Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Ebay and postage charges

Posts

Ebay and postage charges

#1

Ebay and postage charges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

I like ebay a lot. And just about never check up on postage charges. Do you? For no particular reason, I checked the last two buys. I back-checked Ebay's postage calculator against the USPS published rates for the item as shipped. When you receive the item, say it's priority mail, it may not be showing the postage paid by the shipper, but it will show the weight, and the sending ZIP code. Plug those numbers into the USPS calculator, along with your own ZIP, and you find out what the sender actually paid USPS.

On my packages, the discrepancy was about $2 on one package, and $4 on the second. In favor of the seller.

Questions: Those Ebay postage figures--where do they come from? The implication when you look at the posted figure, is that it is an actual USPS postage figure. But who is inputting the weight and package dimension figures, to generate those numbers?

Well, it's not the end of the world if I pay $12 for Priority Mail, versus an actual of $8. I'll just give the guy a 3 on his 'reasonable shipping cost' feedback item. I figure the first two bucks is on the house, since I don't expect him to work for nothing, and a $2 packing fee seems OK to me.

But I am getting a little more curious about how automated procedures can be so effective in increasing costs. You see, it's not the vendor copping a couple extra bucks--it's the calculator's fault. Ingenious.

By the way, and this experience I'm relating may not be typical. I checked a third guy's charge, and he was a little low. Shipped from Maine.

Suggestion: Check the next couple of Ebay packages you receive, for charged versus actual shipping. See what you find out.

Wiley

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#2

Transparency in shipping

Bob Hackett

>Don`t know how it is in the rest of the world but here in non-urban Maine about the easiest and cheapest way to ship is by the US postal service.

If I know it`ll fit in a large flat rate box then that`s what I quote for shipping.If not then I let the buyer know what the shipping will be and I ask if they would like a receipt for the shipping.

The few things I`ve had to crate(MC parts)I`ve set an estimate for the materials and time and include that in the auction as a crating fee.If it`s more then I figure it`s my bad and I eat the cost.

If shipping seems higher than norm when I`m buying I ask the seller if they can ship it in a flat rate box,if not then I pass.There`s no doubt in my mind that some folks are using inflated shipping to pad their profit margin.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#3

Re: Ebay and postage charges

wilbur

>Although the issues with eBay shipping quotes is annoying, I'm not sure it's any different than dealing with shipping costs from any other woodworking vendor out there. All the woodworking vendors that sell on the Internet that I know of charge a shipping fee based on the cost of the items purchased, not the actual cost of shipping. The cost based shipping fee is nearly always more than the actual cost of shipping.

It could be argued that the woodworking vendors are factoring in the cost of shipping materials, but this would apply to the eBay sellers as well.

Back when gas was costing $4.00 a gallon, I learned to get over the whole shipping cost issue for the most part when I realized that I would spend twice as much on gas and tolls to get to the nearest Woodcraft as I would pay for shipping. I also learned not to sweat over paying return shipping fees if I needed to return something. If I buy a pair of jeans from the mall, and need to return them, the Gap doesn't reimburse me for the gas I use driving back to the mall.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#4

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Dale Stansbery

>When you list an ad on Ebay, shipping and handling charges are added into the shipping calculator results that the customer sees. In the last year, Ebay no longer allows the seller to make insurance optional, but still holds the seller responsible to the customer's door. Therefor, I imagine most sellers add the insurance fee as a handling and shipping charge, I do.

I've found the shipping calculator to be very accurate for the USPS part of the shipping charge.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#5

Re: Ebay and postage charges

ron

>Did you allow for the packing material and the box??

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#6

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Marv

>Wiley,

If the seller prints out a label, the weight can be changed to increase the shipping cost. If the calulator was figured at 3 pounds for example, the seller can merely up it to 4 pounds.

Another factor to consider is, the Post Office always rounds the fraction of a pound up to the next higher number.

Another factor is, it is cheaper to print out a label than if the package is taken to a post office. Also, the people working at the post office will sometimes charge the wrong amount. It's not always the seller's fault. You should email the seller and question what you think is an over-charge. Those star ratings are very damaging to a seller. Some sellers are crooks, but most mean well.

