Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

? on Baldor grinder models

Posts

? on Baldor grinder models

#1

? on Baldor grinder models

Dave Mount

>I know, it's a power tool, but it's for hand tools.

I'm finally fed up enough with cheap grinders to drop the required money on a Baldor grinder.

Baldor has several 6" models that vary in price. The 600e and 623e models have all the same specs on the Baldor site, the only difference I see is that the 623e has cast iron tool rests. However, there's about $80 difference in price between the two, and that seems like a lot for the only difference to be the tool rests, which makes me wonder if there are other differences. I won't even be using the factory tool rests, so I don't care about them.

Does anyone know if there's more difference between these models? Any reason I shouldn't just get the less expensive 600e?

Thanks.

Dave

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#2

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

Joel

>The sheet metal rests bend under pressure. The cast iron rests don't. The latter aren't perfect in design but they are rock solid which is a real pleasure to work with.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#4

the tool rest is more important than the motor

Bill Tindall

>For me the priority is tool rest and wheel and the motor is largely irrelevant. A large, flat, stable tool rest makes grinding things like plane irons free-hand relatively easy. No tool rest that comes on a grinder is adequate in my mind. The Wolverine tool rests and jigs work excellently. I found the Lee Valley rest too frail and wiggly and replaced it with the Wolverine.

So, with a given amount of money to spend I would start with the tool rest and then worry about the wheel. If you are going to make a tool rest then that leaves more money for the grinder.

Personally, I would rather have a cheap 7 or 8" grinder than a quality 6". Keep in mind that the soft wheels you should be using will wear fairy quickly so a 6" wheel soon becomes a significantly smaller 5.5" wheel.

I bought a Baldor 3-phase and put a VFD converter on it so that I can vary the speed. Soooo, nice for lathe tools and precision grinding. I'll bet my lathe tools last times longer because I am removing metal in a more controlled fashion. Given proper wheel selection, it not the coolness of grinding that makes slow useful. Rather, it's control by being able to remove metal slowly. You may be able to find a 3-phase grinder used. They are generally cheap because the home shops don't bid them up.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#5

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

woodburnbob

>Just curious, Dave. When you say you are fed up with cheap bench grinders, it makes me wonder what you mean. I wonder how they failed you.

I looked at what Baldor had on their site for the two grinders you are shopping. As you say, the cast iron wheel guards and tool rest appear to be the difference. The motor bearings are listed as the same spec, but could differ in quality(class). The extra cast iron would only be important in terms of dampening vibration and noise, I'd guess, and having something more solid than sheet metal for any attachments that need to be attached solidly. It would make me want the cast iron. If you just want a grinder to spin stones, then they'd be equivalent I guess.

I did Google "Baldor China" wondering who makes them and saw. There is this curious preference out there for China-made machines branded with venerable USA names. Nothing brings it into greater focus for me than that I just read about Grizzly buying the South Bend (lathes) badge in past months and already marketing "South Bend" lathes that appear to differ from the former Grizzly lathes in color only. Haven't studied it though. The CEO announced plans to bring out a new version of the ubiquitous little SB homeshop lathe (e.g. 9A, 10K) this summer). That will be interesting to see. I have an old 9A.

I'm not knocking Baldor, Grizzly or China at all here, just the presumption (of mine, which I'm trying to rid myself of) that former high-quality American brands on tools necessarily imply something about actual origin, workmanship or quality. I'm even reading things along these lines about even some things from Starrett.

Anyway, Dave, I'd be interested in your impressions of whatever you buy, down the line, after you've given the new grinder a shake down.

Bob

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#6

Re: the tool rest is more important than the motor

Joel

>The baldors with cast iron rests HAVE a grinding rest that is large enough, and rigid. They work great.

Baldor grinders are made in USA by a division of Baldor that hasn't changed the design in decades. They might - but right now they haven't.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#7

Disagree somewhat, at the extremes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I have a Baldor grinder, inherited from my uncle, and its vibration-free operation makes a huge difference in how easily I can use it. I don't have space to have it mounted permanently, but find that, other than the hassle of taking it off the shelf, this isn't a huge loss - it's heavy enough and smooth enough that I don't need to bolt it down.

