Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Slot Morticing at Monticello

Posts

Slot Morticing at Monticello

#1

Slot Morticing at Monticello

David Cockey

>Two small cabinets with shelves at Monticello use "slot mortices" to fasten the ends of the shelves to the side panels. Each side panel has two groove, maybe 5/8" wide, ploughed lengthwise on the inside surface, one near the front and the other near the back. Each shelf has two tenons on each end, sized and positioned to fit into the grooves. Between the shelves in the grooves are thin strips of a contrasting wood which fill the grooves and are flush with the inside surfaces. The strips support the shelves. This may be simplier to build than cutting individual mortices or half-blind dados, though the strips need to be carefully sized for a tight fit.

Bob Self, conservator at Monticello, pointed out this construction during this morning's tour for Working with Wood participants, and this evening at the conference showed a slide of on of the roofs Monticello which uses the same type of construction to locate rafters. The cabinets are thought to have been built at Monticello, and there is speculation that Thomas Jefferson may have built one.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#2

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Interesting. Are these fixed shelves, then - or do you think part of the idea was that, by substituting longer/shorter strips of wood, you could adjust the shelves?

I'm at a loss to understand how this approach could locate rafters, though - I can't think of a framing member that would have the same relationship to the rafters that the sides of a cabinet would have to the shelves.

Thanks for the note on this interesting variation in shelf support.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#3

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

David Cockey

>They appeared to be fixed shelves. I suspect the strips are glued in place. However the same idea could be used with shelves able to be adjusted if the strips were held in place by screws.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#4

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

Dan Sheehan

>If I understand it, imagine you are facing the interior of a bookcase as it lies on its side and its pitched toward you at 45 degrees. The shelves would then resemble the rafters of a 12 pitch roof as you would see them as you stand in the attic.

I can only guess that the groove would be a rabbet along the face of the top plate instead of the usual individual rafter housings and the spacers would define the distance between rafters.

That's how I envision it. I don't see the advantage in the bookcase or in the roof though. But Jefferson was a lot smarter than I am.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#5

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>They look like bridal joints to me. What am I misunderstanding?

Pam

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#6

If I'm understanding David's description,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the maker plowed two grooves in the cabinet sides, as if about to install those long metal shelf supports with the metal clips sitting in little slots, then inserted strips of wood in the grooves to support small tenons on the ends of the first shelf; then more strips to support the second shelf; and so on.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#7

Re: If I'm understanding David's description, *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know (honestly), but I did a search on slot mortise and came up with the link below, search the page for "slot." This example looks more like a bridal joint than anything else.

Pam


Slot Mortise

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#8

Re: If I'm understanding David's description,

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>Bill's description was correct. I saw Bob Self's presentation last night and he showed two uses of this type of construction, one was in a document press(a tall cabinet for document storage) and the other was for rafters in the roof framing. Mr Self, or anyone else, had seen this type of construction mentioned anywhere else.

Jim

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#9

Re: Slot Morticing rafters

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I can see some advantage to a rafter design like that - the rabbet would provide positive registering for the rafters and contribute to good support of the roof. The blocking between would be functionally identical to the pressure blocks used in modern framing.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#10

Nice resource

Dan Donaldson

>That is an interesting page. Thanks for posting it.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#11

Re: If I'm understanding David's description,

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm not saying that Bill's description was incorrect, how would I know. I am saying that the picture I found is more like a bridal joint. Now, is this an incorrect picture? Incorrect terminology? Or something else?

Pam

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#12

Terminology *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'd never seen the term "slot mortise" used for a bridle joint* until this reference, Pam.

David mentioned, in the original post for this thread, that he'd never seen the construction he described - if it's a rare or unique construction, there logically might not have/wouldn't have been a commonly accepted trade term for it.

Terminology is important, of course: without commonly understood meanings of words, we can't communicate, and every trade (in the broadest sense of that word, from custodial work to particle physics) has to develop its unique language to avoid 1,000 word descriptions of every step of every process. The trouble begins when someone, like Thomas Jefferson, introduces a new concept/construction/detail that has no existing word.

*I was raised to spell it "bridle" - no idea of the etymology. Speculatively, I suppose, it could refer to the tenon fitting in the open mortise like a bridle fits in a horse's mouth. "Bridal" seems to be a modern, common spelling.


Wikipedia's description

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#13

Re: Terminology

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>"Bridle" makes a lot more sense; but then I still can't seem to accept "rabbet" for "rebate," which also makes a lot more sense.

I'd love to see some pictures of what David, et al, are calling a "slot mortise."

Pam

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#14

Bridle joint a.k.a. Open Mortice and Tenon joint

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Pam/Bill,

I know them as bridle joints. 'Bridal' is probably a phonetic spelling, propagated through the internet. I've never seen it in any print publication.

An alternative name that I've seen is an Open Mortice and Tenon.

Slot mortising, in my experience, is a term reserved for a machine operation, where a mortice is cut with a slot mortising bit into both components, and a loose tenon/tongue inserted into both mortices. A Festool Domino is a portable slot mortiser

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#15

Re: Bridle joint a.k.a. Open Mortice and Tenon joi

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, so where did Thomas Jefferson get a Domino? :)

Pam

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#16

At least you don't call them "rabbits"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>one of the misspellings that always shocks my inner English teacher

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#17

So we may have a multiple meaning problem here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Sounds like "slot mortise" may have more than one meaning. Could be confusing.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#18

Why, from the games table of course *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Sorry, couldn't resist...

Dominoes date to 1120, apparently.


Per wikipedia

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#19

Re: Terminology

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think David's description is good, but many have misunderstood and the slot mortise name is misleading. What the cabinetmaker did was plough two vertical grooves in each carcass side, front and back, and make strips that just fit into the grooves. By cutting up the strips into short pieces and gluing them in the grooves, he formed mortises to hold the shelves.

This system is faster than making a bunch of individual mortises. I recommended it on this forum last year for a fellow who was making a piece with rows of slats in mortises.

Not a slot mortise; not a bridle joint.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#20

Finally, I see it. Thanks, Warren.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Although it sounds like fitting the slots to make sufficiently tight mortises might get a little fiddly.

Pam

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#21

Well, he was a man ahead of his time.

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#22

Bob Self's term

David Cockey

>Bob Self used the term "slot mortising" to describe this construction. Bob is the conservator at Monticello and also extremely knowledgable about furniture associated with Thomas Jefferson.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#23

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

David Cockey

>Was my description in my original post that unclear? I assume you read the post and not just the title.

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

#24

Re: Slot Morticing at Monticello

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Was my description in my original post that unclear? I assume you read the post and not just the title.

Frankly, since you ask, yes. First you called it slot mortising, as did the presenter. Very confusing for anyone who knows anything about the various machines available for woodworking. Second, you talked about "thin" strips of wood inserted in the grooves. Third you mention shelf mortises being inserted into the grooves. Fourth, by this time I was thoroughly confused and befuddled. I would guess that if I had seen the presentation, there would be no issues (except for the utility of such a manufactured joint). Yes, I read the entire message, several times because it was clear that you knew what you were writing about.

Whenever I'm confused and think something useful is being said, I pursue it. I also think that my confusion is not unique, so the later exposition may have helped others to understand it. If you reread Warren's message near the end of the thread, you may learn something about how to describe a woodworking technique. And given that the vast majority of us weren't there, a simple little drawing or a photo of a mockup would have gone a long way.

Pam