Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Matsumara chisel question

Posts

Matsumara chisel question

#1

Matsumara chisel question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I don't know the innies and outies of Japanese chisels, but I have had this Matsumara white steel chisel from JapanWoodworker for a couple years. About the only thing I've used it for is to square up the ends of mortises cut by my r**ter. I got that particular one because I was told I could whack on it and that it would work well for this application.

Well, I went to use it the other day and discovered that it is bent. Not much, mind you, but bent nonetheless. Are these things supposed to bend? I don't put much pressure on any chisel, preferring to pare down the ends of those mortises. I happen to like craftsman style furniture so there tend to be a lot of mortises.

Can this chisel be straightened without deleterious effects?

Perplexed in gradually warming MN (not much mind you, but +22F is better than -10F)

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#2

Define 'bent'

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bruce,

Japanese chisels frequently have the cutting head at a slight angle to the handle. So if you're looking at it in side view, and place the back of the cutting section flat on the work, the handle will angle up a bit from horizontal. All of my bench chisels and paring slicks are this way; only the mortise chisels are truly straight. The variation in angle differs by maker; for example, my Funahiro paring slicks are more 'bent' than the Imai ones, and therefore provide greater handle clearance.

I'm imagining the purpose of this is to create a bit of hand clearance. Is what I'm describing above what you mean by 'bent'?

Wiley

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#3

nope

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I realize the cutting surface is offset, but what I'm talking about is a curve of the flattened surface, perhaps as much as 1 mm evenly faired over the 2" length of the hollowed back. It used to be more, but I tried to straighten it somewhat. Then it occurred to me that this might be a really good way to break the blade. Here's a pic, but I'm not sure it will come through.

BTW, it is clamped to a really nice piece of apple that Jack Guzman sent me to fix a couple (now up to 3) saw totes.

Bruce


img

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#4

Uff da! Where is Dave Burnard?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Never tried to fix one like that before. Cold working it down through the soft backing with a hammer comes to mind. Maybe Dave could advise, if he sees this, as well on the possibility of bending RC62+ steel.

Wiley

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#5

I have to congratulate you

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>on the proper use of "uffda!"

I hope Dave sees this.

Thanks, Wiley.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#6

That`s bent alright!

Bob Hackett

>It may well work to your advantage in certain circumstances.

Boat builder`s slicks have a little "rocker" or bend to them just like that.That rocker allows you to lever up and out of a cut if need be.

I`ve straightened laminated domestic chisels back to flat but I don`t have any experience with Japanese laminated chisels so I`ll let others offer solutions rather than risk your iron.

MB

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#7

Re: That`s bent alright!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bob,

What did you do to straighten other laminated chisels? This is a good topic.

WIley

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#8

Does it no longer do the job for you?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#9

Straightening with caution

Bob Hackett

>There`s 2 reasons I didn`t post my approach under this thread.1-because I have NOT straightened a Japanese chisel,so I have NO experience with them.2-having no experience with dealing with a chisel with a ground hollow in the back I don`t know if there are other stresses involved with them that may put them at risk using this approach.

That being said,here goes.

Those of you who think New England was always populated by fine craftsmen who always knew what they were about should look at my abused tools box,and it`s a BIG box.The tools there say otherwise.

A lot of these chisels have been hammered into wood till they were hopelessly stuck.I don`t know if it was frustration,desperation or just stupidity but once they were stuck they were beat anywhere that would accept a hammer blow in an attempt to free them.

Long story short,they`re anything but straight when I get them.

Looking at the amount of abuse tells me two things.

1-a rough idea of how hard the tools steel is.Softer steel takes more abuse,harder chips and cracks under side blows.

2-If it`s really beat it`s probably been stressed to it`s limits and won`t take much more abuse while straightening.

This info and the type of bend decides my approach.

If the bend is over the length of the back and the chisel has only moderate abuse them I`ve had good luck using my bench vise as a press and using 3 pieces of copper(I suppose hardwood would work too)I slowly press the bend out.

If the chisel has seen a lot of abuse and I`m worried about stressing it further then it`s usually because it`s been really beat and I`ll have to regrind all over anyway so my approach changes.I work the face of the chisel(the soft side)till I`ve moved enough metal to straighten it.This technique lends more control and I can work out small kinks or bumps in the tool steel this way.Think of tapping out a Japanese plane iron(I have successfully done that).

If it`s a top notch chisel(Whitherby,Swan,Underhill,etc)of reasonably good length that has a kink in it or is really stressed then I go to heat.Either a torch or the forge to anneal and stress relieve then straighten and grind.Then heat and quench to "full hard" and temper in the toaster oven to draw off to the hardness I`m looking for.

If I could figure out how to reduce the size of files so I could post them here then I`d be happy to include pics but it keeps telling me the files are too large to post.If anyone would like pics I could send them in an e-mail.I`ve at least been able to get that far in my ongoing fight with technology.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#10

Thats a very rare Japanese cooper's chisel.

Victor Parisian

>List it on E-bay. Could pay for a semester of college. Then again maybe not.

Haven't the foggiest idea as to how to straighten it.

Victor.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#11

Re: Straightening with caution

Dan Donaldson

>If you want to email me the pictures, I will process them for you to get them so they can be posted. If you do so, send the originals before anything has been done to them. (as big as possible)

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#12

Re: Straightening with caution

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Well, I have a ten-ton press at work, but I'm not sure I could use it with any finesse.

