Re: How to start flattening a skinny board?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Jake,
Welcome!
For a 1" thick board, I agree with Frank that shimming is optional, provided you start with the convex side up. For a thinner board, which you can feel flexing, I like to shim because it makes the work steady and the blade stays in the cut; a thin board unshimmed is always trying to squirm out from under the blade. If you decide to flatten the concave side first, you have to shim of course.
The question you asked is, which side to start with? I like to start with the convex side up, because if--repeat, if--there is any tension left in the board, you will be cutting away and relieving some of that tension when you work the middle of the board. This means the board could straighten slightly on its own, if you work the convex side first.
Rather than do 100% of one side, then 100% of the other, I suggest go back and forth, at least two passes on each side. This is for thickness control, given that the board may decide to re-bow itself, or straighten out a little. You don't know what it's going to do. Sometimes it doesn't matter much, if the board is going to be constrained in the project by a groove or dado or glue or internal framing. But if this board is going to be a rail or stile, that means it has to be dead straight and also full thickness. So you will want to let it acclimate a day or so after your flattening--so you want to leave some meat on it for final adjust. Plus you may get some tearout, and it could get dicey whether you're going to hold your 3/4" thickness. For these reasons, I like incrementalism because it keeps your options in front of you.
If you do decide to do the back-and-forth way, rather than all-one-side then-all-the-other, you will of course need to shim when you're working the concave side.
One other thing that can bedevil flattening operations, particularly for thinner boards......If your benchtop is not flat, and you're relying on it to be flat, the board will never get flat. This is mainly something to be aware of, rather than having rules about. Check the bench top. If it is less flat than the flatness you require on the board, then don't rely on it to be flat. Use the methods that Frank stated.
Wiley