Cheap motors that vibrate a lot make it hard to present the tool to the wheel reliably.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#8

Vibration

Bill Tindall

>It has been my experience that vibration is a result of the wheel being unbalanced and this is not an easy problem to fix if the wheel is of poor quality or you are using a hand held dresser. Of course a heavy unit mitigates the effect, but a quality wheel and balancing it eliminates the source. I have met a number of the inexpensive $100 grinders of late and I could used any of them.

I own a Baldor grinder but it was the last place I spent my grinding money. My point is that the tool rest, wheel and dresser are more important to the woodworking tool grinder than the thing that turns the wheel. I am advocating spending what one needs to spend on tool rest, wheel and dresser and what ever is left over spend on the grinder itself. This recommendation presumes that the bulk of grinding will be on woodworking tools and not log splitting wedges, farm machinery and other heavy duty tasks.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#9

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

Tom Lewis

>I would consider the Baldor model # 632e

1800 rpm with cast iron tool rest. About the same cost of the 3600 rpm model # 623e

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#10

Agree

Frank D. in Montreal

>I also get good results from cheap grinders because the vibration comes from the wheel.

I dislike slow grinders though, because I think what causes loss of control is wheel vibration, not wheel speed. With a little practice it's not too hard to avoid overheating which is I think the real danger of higher speeds, although if you press harder to speed things up on a slow wheel you have the same problem. The advantage to a faster speed is faster results, which is why I turn to grinding in the first place. To avoid overheating all you have to do is lighten the pressure of the tool on the wheel.

Just a few thoughts. Baldors are nice grinders, built like tanks (and I've used them), but I could never justify the price. For slightly more than a Baldor you can get a high-end belt grinder which is IMO a much better tool (much less heat, much faster results, very versatile if you can change wheel sizes and platen shapes).

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#11

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

ThomD

>I've had a Grizzly 8 inch 1800 rpm model for almost 30 years. always been good. Probably due to lower speed. These days grinders are all but obsolete compared to belt sanders. Baldor grinders show up on cragslist up here fairly regularly, so I would probably follow that route.

I have the wolverine rest, and it is good, mostly because it is designed by a turning company, and if you turn some of those accessories are also good. I think the LV rest might have the edge for hand tool users alone. The way it wraps the stone for one.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#12

Re: Thanks and answers/additional info

Dave Mount

>Thanks everyone for your thoughts.

Re: comments about the rest being more important, I understand that. I already have the both the Wolverine setup (primarily purchased for turning tools) and the Lee Valley rest (I agree the wraparound rest is nice). The issue is what turns the wheels.

Right now I have a Delta 8" 3450 rpm grinder. I have struggled with vibration since I got it.

Re: wheels, I am using Norton white and blue wheels. I presume these are considered "quality wheels". If so, I would greatly disagree with folks who say buying quality wheels gets around balance problems. Both of the Norton 8" wheels (one white, one blue) I bought were significantly out of balance when received and made the the grinder vibrate like crazy.

After buying the Norton wheels and thinking I was set, my next investment was the Oneway balancing system to deal with the vibration. A big improvement, but vibration keeps creeping back in and I have to disassemble everything and rebalance the wheels. This gets very tedious, very fast. (By the way, I should mention that when I got the Oneway balancing system, it confirmed that the Norton wheels were significantly out of balance, rather than just being a problem with the grinder. In fact, one was so far out of balance I had to add a third weight screw instead of the two that are normally required. Even with both screws all the way to the light side, the wheel was still light there.)

I have been swayed by the many testimonials that say there's no comparison between a "typical" $100 grinder and a Baldor. I've been through so much crap and money trying to get a good setup, I decided to give it a go. I recognize some of the advantages of an 8" wheel, since that's what I have. However, the price difference between a 6" and 8" Baldor is big -- I can't justify a new 8" Baldor at this point, and all the used units I've seen look it and still aren't cheap. Moreover, it strikes me that 6" wheels should be less fussy about balance, given the smaller diameter.

This past summer I built an oversize garage and walled off a side room which is will be a metalworking area. I wanted a dedicated place to put the welder, torch, anvils and forge (I get plenty tired of hauling them in and out of the woodshop to use them). One of the grinders will go out there, one will stay in the woodshop.

From all the responses, it does not appear that anyone knows of a difference between the 600e and 623e other than the tool rests. Since I will be using aftermarket tool rests, it seems to me the 600e is the one I should buy.

