Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Don't do this to a Japanese saw

Posts

Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#1

Don't do this to a Japanese saw

wilbur

>A little while ago I had an accident with my Heiji ryoba. In a nutshell, I was making a crosscut and got carried away with sawing. I pulled the ryoba so that it exited the kerf, and as I pushed the saw back to make the return stroke, it caught on the board, bent, and snapped off the corner on the crosscut side of the ryoba.



OUCH! I felt terrible. This was completely due to my being stupid, and to preempt any discussion about how Japanese saws are just too flimsy, I'm sure the same thing would have happened if I had done the same sort of thing to a western backsaw. But I wound up learning something pretty incredible about handmade Japanese saws, given their reputation for being fragile.

I emailed So Yamashita, from japan-tool.com about this, and to my surprise he said this could be repaired. He helped me send the ryoba back to Heiji, the saw maker. Apparently Heiji sent the saw to his guy who does welding, and a piece of saw blade material was welded onto the broken corner. Then Heiji rescraped and retuned that part of the saw. The process took about a month, and this is what I got back.



I can barely see where the repair was made, and the main clue that there was a repair is that the scraping marks follow a sightly different pattern than on the main part of the saw blade. I can see this if I look closely, but I tried to photograph the change in scraping pattern, and it just doesn't show up well in a picture.

Of course you would think that I would be much more careful with this ryoba since I already broke it once and had just gotten it back. Instead, the first thing I did was to try it out on crosscutting some white oak, although I was more careful not to pull the saw out of the kerf this time.


Pretty incredible quality of cut, if I do say so myself.

I don't know how much the repair will cost me. I emailed So telling him that I got the ryoba back and that it was working great. He hasn't even sent me a PayPal invoice yet. When I first emailed him about this, he estimated that the repair would be about $75-80. Quite a bargain, I would say.

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#2

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Wow!! What a great story! We can fix that! That So-san is such a fine person.

And Heiji--holy cow, that is a beautiful surface on that saw body! And the cut looks as though it has been planed.

Really happy for you, Wilbur. Thanks for sharing this. Fixing stuff is a category that isn't talked about so much.

Wiley

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#3

What incredible skill!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>That's nearly invisible.

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#4

Re: What incredible skill!

Tony Z.

>Beautiful repair!

For a "ham and egger" such as myself, I probably would have taken the saw to a belt sander and simply rounded off the break! However, saws I have are not anywhere of the quality of yours.

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#5

Great save!

Hank Knight

>Great save, Wilbur! I'm glad you Heji san was able to repair your saw. I winced when I saw the break because know how much you love that saw.

That's a nice way to start off the New Year. Have a happy one.

Hank

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#6

Re: What incredible skill!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Don't know about a belt sander, but I'd certainly ease the broken edges and get on with it. However, I'm glad Wilbur isn't such a penny pincher, that patch is something else, truly wonderful.

I wonder if there's something about ryoba that makes them more fragile. I had this problem with a handmade version, too, but not so hand made that the vendor balked at replacing mine. Good thing, too, since as I continued to use mine it continued breaking, right down to the unedged part. I've never had the problem with single sided Japanese saws.

Pam

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#7

Re: Great save!

Edward in Vancouver

>That is a nice repair.

I've shy-ed away from japanese saws for a while because I am fairly ham-handed, and the one Japanese saw that I DID have was constantly losing teeth, so I'd just go to L.V an buy a replacement blade. This happened about 3 or 4 times and I have a drawer full of toothless blades to prove it. Then in the middle of one project I bent the blade just under the support, and a fairly large crack appeared. The teeth were fine, but the blade would snap in two if I continued to use it. I "repaired" it by cannablizing a 1" stip of metal from one of the toothless blades and silver soldering it over the crack. It looks like a nightmare but it still cuts well, and I've since learned never to use that saw for hardwoods ever again.....

Re: Don't do this to a Japanese saw

#8

A real bargain!

wilbur

>I just got the invoice for the repair. The repair itself was �4950. To save you from running to a currency converter website, that's $54 at today's exchange rate.

I can't believe that's all it was, for the amount of work and skill it would take for this repair. Put it this way: the price of shipping the saw to Japan and back cost more.