Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

What do I have here?

Posts

What do I have here?

#1

What do I have here?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>All along I've thought this was a scrub, but Bill (sight unseen) suggests maybe it's something else and that I should post it for discussion and identification.

The body is 10-1/4" long, the iron 1-1/4" wide. As you can tell from the pics, the sole is heavily radiused, maybe a 5" or 6" radius.

I got this the old-fashioned way: I inherited it from my grandfather, a Swedish immigrant from pre-WWI. The sole in front of the mouth has been fixed, as was the wedge, both oak. I have no idea who did it. I also don't know whether he did the repairs or got the plane as it is. The only thing I know for sure is that the iron, and presumably the plane, is Peugeot Freres. There is a stamp on the body top ahead of the mouth that I can't make out

I'll have to post pics in three parts. Any help identifying its intended function will be deeply appreciated.

Thanks

Bruce


img

Re: What do I have here?

#4

Guessing

David Miller from Iowa

>That it is a northern European smoothing plane, user modified to be a molding plane.

Re: What do I have here?

#5

Re: What do I have here?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The scrubs I've seen - and, understand, this is hardly a world-traveler-grade count - have flat soles, a highly cambered blade, and a mouth large enough to stuff a Siamese cat through (wear gloves and hearing protection before trying this test).

Beyond that, my knowledge of wooden planes requires a 3x5 card and a magic marker (the poster-making kind, not the Sharpie kind). I'll be interested to hear what people who (unlike me) know what they're talking about.

Side question, in several parts: the online references I can find to Peugeot Freres talks first about Peugeot automobiles; a little further digging reveals that the same company, more or less - at least the same family - made coffee grinders, pepper mills, sewing machines, and other things like that. There's no reference to tools, yet a Peugeot Freres tool catalog I found uses a lion logo similar to the one used by the automobile/coffee grinder/sewing machine company. Were they related? Are they still making tools?

Re: What do I have here?

#6

That makes sense, David

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I agree with that suggestion, too. As I look at the sole of this thing from the end, it's apparent that the radius is off-center, as though roughed out by hand. And there IS a very faint stamp on the body that might say "GERMANY", although auf deutsch in origin, it wouldn't say GERMANY, would it?

And thus a possible explanation is that this is a cobbled-together plane for cutting a cove bigger than Grandpa's #45 would handle. (I have that, too, with most of the cutters).

Re: What do I have here?

#7

I found a couple

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>PF planes in various places, almost all looking similar to this one. But mine doesn't have a size stamp that I can find, and this also seems to be a bit narrower than the others. And I agree that the scrubs I've seen have flat bottoms. You gotta have something to register against. I always used it as a scrub. Maybe now I'll have to start cutting coves or moldings as soon as I have a need for a cove or molding that size :-). Maybe it's the right size for your soffits?

This one does have a mouth big enough for your cat, Bill, but it's been modified so there's no way to tell what the original was. However, lacking either a cat or sufficient hand protection, I'll never know.

And it's also decidedly a right-handed contraption.

Re: What do I have here?

#8

My Guess

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>I've seen another somewhat similar (western style with tote/handle behind the iron); I was told that one was used by barrel makers to "back out" the inside face of a barrel stave.

FWIW .... rj

Re: What do I have here?

#9

that would work, too,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>except there is no rocker in the sole from front to back. It would work slicker than the dickens for straight-sided thingies like pails.

Re: What do I have here?

#10

Stephen Shepherd

Gutter plane

Stephen Shepherd

>

Re: What do I have here?

#11

Not a scrub, maybe not a Peugeot Fr�res?

Charles R. Smith

>Bruce,

It's a challenge for we who live in North America to be facile with European hand tools. Hence, what I say may be incorrect, but I'll give it a shot...

I have scrub planes (and a variety of other wooden-bodied planes) from both of the major French manufacturers, Peugeot Fr�res and Goldenberg et Cie. None of my scrub planes has a curved sole. Hence, I agree with the others that your plane may have a different function.

I also note that your plane's body is identical to my planes made by Goldenberg et Cie., and is not identical to the bodies of my Peugeot Fr�res tools. Hence, I am wondering if somewhere along the line, the your Peugeot Fr�res plane iron was placed into a wooden body from Goldenberg.

Here is what I know about the Peugeot Fr�res company. But please keep in mind that this information, which I gleaned from some French and German museums, is based on my own translation using my high-school French and German. Thus, I think it is reasonably accurate but I acknowledge that I may have made mistakes. I have not included any information about their automotive products -- having driven various Peugeot cars over the past 4 decades, I prefer Detroit iron. :)

In 1810, Jean Pierre Peugeot (1768-1852) and his brother Jean Fr�d�ric (1770-1822), the oldest sons of Jean-Pierre Peugeot (who was a dyer; 1734-1814), joined with Jacques Maillard-Salins of Montb�liard, to set up the company "Peugeot Fr�res et Jacques Maillard �Salins�. They converted a grain mill into an iron foundry.

The name of the company was changed to �Peugeot Fr�res et Compagnie� [Peugeot Brothers and Company] in 1819, and then to �Peugeot Fr�res A�n�s, Calame et Jacques Maillard Salins� in 1825. It was also in 1825 that they began building a factory in Valentigney.

They began by producing saw blades and clock springs, but soon expanded the product range to include umbrellas, coffee grinders and other tools. They also produced corsets (not something I expect to find in Lee Valley's antique tool collection).

In 1832 the company was renamed �"Peugeot Fr�res A�n�s" and produced tools for carpenters and turners.

However, as early at 1842, the company was divided by disagreements between the seven cousins. One part of the company was called �Peugeot, Japy et Cie�, and in 1851 it was renamed �Peugeot Fr�res�. It remained in Valentigney and used as its trademark a lion standing over an arrow.

In 1865 this factory was handed over by Jules (1811-1899) and Emile Peugeot (1815 - 1874) to their respective sons Eug�ne and Armand. In 1891, they renamed the company "Les Fils de Peugeot Fr�res" [The Sons of Peugeot Brothers].

In the other part of the company, the four sons of Jean-Fr�d�ric Peugeot (Fritz, Charles, Jacques and Georges) along with the four Jackson brothers from England (William, John, Charles and James) came together under the name "Peugeot A�n�s et Fr�res Jackson�. This company was located at Pont de Roide, and on their plane blades used the trademark of an elephant, sometimes accompanied by the words " V�ritable Pont de Roide�. John and James left the company in 1852. As with some other English steel and tool makers who worked on the Continent, the Jackson brothers had a significant influence on the steelmaking industry in France.

This part of the company was renamed �Peugeot A�n�s� sometime between 1877 and 1899, and in 1894 was renamed �Peugeot et Cie�.

Hundreds of thousands of planes were manufactured each year, but the competition was costly, and in the 1920s, the two halves of the company came together. The products continued to be produced until 1936 when the new name �Etablissements Peugeot Fr�res� was adopted for the combined company. The elephant symbol disappeared in favour of the lion. Chrome-plated steel and plastics came into increasing use. Starting in 1933, electric power tools were produced and hand tool production waned.

During the Second World War, the factories were requisitioned by Volkswagen; they were later bombed and plundered.

After the war, the factories were modernized, and production of hand planes was stopped. In the face of increasing competition by American products, the company joined with its French rival, Goldenberg, under the new name SICFO (Soci�t� industrialist et commerciale fran�aise d'outillage) [or French Industrial and Commercial Tool Company]. SICFO was sold to the British arm of Stanley in 1986. Some power tools are still sold under the name Peugeot.

The first plane blades originated in the 1850s and are marked with �Peugeot Fr�res Valentigne�. The iron bears the name "Peugeot Fr�res� and includes the symbol of a lion, a hand or a half-moon. Sometimes the cap is also marked with �Peugeot fr�res� and a lion. The marks �Peugeot Jackson�, �Peugeot a�n�s� and �Peugeot et Cie� with the picture of an elephant are more easily datable, but apparently they exist only on plane irons. There are also older irons with the words "Peugeot-Japy."

The lion was first registered on 20 November 1858. This symbol stands for the three qualities of the blades: the robustness of saw teeth, the elasticity of the blade and the fast cut. The quality of the steel that was used is reflected in the trademark. The lion was used for forged saws and tools. Later, the present form of the lion was registered as the trademark for cars, bicycles and motorcycles. The half-moon stands for steel kept at a moderate temperature.

Charles R. Smith (who is still learning to master both European and U.S./Canadian hand planes)

Re: What do I have here?

#12

I agree with Stephen *LINK*

Roy Anderson

>There is a company that still makes these types of planes, called a gutter plane or a rounding plane. E.C. Emmerich in Germany. Go to the link and download their pdf catalog and you will find a picture of their gutter plane and a lot of other really, really neat toys. I have one of their scrub planes and it is a joy to use.


http://www.ecemmerich.com/

Re: What do I have here?

#13

Wow! That's certainly more history

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>than I had any right to hope for. Thanks so much for the exposition.

Just above the name on the blade, there is a faint symbol, but it is most assuredly not an elephant or lion. It could very well be a half moon, but the details are too obscured to see clearly. I don't have the heart to scrub away all the patina to get at bare metal.

Whatever the function of the plane, it seems highly likely, based on your reply as well as others, that this plane is cobbled together from a couple sources. Very well could be either a gutter plane or large moulding plane. At any rate, I think it won't see service anymore, just hold an honored place on the shelf to remind me of my grandfather.

Thanks again.

Bruce

Re: What do I have here?

#14

radius

paul womack

>IIRC Adam Cherubini uses (and enjoys) a scrub with a non-flat sole.

IIRC (again) a guy on the OLDTOOLS list had a rounded sole scrub that he claimed was both original and wondrous.

However, the radius on the pictured plane does seem quite extreme.

What would be the diagnostic difference between a gutter plane and a round-soled scrub?

BugBear

Re: What do I have here?

#15

that's what I'm trying to find out

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>It's not apparent in the pics, but the radius is off center. That plus the let in piece ahead of the mouth lead me to believe that the sold has been owner modified.

I've not used it much, but it scrubs off wood like crazy.

Re: What do I have here?

#16

If absolutely nothing else

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>the "measuring and marking" tool chest on the opening page is certainly lustworthy. What a selling concept!

I have one of the ECE block planes, and for reasons unknown have never been able to get it to work for me.

That being said, they have a lot of neat stuff.

Thanks

Bruce

Re: What do I have here?

#17

Re: that's what I'm trying to find out

Cecil Nickerson in Halfmoon Bay

>Was Grandpa a boatbuider? Such planes were used to back out planking in carvel-planked boats. Just my guess.

Cecil

Re: What do I have here?

#18

Nope, not a boat builder

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>He learned cabinet making in Sweden prior to emigrating to the U.S.

Re: What do I have here?

#19

scott grandstaff

gutter

scott grandstaff

>The difference between a gutter plane, an oversized molding plane and a round sole scrub???

Zilch

I needed a very large and deep flute up each side of a handrailing one time.

So I grabbed an underloved wooden jack plane and made a gutter plane out of it.

Took less time to make than it is taking to talk about this particular round soler under discussion, I can tell you that!

It is standard jack length with a decent tote to hang onto and way more radius than the plane shown. I was looking for a deeper flute but if I'd wanted a shallower one the radius shown would have been fine.

Well, I cut the sole, ground the blade, made and installed a new mouth piece,

and it worked my big flutes just fine.

The ballustrade was installed and stands there today.

I have also used the plane for scrubbing a few times. Not my favorite.

I have lately fallen for a flat sole version of the same thing.

Wooden jack with deeply radiused iron and wide open mouth.

There is a copy of that story over at Wiks place under Beware the Worm. (it was a pretty wormy plane to start :)

Round sole scrubs want to wiggle around a some in wild scrubbing action. Harder to drive accurately.

I get better steering, with a flat sole.

yours Scott