Re: Terminology Question
Don McConnell
>Hank et al,
You are correct that a coffin-shaped mitre plane would not be a good candidate for use with a shooting board. Though, as Bob has already pointed out, it would be suitable for use with a mitre jack. And, in this usage, a coffin-shaped plane may have been somewhat more comfortable, especially in long sessions, than a "square" (actually, rectangular) one. Otherwise, I agree that they seem a little counter-intuitive.
As to the definition of a mitre plane, I suspect that you are primarily asking about their relationship to the use of shooting boards? To begin to answer your question, I thought a bit of a historical survey might begin to provide some context, though I've not been able to come close to any kind of definitive answer.
Joseph Moxon (ca. 1680) and Richard Neve (1736) both describe the strike-block plane, and its uses, in similar terms. It was a tote-less rectangular plane, about 14 inches long according to Neve, used to shoot "short Joints" as well as mitres and bevels of mouldings, etc. Neve doesn't mention any method of use, while Moxon describes holding the plane in one hand and a small mitred piece in the other hand then planing it by thrusting it along the sole of the plane and across the finely set blade. Interestingly, for larger pieces, he describes setting them up in the bench vise and planing the miters with a (coffin-shaped) smoothing plane. :-)
Between 1736 and 1831 the term "strike-block" seems to have been supplanted with "straight-block." At least, thus far, I haven't found both strike-block and straight-block planes in the same inventory or list, so I believe them to be essentially the same planes. Though the change in terminology may also signal some minor changes in size, etc.
By 1831, Peter Nicholson, describes the straight block plane as being 12 inches long and having a more acute bed angle than common pitch planes (i.e. around 40 degrees). As we'll see, these were standard bevel down planes, and I believe strike-block planes shared these characteristics. In any event, Nicholson describes straight-block planes in terms very similar to the earlier descriptions of strike-block planes: " The Straight Block ... Is used for shooting short joints and mitres ... and ... is frequently used in straightening the ends of pieces of wood perpendicular to the direction of the fibres ... . ..."
Meanwhile, the 18th century saw the emergence of wooden and metallic mitre planes. The early mentions of wooden mitre planes do not detail how they differed from strike or straight-block planes, but plane maker J. Wilks' 1828 price list has these entries:
707 Strait Block, 2 1/4 [iron]
708 Mitre do. with stop and iron reversed
709 Iron do. steel faced
Incidentally, the mitre plane was about three times the price of the straight block, and the iron mitre plane was more than eight times as expensive. But, what I want to particularly note is that the mitre plane is described as having its "iron reversed." I.e., contrary to the straight block (and other bench planes), it was a bevel up plane. Typically, these English mitre planes had bed angles of about 20 to 25 degrees.
Even though this price list (and at least one other early listing of both straight block and mitre planes) is roughly contemporaneous with Nicholson's 1831 _The Mechanic's Companion_, it's interesting that he doesn't mention mitre planes. This may reflect the fact that he trained and worked as a cabinetmaker in the 18th century, but that is only conjecture. Incidentally, straight block planes continued to appear in British plane makers' lists until, at least, the 1870's.
In the meantime, the development of mitre planes in the U.S. diverged from the British pattern, though I haven't been able to narrow down a clear time frame for that divergence. As already discussed, the 19th century U.S. mitre planes were standard bevel down planes, with bed angles of about 40 degrees. This sounds similar to the British strike/straight-block planes, but they were shorter and narrower, and some were coffin/oval-shaped.
The earliest definite reference to mitre planes of this type, which I've found so far, is an 1859 Herman Chapin price list. It includes the entries:
Mitre Plane, Oval or Square, 1 3/4 to 2" [irons]
Mitre Plane, Oval or Square, Boxwood or Rosewood, 1 3/4 to 2" [irons]
Similar listings regularly appear in nearly every ensuing U.S. plane maker's catalogue right up to 1925. Unfortunately, I'm not sure much evidence exists to document how much prior to 1859 this type of mitre plane emerged. Though, one 1763 plane from the Dominy shop may suggest an early stage in this development. It is a shop-made plane, 6 11/16" long, with a slight oval, or coffin, shape, with a bed angle of 30 degrees. This bed angle would have been problematic (necessitating a 20 degree, or less, bevel angle), so it isn't surprising that the later versions had bed angles closer to 40 degrees. However, I don't want to put too much stock in this single example, because, being shop-made, we simply don't know if it was an early aberration or part of a larger development.
Now to return to the question of shooting boards. Interestingly, Peter Nicholson's _The Mechanic's Companion_, is also the earliest mention I've found, though he calls it "The Shooting Block." His description:
"Is two boards fixed together, the sides of which are lapped upon each other, so as to form a rebate for the purpose of making a short joint, either oblique to the fibres, or in their direction. By this instrument the joints of panels for framing are made, also the joints for the mitres of architraves, or the like."
This description of the purpose of the shooting block closely parallels the descriptions of the uses of strike/straight-block planes, so it is easy to assume that Nicholson's intent was to imply them being used in conjunction with each other. And this may well have been his intent. But, it may also be relevant that he doesn't specifically mention them in relation to each other.
Which seems to gain in significance when consulting the other early mentions/illustrations of shooting boards. In general, when a plane is indicated in conjunction with shooting boards, it is described or illustrated as one of the longer bench planes. I'm including one such illustration, from 1841, below. The plane shown has a closed tote and is longer than a jack plane, which is quite typical. Further, illustrations from Holtzapffel's Volume II, 1846, also show similar planes on a shooting board and a donkey's ear. These, and other examples, seem to suggest that, at least in the early part of the nineteenth century, there was not a strong correlation between straight-block/mitre planes and shooting boards.
Of course, the English strike/straight-block and mitre planes work well with shooting boards, so I'm not suggesting that we should cease and desist using them this way. I guess all I'm currently suggesting is that the evidence indicates that they haven't always been regarded in precisely the same manner as we now do.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR
