Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

How to start flattening a skinny board?

Posts

How to start flattening a skinny board?

#1

How to start flattening a skinny board?

Jake in Comber, Ontario

>I have a skinny board (ash) that has a banana shape around 1/8" to 3/16" of a gap in the center. The board is 27" long, 1" 3/4 wide and 1" thick. I want to make it 3/4" thick. What would be a good technique to flatten the first side? I was thinking that I should just put a spacer under the middle and plane down the the hump until it was flat, but then thought I could shim the two ends and work on it that way. I'm not sure (I haven't done much of this before) what the best technique would be.

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

#2

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

Frank D. in Montreal

>You could do either, but I prefer not to work with shims at all. I just place the board upside-down (relative to the side I want to flatten first), rock it to determine the high spots, then turn it over and start planing. It doesn'T matter if the board flexes, because you know where to take off wood (I use a no. 5 with a cambered blade to do this). If you're taking off wood in the middle, just skew the plane to create a hollow (concave surface) when the board flexes. Turn it back upside down, measure your progress, and then continue until that side is flat and doesn't rock (or lets no light pass) when resting on your benchtop. Once this first side is flat, do the same for the other side (except this side will be easier because the board won't flex) after having scribed a line for thickness. Leave a little extra so you can go back and smooth or correct the first side if necessary.

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

#3

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jake,

Welcome!

For a 1" thick board, I agree with Frank that shimming is optional, provided you start with the convex side up. For a thinner board, which you can feel flexing, I like to shim because it makes the work steady and the blade stays in the cut; a thin board unshimmed is always trying to squirm out from under the blade. If you decide to flatten the concave side first, you have to shim of course.

The question you asked is, which side to start with? I like to start with the convex side up, because if--repeat, if--there is any tension left in the board, you will be cutting away and relieving some of that tension when you work the middle of the board. This means the board could straighten slightly on its own, if you work the convex side first.

Rather than do 100% of one side, then 100% of the other, I suggest go back and forth, at least two passes on each side. This is for thickness control, given that the board may decide to re-bow itself, or straighten out a little. You don't know what it's going to do. Sometimes it doesn't matter much, if the board is going to be constrained in the project by a groove or dado or glue or internal framing. But if this board is going to be a rail or stile, that means it has to be dead straight and also full thickness. So you will want to let it acclimate a day or so after your flattening--so you want to leave some meat on it for final adjust. Plus you may get some tearout, and it could get dicey whether you're going to hold your 3/4" thickness. For these reasons, I like incrementalism because it keeps your options in front of you.

If you do decide to do the back-and-forth way, rather than all-one-side then-all-the-other, you will of course need to shim when you're working the concave side.

One other thing that can bedevil flattening operations, particularly for thinner boards......If your benchtop is not flat, and you're relying on it to be flat, the board will never get flat. This is mainly something to be aware of, rather than having rules about. Check the bench top. If it is less flat than the flatness you require on the board, then don't rely on it to be flat. Use the methods that Frank stated.

Wiley

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

#4

Less banana, but still there

Jake in Comber, Ontario

>OK, the board is still shaped like a banana, but much less. I can still see light under the sole of the plane around 1/32" at one end. I was hoping to use this as skill builder, so I want to make it flatter if I can. Every thing I try seems to keep this shape. When I put the plane in the middle of the board, it doesn't cut at all. I can make a continuous shaving from end to end though. I can't figure out what I'm doing wrong. I planed it convex side up, and haven't touched the other side.

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

#5

Re: Less banana, but still there

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Jake,

You're getting there. It's all to the good.

Got a two-foot or four-foot level? If so, put it on top of the convex side and see what's going on. That'll tell you what you need to do. You may already have it pretty flat between the 10 yard lines--the straight edge test will let you know.

Once you've done this for a while, the shaving will tell you everything you need to know, but for right now, the best learning will be to check with a straight edge, so you can interpret the results you've gotten so far--and see what you need to do next.

Wiley

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

#6

P. S. re straight edge

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>If you're using (or have) a long plane, like a No. 7 or No. 8 or a long woodie try plane or jointer--just tilt it up on edge, and that can be your straightedge. You can check things on the fly real fast that way.

Wiley

Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?

#7

Also

Dan Donaldson

>If you are trying to take some out of the middle, use a shorter plane to work on the short area in the center, then back to the longer one.