Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Couple of suggestions for new forum

Posts

Couple of suggestions for new forum

#1

Couple of suggestions for new forum

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>How about automatically marking messages we input as read rather than unread?

And how about putting duplicate Post and Preview buttons at the top of the text box in addition to ones at the bottom?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#2

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

Bill Tindall

>This is going to seem like I am in a contrary mood this AM but I prefer the message marking as it is.

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#3

***MAJOR ANNOYANCE***

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>These periodic formatting changes are a major annoyance for someone who has spent their life in front of a workbench instead of a computer screen. For someone not skilled in this realm it takes a long time to adjust to new procedures. There were still things that I had not figured out about the last format. Since these changes, I no longer see the number of times a message was read. I no longer know how to search the archives. I am unable to reference the remarks I made the last time there was a useless format change. I no longer know how to find someone's email address. I have not seen explanations of these changes and I have no confidence that I could understand them if there were presented.

I cannot recall anyone complaining about the previous format or the one before that. And I have not seen any improvements which warranted these changes.

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#4

the old format worked just fine.......

Chicago Bob

>and I almost felt comfortable with my ability to "get around" with searches, etc. I guess I am part of the "old fart" faction on Woodcentral who just wants to spend his time learning about woodworking and making new woodworking friends and less time learning about new software.

Even with that said, Woodcentral is a great board and I appreciate all of the continuing effort by its staff to make it the best.

Bob

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#5

I have been tolerant

Bill Tindall

>I haven't seen any change except editing capability that warranted the aggravation to me. However, I presume that the changes make managing the Forum easier, cheaper, what ever. I am willing to accept the changes for some "greater good". My attitude is that I am getting something for nothing and I need to appreciate what I am getting and not be demanding of the free lunch.

That said, it would have been good to have some warning of the changes and some instructions on how to deal with them. I am hopeful someone will tell me what the use of the symbols that appear in the header do. And please be rid of the silly faces to the side. They are so unprofessional.

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#6

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>This is my first post in the new format and I hope I'm flexable enough to adapt to the changes. I believe one can do quite alot if it is something enjoyable that drives the effort.( where are the smilies??)

JR

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#7

Re: I have been tolerant

Alex

>asdfffdsa

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#8

Re: I have been tolerant

Alex

>How do I delete or edit a post?

Everyone is talking about formatting options, smileys on the side, etc., which I am not seeing. Maybe a Firefox extension I have is supressing them?

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#9

RTFM?

Alex Y

>I say that only to myself! Ellis has shown great patience with those of us who crash ahead without reading his very clear instructions. And now I see the editing stuff, now that I have a profile.

Personal preference: I would prefer more screen real estate for typing, if there is any way to selectively turn off the smileys and formatting info. The bbcode add-in for Firefox provides all this capability with a right-click to the screen, and it stays hidden when not needed. I think the additional capability here is great for those who do not have another way to get it, but I'd like to be able to turn it off for myself.

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#10

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Well, I've only pointed out things that all of us do every day and that, as a previously successful software developer, would seem to make all of our messaging lives easier. Do all of you enjoy displaying a page down to make your post? Do all of you, aside from Bill, enjoy having to read the message you just posted to change the color of the title?

Of course I appreciate Ellis' effort, and I'm real tired of being accused of being unpatriotic every time I make a suggestion. If I didn't appreciate it I wouldn't bother trying to effect any changes; but in my world, it's better for one person to flip a switch than for hundreds of people to do it hundreds of times every day.

Pam

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#11

Re: ***MAJOR ANNOYANCE***

Tony Z

>Got to agree with you Warren. I have to say WoodCentral's changes are far worse than what Fine WoodWorking did to Knots. With a bit of study, I'll find my way around on WoodCentral, but I've already removed Knots from my favorite list.

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#12

Woodcentral is still free and excellent.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#13

WOW!!!

Brent Smith in Montreal

>It always amazes me to see the responses to format change on any forum. You'd think a new way of handling the national debt was being forced down peoples throats.

The truth is, that within a few weeks, or months for the truly ruffled, no one will remember the things that are bothering them today. It's one of the beautiful things about humans...our ability to adapt!

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#14

AMEN     Twice

Ron in Kokomo

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#15

Re: ***MAJOR ANNOYANCE***

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Esteemed friends,

We're all different snowflakes, so there is an equally great variety of reactions. Reactions to change.

I struggled yesterday with it myself. But please hear me out on just one thing. This is not change for change's sake. I'm not a techie, or even competent, at what goes on inside a computer's software. In fact, trying to straighten out my own edit function yesterday, I managed to lock myself out of the Admin. Panel! It's kind of a mystery to me, how these things work, and maybe that's where many of you are.

But I do know, from working with Ellis, that he had ridden the old horse as far as it could go. For the past two or three months, at least, we have been getting eaten alive by spambots--robotized spam coming from all corners of the globe. All viagra all the time, etc etc. You don't see this spam on the HandTools board, because we're a backwater. But the main Messages Board was under siege, and there were three or four of us deleting spams all day long.

So it was kinda like what you learn in infantry training--I think Mainely Bob will back me up on this--one of the first things you learn is to not get pinned down under fire. You have to keep moving tactically. That's where Ellis found himself--he couldn't breathe for deleting the incoming. He had to keep moving and not get pinned down.

So he made one big push of several all-nighters in a row to get the new forum to a usable state, and then he went live. Not everything was ready. The HandTool archives are not there, and I suppose there will be a search function associated with the archives when they get up. In addition, all of us with our different browsers and browser versions and operating systems, etc, are dealing with Profile, Registration, and Passwords. We will work through these, and someone (Dean Lapinel was it) even came up with a way to make smilies go away for those who don't like smilies.

