when we disagree with what they say.

Re: Searching the forum

#22

I wish.......

Bill Tindall

>...I got such a concerned response from the managers of other software I have had to use, starting with MS, and the list goes on. Thanks for working on what many of us feel is an important problem.

Re: Searching the forum

#23

AMEN 3 times

Ron in Kokomo

Re: Searching the forum

#24

Re: NO! Ellis, say it ain't so!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>For any number of reasons, such as new standards, the hackers have caught up and/or surpassed, new features, etc. Fact is, software almost defines the concept of change, and very little of the change is voluntarily undertaken (I'm excepting vendors here, who have to keep moving to make money). No one, except an autistic psychopath [sic] would voluntarily change a running system unless the benefits were extreme.

That said, as I said after the last board changes, I think it would behoove the powers that be to provide everyone a beta version so that we could try it and find these problem areas before implementation. But noooooooo....

Pam

Re: Searching the forum

#25

Re: Couple things

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'm not totally reformed from software development yet (and, btw, I used to be pretty good at it), so I'd suggest that somehow the subject, poster name, and message body be merged with the message is placed in the archive.

Pam