Re: Thanks and answers/additional info
Dave Mount
>Thanks everyone for your thoughts.
Re: comments about the rest being more important, I understand that. I already have the both the Wolverine setup (primarily purchased for turning tools) and the Lee Valley rest (I agree the wraparound rest is nice). The issue is what turns the wheels.
Right now I have a Delta 8" 3450 rpm grinder. I have struggled with vibration since I got it.
Re: wheels, I am using Norton white and blue wheels. I presume these are considered "quality wheels". If so, I would greatly disagree with folks who say buying quality wheels gets around balance problems. Both of the Norton 8" wheels (one white, one blue) I bought were significantly out of balance when received and made the the grinder vibrate like crazy.
After buying the Norton wheels and thinking I was set, my next investment was the Oneway balancing system to deal with the vibration. A big improvement, but vibration keeps creeping back in and I have to disassemble everything and rebalance the wheels. This gets very tedious, very fast. (By the way, I should mention that when I got the Oneway balancing system, it confirmed that the Norton wheels were significantly out of balance, rather than just being a problem with the grinder. In fact, one was so far out of balance I had to add a third weight screw instead of the two that are normally required. Even with both screws all the way to the light side, the wheel was still light there.)
I have been swayed by the many testimonials that say there's no comparison between a "typical" $100 grinder and a Baldor. I've been through so much crap and money trying to get a good setup, I decided to give it a go. I recognize some of the advantages of an 8" wheel, since that's what I have. However, the price difference between a 6" and 8" Baldor is big -- I can't justify a new 8" Baldor at this point, and all the used units I've seen look it and still aren't cheap. Moreover, it strikes me that 6" wheels should be less fussy about balance, given the smaller diameter.
This past summer I built an oversize garage and walled off a side room which is will be a metalworking area. I wanted a dedicated place to put the welder, torch, anvils and forge (I get plenty tired of hauling them in and out of the woodshop to use them). One of the grinders will go out there, one will stay in the woodshop.
From all the responses, it does not appear that anyone knows of a difference between the 600e and 623e other than the tool rests. Since I will be using aftermarket tool rests, it seems to me the 600e is the one I should buy.
Thanks for the discussion.
Dave