Thanks for the discussion.

Dave

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#13

wheel dresser, tool rest, motor diameter

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Dave,

After a while, the 6" grinder wears to too small a diameter to put an adequate grind on tools (too thin a bevel which overly weakens the tool when there's 1/2" off the wheel.)

If you have the option to start new, I'd look to an 8" model.

As others have said, most important is a tool rest that's reasonable and a wheel dresser. The best grinder in the world is useless with a glazed wheel. Often, I'd surmise that the burning problems people experience might be due in part to a glazed wheel, which rubs, creating friction, more than cutting the steel

Additionally, the diameter of the motor is important.

I used to use a Makita 6" grinder, but the motor was 8" diameter, and continually interfered with hand position when sharpening.

Look to a grinder with a motor case diameter smaller than that of the wheel - eg: 5" motor case on a 6" wheel, or 7" case on an 8" wheel.

Good luck,

Andrew

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#14

I absolutely agree with this

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>esp the business about the motor diameter. I've had the cheapo 6" Delta for 20 years, desperately wishing it would bite the bullet. The fact that the motor is larger than wheel also limits the size of the blade you can sharpen. For instance, forget about building a jig that would handle planer blades. Anything larger than about 4" has to be sharpened at an angle, and that simply doesn't work.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#15

Another factor that causes vibration

Bill Tindall

>This factor was brought to light in a discussion on the main board some time ago and it is not my discovery. I can not recall who deserves the credit but they are probably one of the machinists.

Either the hole in the wheel is not concentric with the rim of the wheel, the hole has slop, or if you are using a bushing the bushing is defective. From the description of your symptoms I believe some out- of- roundness is the source of vibration. Unless the shaft bearings are shot or the shaft is bent the grinder is not the problem. The fact that at times there was acceptable vibration confirms that some out of roundness is the source of the variable severity of vibration. Most of my wheels are bushed and I have not had any store-bought bushing that was concentric and/or tight. As a result every time I changed the wheel I got vibration until I retrued the wheel. I wound up making my own bushings from aluminum and that cured the problem.

Rather than buying the wheel balancing system I would have suggested getting the Wolverine dressing system. When I install a new wheel and it vibrates it gets made concentric with the arbor with the dresser and all is well. I was not successful making an out of round wheel round again with a hand held dresser. I think it can be done, but it takes some technique.

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#16

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models------WebKitFormBoun

CraigD------WebKitFormBoundarykUPtmBlX+eI4kXA3----

>I've had a Baldor 623E for something like 20 years and for my use, it is nuke proof. Probably the best bit of gear I own. I've stalled it many times (getting stuff jammed between the wheel & rest) but that doesn't seem to bother it. The cast iron rests are very solid.

------WebKitFormBoundaryQsh3gEeC4eBHp+up

Re: ? on Baldor grinder models

#17

Re:Other factors that causes vibration

Bob Hackett

>I completely agree with Bill on this.

Unless the bearings are bad or the shafts are bent or otherwise defective there`s no reason that Delta can`t do everything you want.

I`d take the wheels off and check the bearings,then the shafts with an indicator for runout and if everything`s as it should be then the problem`s in the wheels.

I used to set up both industrial surface grinders and centerless grinders and if a wheel was put on an arbor and installed but didn`t look like it would dress and balance out with minimal problems we pulled it and returned it.

Even with brand names like 3M and Norton you still get the occasional problem wheel.They would much rather have you return it than have it come up to speed and fail.Once you put a dresser to it you owned it though as you had modified it from factory specs.

The Oneway arbor should be a good one as long as it`s a smooth sliding fit on the grinder shaft with NO slop.If there is more clearance than needed measure the shaft to be sure it`s not undersized or out of round.Oneway is very good about quality control IME.I`d be surprised if their arbor wasn`t within tolerance.

Even if you do get a new grinder it`s a good idea to measure and check everything to be sure it`s within specs,even on a Baldor.That way when you flip the switch and things aren`t up to snuff you know to look at the wheels.

If you have to periodically rebalance a wheel it sounds to me like the wheel has a manufacturing defect that caused a density difference.You balance it,dress it,run and redress as needed till the balance weights are now heavier than the more dense area(because it`s smaller from dressing the wheel).Then you need to redistribute the balance weights starting down the same road again.

MB