Will hide glue stick to shellac
Bill Tindall
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Will hide glue stick to shellac
Bill Tindall
Re: Will hide glue stick to shellac
Stephen Shepherd
>No, not unless you etch the shellac so it has a tooth or key for the glue to grip. You can lightly sand it, go over it with a toothing plane or etch it with a fresh cut clove of garlic.
Stephen
Re: Will hide glue stick to shellac
Dean Lapinel
>Stephen,
Do you have the time to write a little more about garlic and shellac? I'm not familiar with this.
Yes
Adam Cherubini
>Yes. Hide glue will stick to shellac. Pretty sure everything sticks to shellac. It's a great primer/sealer and folks often use it to allow one finish to bond to another. Shellac sticks on most surfaces (even oiled surfaces) and most everything sticks to it (including hide glue).
The problem you may encounter is gluing to old shellac. Folks oil and wax shellac and hide glue may have trouble sticking to certain surfaces. Chances are, you won't detect the problem. It will manifest in reduced shear properties. But HG shear is really high so you may not miss what you lose. You may also lose properties on highly smooth surfaces. The key is to rough up the surface and allow for a discernible bondline thickness. .005" ought to do it. A piece of window screen or a sheet of paper could be used to maintain such a bondline.
Adam
Re: Will hide glue stick to shellac
Stephen Shepherd
>Dean,
Not only is garlic used to etch metal and other smooth non porous surfaces so hide glue will stick to them, garlic is also used to prepare smooth surfaces for other finishes like shellac. paint and varnish. I have some nineteenth century recipes that call for garlic as an ingredient in the varnish.
I covered the chemistry of garlic in Hide Glue - Historical & Practical Applications and there is another book in the works on traditional 19th century furniture finishes.
Shellac will stick to hide glue but the reverse is not necessarily so, especially on thick or old layers of shellac, it is a good idea to always prepare the surfaces for gluing, to address the original question.
Stephen
Re: Will shellac stick to whatever... NM
ThomD
Re: Will hide glue stick to shellac
Paul M.
>Hide glue may stick to shellac, but it will not stick well. I'm not doing much furniture anymore, but here's a point of reference from a related subject.
I'm building classical guitars (latest passion). There are two schools of building of classicals, the ones who glue the bridge on the top before the french polish (shellac) application, and the others who glue the bridge on the top after the french polish.
If you glue the bridge on first, you need to work the french polish into many small corners between the top and the bridge which is very difficult to do without lots of witness marks. I'm not good enough with french polishing to get away with this.
The other school will apply french polish across the entire top before the bridge is mounted on the guitar. Then the shellac on the top is *removed* where the bridge will be glued. The hide glue is not expected to stick to the shellac under string tension as it would clearly be the weak point. So the finish is scraped down to bare wood in this location before the bridge is glued down with hide glue.
I hope that helps!
Re: Will hide glue stick to shellac
Adam Cherubini
>I think alot of french polishers lubricate the rubber with oil. That could be part of the problem. A super smooth surface is another.
Adam
precisely the info I needed
Bill Tindall
>This is just the sort of application I was wondering about.