We're pretty close to getting through this. But Ellis did not change things because he thought change would be cool--it _had_ to be done to stop the spam attacks. Ellis is doing heads-down work right now to get to 100%.

Wiley

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#16

Re: WOW!!!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, but it appears we don't like to take the time to adapt, we have to be dragged kicking and screaming into it. To me change is what keeps it all interesting, creative destruction and all that.

Pam

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#17

Absolutely right Wiley!

Bob Hackett

>Most groundpounders I know would rather be mobile than in a static defense.

I`ve noticed some of the other forums doing the same thing and the software seems to look similar.I Forge Iron made the switch thru the holidays(took over 7 days too) and so this looks somewhat familiar to me.

BTW-they are STILL chasing major bugs over there so Ellis and crew seems to be well ahead of the power curve.Nice job guys,thanks.

MB

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#18

I like the new forum!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>

How about ....

I REALLY like what Ellis has done!

I understand that some are not that computer literate (even though you are here on a www forum) and that many do not like changes (even when they are computer literate) :\ . However many just do not seem to be aware of the work that has gone to make the forum more user-friendly.

I post on just about all the forums around (it is very intreresting how they all have personalitoes of their own, and how differently many react to the same question). Anyway, I post a lot (what can I say, I'm hyperactive and I need a life :) ) . Because of this I can say that this is one of the easiest forums to both express oneself and to upload information.

From the point of uploading images, WC is now on a par - if not better - than the majority of the forums. The forum that is the odd one out is Knots. This uses a different set of codes. In fact EC used to use the same codes, and this made it very difficult to post to a few forums - when the coding is the same, it is just as easy to post to two forums as one. Now I am not expecting many here to do the same as I (there are a bunch who do), but you need to understand that WC is SOTA.

There are a few features I would like to see added: let's have back the number count. It is useful to see how popular a topic is - for example, if I post an article but no one bothers to read it, I will not post that subject again. If I post that article but no one replies yet many read it, it says that many find it interesting but for one or other reason have nothing to add.

The other feature I would like is to be able to EDIT a message after it has been posted.

Otherwise ... thank you Ellis. You put in a lot of time and effort, and I think that you deserve a big vote of confidence and thanks!!

For all of you with a whinge ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#19

Re: ***MAJOR ANNOYANCE***

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thank you Wiley. As I mentioned earlier, I was not aware of any underlying problems. I reread the posts made by Ellis on this hand tool forum. Although I certainly could not understand all that he wrote, I don't think he mentioned attacks at all. He talks only about superficial improvements, "new and exciting", more bells and whistles, bangles and baubles.

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#20

Me Too! +10

Hank Knight

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#21

Re: I like the new forum!

Dan Donaldson

>If you have a profile, you can edit your own messages for about 30 minutes or so after you post it. ;)

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#22

Ellis Walentine

View counts and searches

Ellis Walentine

>Hi Warren,

Sorry if the new board format seems hard to get used to. I see you don't have a profile, so you shouldn't have to worry about the formatting buttons, picture upload utilities and all the rest of the nifty new features that are available to registered users. You really should register and see what I'm talking about.

Regarding view counts, we temporarily suspended them because we're trying to isolate some remaining server performance bottlenecks, and the view counts were significantly slowing response time. They'll be back as soon as we've completed optimizing the processing times.

Searches are not yet enabled because we are moving up to a new search utility that will search on all messages and archives at once, similar to a Google search. In order to make the search faster, we must index about 800,000 messages for search terms. This process will require that I shut down the boards again while I rebuild 38 databases -- in the middle of the night, so the fewest people are inconvenienced -- and then start the indexing utility, which could take three days to fully complete its work. Once that's completed, you will see a new search term box in the navigation bar. I estimate we'll have it ready to go live by Friday of this week.

As I mentioned in another post, I do understand how change itself is upsetting, and even though I have kept about 95% of the look and feel of the old boards, people are now complaining about the 5% that actually has changed. The good news is that we won't have spam bot problems, Macintosh users won't be hopelessly victimized by old buggy scripts, you will have new abilities to edit and delete your posts, format text, upload multiple images and other file types, and receive e-mail notifications of replies to your posts. Registered users also may include HTML in their posts, include links, bypass the content filters, send a trouble ticket when a problem arises, view profile lists, and more. If none of these amenities is of interest, it's no problem. You can still read and post without registering.

In late February, I intend to move WoodCentral to a bigger and faster server, which should further improve delivery time. In the meantime, let's understand that this is a work in progress, that changes can be upsetting but they needn't be, and that tweaks like font sizes and viewport size can be modified as we move forward, if the consensus is there.

Believe me, I don't undertake any projects like this without a good reason, and there were many reasons for this particular upgrade. I've done everything I could to make the transition smooth for everyone, with some success. The profile/password issue seems to be settling out as well, as I'm personally helping all comers by e-mail.

All I can say is to please be patient. We're not done yet.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#23

FWIW

WoodburnBob

>Ellis, in following this thread, I've been guessing that the irritated and complaining patrons vs the supportive or non-vocal remainder is something like 5/400, i.e., about 1%. Maybe I'm off by an order of magnitude. Still, so what. This is vastly lower than the prevalence of constitutional (congenital) complainers on any topic in the general population.

Your concrete explanations to the disgruntled are very helpful to the rest of us and increase our admiration for you on many accounts.

Whatever you do is fine with me. I trust your judgment to run your affairs responsibly. I always have. I do not feel entitled to the existence of this site without change in perpetuity. Bob

Re: Couple of suggestions for new forum

#24

Ditto...what Bob said

Marv