Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Spring steel *LINK*

Posts

Spring steel *LINK*

#1

Spring steel *LINK*

Nathan

>I'm still shopping for a tenon saw (or two). I live in continental Europe and I'm on a tight-ish tool budget.

As was suggested earlier, I registered on the British eBay and there are lots of tenon saws on there. Through eBay, I made contact with a British antique tool dealer - Second Hand Tools and I'm hoping I'll get something nice from them.

However, I'm still considering buying a new saw as well. Here where I live, I can get a Japanese Ryoba saw and I'm giving that serious consideration, but the cheaper ones have very hard blades and you have to use a special file - maybe not the best for a beginner.

So, I'd like to start with a back saw. Anyone familiar with this one (Axminster - see link). It's only 12" (but that wouldn't bother me too much) and has 14 tpi.

It's got a brass back and a spring steel blade.

Could this be a good beginner's tenon saw? Or, alternatively, is this saw worth $50, in your opinion?

Thanks for looking.

Nathan


Axminster Benchcraft Tenon Saw

Re: Spring steel *LINK*

#2

Re: Spring steel

Marv

>Hello Nathan,

Most of the cheaper backsaws are not carefully hand filed as one expects with a highend or the more expensive saws. I suggest that you buy a cheaper saw than the one you mentioned because, more than likely, you will want to refile it. Even the cheapest saw can be refiled and reset to make it cut as good as the most expensive saw. After all, they are all made of a piece of sheet metal. The thickness of the blade will effect how well it cuts even when filed properly. The hardness of the metal will effect how long it remains sharp.

So if you can't afford or just don't want to spend the money for the expensive saws, buy a cheap one and have it refiled. It will be less expensive in the long run and in the mean time, you might practice filing a saw yourself. It's not difficult once you learn what makes a saw tooth cut properly.

Good luck :)

Marv

Re: Spring steel *LINK*

#3

Re: Spring steel *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Nathan,

Sorry to be so late getting to your question. I do have a suggestion for you.

The experience any of us have with any saw depends on whether it is straight, sharp, jointed well, set well, and so on. If you buy a high-end saw, it will possess these features by and large proportional to its cost. This is because there is a lot of hand work in the saw.

It is also possible to get a well-made vintage saw, which will have good 'bones', and have it tuned up by someone who really knows how to do it. At that point, you would have a reference saw, against which you could compare your own sharpening skills. And it will be the functional equal of any other high-quality saw.

There are a few US vendors who occasionally sell excellent restored saws on ebay. There is good value in these, but then you are long distance and paying for shipping, etc.

My suggestion is that you contact "Pedder" in Germany, who I only know as an internet acquaintance. My impression is that he both makes and rehabs backsaws. You could write him, explain your situation there in Europe and what you're looking for, and ask whether he has saws for sale, or whether he would sharpen and tune your ebay.UK saw, or whether he could recommend someone else who might assist you. Pedder's website is linked below. I have used Google translation on it.

Wiley


Pedder's website in Germany

Re: Spring steel *LINK*

#4

Thanks, point taken

Nathan

>Thanks, Marv & Wiley, for your kind encouragement and advice. Your point is well taken. I'm still not sure how I'm going to get my hands on a half-way decent saw, but I'm sure it will happen at some point.

In the meantime I found that, of the various tools I tried for tenons, I'm getting the best results from an ordinary Czech hacksaw, which has a "gent saw" handle and a heavy-gauge steel frame. It cuts a little slow, but clean. The main problem is it's heavy and unwieldy.

I found that I get better results with it by sawing at a brisk clip, but occasionally this results in a slightly inaccurate cut.

Anyway, if you're interested - over on the loud side I just posted a report on the 16th week of my apprenticeship.

Thanks again,

Nathan

Re: Spring steel *LINK*

#5

Re: Thanks, point taken

Marv

>Hi Nathan,

I know of some people who are using a regular panel saw sharpened rip for tenons that are not really small. The older saws are taper ground and will not bind in the kerf with minimum set in the teeth. A handsaw is considered to be a panel saw if it's 24" or less.

Marv