I did successfully straighten a 1/4" thick leaf spring to make a bowie knife. Will that work? :-)

Seriously, if it can be straightened, I'd much prefer to do that. It's better than having to discard a tool.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#13

Re: Does it no longer do the job for you?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Obviously, the chisel still cuts. It irks me that something as thick as this chisel would bend at all, but mostly it's because I depend on a straight back to register against the surface when I pare. Or even when I chop. My much thinner Bergs haven't bent when doing the same operation, which is why I got this Matsumara. Maybe my expectations are too high.

Any input on what I should expect would be extremely gratefully accepted. I just need to know what it can do. I don't even know anyone else in MN who uses Japanese chisels, although there's bound to be someone.

Thanks

Bruce

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#14

Hi Bruce,

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>How old is this chisel?

You might want to contact The Japan Woodworker and ask/ talk to them about it they may replace it or know how to straighten it out.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#15

Re: Does it no longer do the job for you?

Darin

>I don't think you bent it. I vaguely remember reading that sometimes a flaw in the manufacturing process will cause this to happen. I found one like that is a set of chisels I had setting in the box for several years unused, no problem exchanging it.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#16

Re: Does it no longer do the job for you?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know Matsumura chisels at all; but I think Dave Burnard uses them. I do know that it's important to use a chisel for its intended task; so when face with a mortise to cut, I use a mortise chisel and have never had one bend on me, eastern or western. I don't use the drill and pare method as my attempts at that fit badly and it's just too fiddly; but I see nothing in the process to bend a chisel, even a regular bench chisel. And yet, yours did, maybe.

In looking over Japan Woodworker's Matsumura chisel selection, they offer regular bench, dovetail (shinogi) bench, and fishtail (bachi nomi) bench; but nothing stronger, which is what I'd aim for to do your task.

Pam

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#17

Agree

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I don't think Bruce bent it. It's too regular of a curve for one thing. Looks exactly like it came from the vendor that way. If it's going to bend, it will bend at a weak point, not in a continuous curve over the stoutest part of the chisel. And nothing will bend from light paring or chopping off thin slices.

Wiley

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#18

Pam asked a good question

Bob Hackett

>What is it that you most use this chisel for?

Have you tried using it as is?

I understand it will not work as it used to but that doesn`t mean it won`t work with a modified approach.

As I said about slicks,having a bit of rocker to the blade and a slightly crowned edge made these tools more user friendly.

When I turn a 2" paring chisel into a "mini slick" I make these modifications and also bend the socket up some so it and the handle clear the work.

The folks I``ve made them for favor them after they master the short learning curve and stop trying to use them like their other paring chisels.

MB

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#19

If it absolutely needs to be flat

Bob Hackett

>I`d start by flattening the forward area to as far back as you need to have it register for the jobs you do.

The hollow ground in the back is proof that the entire back doesn`t need to be dead flat.You only need enough flat to register within your comfort zone.

As the blade is used up it`ll get more flat till it gets back to normal(only shorter).

MB-Who excells at stating the obvious.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#20

scott grandstaff

Re: Agree *LINK*

scott grandstaff

>Mee too

Pretty sure Bruce didn't bend it. Unless there was a cheater piece of iron pipe 18" long involved in the prying, or a three pound sledge! heh ehh

There is always red heat and bend it back??

Harden and retemper anew?? I've done it. Not impossible

Like Bob, I use the three point and press routine most of the time. I get around 80% success this way. Once in a while one snaps. Comes with the territory.

With this finicky Japanese one? I'd set up my chisel back grinder. A cup wheel and a drill press can get you there. See the link. You'd lose the hollow grinding these are famous for, but oh well.

yours Scott


grinding chisel backs flat

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#21

Not so sure

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>The bend used to be more, I straightened it somewhat. I sharpened it a couple times and I do recall that I was able to hone the whole back.

I will use it as is, and just learn to cut without registering the whole back.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#22

Re: Pam asked a good question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I got it as I didn't have a good 1/2" that could be whacked. (that was before I got a set of Hirsch firmers that DO take a whacking). Also, I had no experience with Japanese chisels and thought that would be a good introduction.

The blade is very hard, takes a very good edge (still chips a bit though - I'll have to experiment with blade angles), but is just curved along the length. Just have to get used to it. I work almost entirely with domestic hardwoods, ash, oak, maple and walnut.

My unstated part of the question has to do with the difference between the softer iron and hard blade. I'm fairly certain that I can bend it back into some semblance of flat, but will it crack the hard steel part?

Next time I experiment with chisels, it'll be a Blue Spruce.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#23

Thank you all for a great discussion

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I've learned a lot.

Bruce, getting used to the cold, finally.

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#24

Re: Hi Bruce,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Scott,

It's three years old. I haven't used it all that much, but it worked well for my intended purpose. It probably would be good to at least talk to JWW. Exchange might work, but I'm far more inclined to learn how to fix something rather than just keep swapping it out for something perfect.

Bruce

Re: Matsumara chisel question

#25

Will it crack?

Bob Hackett

>That depends on the type of steel,the hardness and how much internal stress the steel is fighting now.

I`m guessing that there`s a fair amount of stress involved as it has already caused the chisel to bend.The fact that you are trying to work against that stress means you will be adding more.Will the combined stress be enough to crack the tool steel?Only one way to tell.

The safe approach would be to abrade material from the back rather than test your luck with bending.

I`d do what others have suggested and contact the person you bought this chisel from.Maybe they`ll exchange for another,if not then how do they suggest you fix the one you have?If you follow their directions and the chisel either snaps due to bending or rebends after careful grinding then at least you know what not to buy next time.

Hopefully you didn`t spend a lot of cash for the chisel.

MB