Marv

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#7

Hedging their bets, er, bids . . .

steve mackay

>While I see a lot of things I'd bid on as a great deal, now days I make sure I look at the shipping charges. Lets say, a $10 dollar tool. Hey, great deal. Scroll down to the shipping charge . . . $25 ! So the $10 dollar tool is costing me $35. Never mind. Then theres those flat rate boxes. If I see that and I run away. I know sellers are hedging their bets by posting high shipping charges but come on. Are they still doing the biz they did before ? I doubt it. I ship 12 pound models from El Paso to Fort Lewis, FED-EX, for $9. AND its there in four days opposed to two weeks USPS. I keep the price down to keep my customers. Basic business. Learned THAT by the age of ten.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#8

Re: Hedging their bets, er, bids . . .

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've found Fed-Ex and UPS to be more expensive for individuals than for people in businesses. What shipping I do, I do by USPS, though I do parcel post as little as possible.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#9

Matters not . . .

steve mackay

>I ship as an "individual". Average person can walk into the FED-EX place and ship the same as a business. If you can handle the teenagers working there, Kinko's will do in a pinch as well as a number of other outlets or stores.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#10

Matters alot

Bob Hackett

>When every town has a post office it`s a whole lot cheaper to use it than to drive 45 minutes(one way)to the nearest Kinko`s.

I guess it`s the same old set of blinders.Folks in rural areas think everybody is helpful and honest.Folks in suburbia think everything`s just around the corner,just remember to lock your car when you leave it.;^)

MB-Who hasn`t locked his house in 10 years and leaves the keys in the truck in case someone needs to move it.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#11

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Dale,

Very helpful. That explains the numbers. One thing I like about the new system--you get to look at the postage figure before you bid. One thing I don't like--I'd rather not pay for insurance. Way it goes, though....

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#12

You're right

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

Correct as usual. Nobody else explains their shipping charges. They tell you what it is, and you can pay it or not. Which is where Ebay has ended up. I think I still have the 'flea market' paradigm in mind for Ebay, but Ebay is putting as much distance as possible between themselves and 'on line flea market'. Hey, this is a high class joint here....

Wiley

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#13

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, when buying I'd rather not pay for insurance either, have always considered it a for-the-seller thing.

Pam

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#14

Guys, FedEx bought Kinko's a few years ago.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#15

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I always check the postage and often don't bid if the postage is too high (I used to try to convince a seller to decrease the postage, but no longer bother). For the last year or so, Royal Mail was so expensive that I stopped buying from UK sellers, I mean like 3 and 4 times an item price, quite outrageous.

Funny, I have almost no tolerance for the average "flea market" seller trying to recoup all shipping costs, s/he's just trying to unload some stuff s/he no longer needs and should be happy to sell it at all :); whereas for the professional seller with a business I can let it go a bit.

Generally, as ebay ages and grows bigger (say by buying Paypal), I like it less and less.

Pam

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#16

Also . . .

steve mackay

>I get by but I'm not up on new technology and the operating system behind Da' Bay seems to get bigger and bigger (ie : slower and slower). And I wish they'd stop changing it every couple weeks.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#17

UPS sometimes charges for rural delivery too...

John in NM

>Though I don't use them often, I have had this happen - extra $5. I'm not sure I've ever shipped UPS for less than $10, USPS is great for a lot of stuff, just got to know the ins and outs (very small boxes are cheaper 1st class than PP if you can believe it).

On keys in cars - I used to do that when I lived in Orono. I was coming back from the dump in dad's truck one day, and I saw a Saab on the side of the road with the hood up - a normal state of affairs I knew, because I had a very similar one. So I stop to see if I could help, and notice by the primered quarter panel that it is in fact my car. It seems a couple friends had come over looking for a ride, and since I wasn't there, they'd borrowed the car - if I'd owned a reliable car I never would have caught them!

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#18

Kinkos gone - FedEx Office now

Tony - Memphis

>

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#19

Hilarious story!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#20

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Todd Hughes

>"Questions: Those Ebay postage figures--where do they come from? The implication when you look at the posted figure, is that it is an actual USPS postage figure. But who is inputting the weight and package dimension figures, to generate those numbers"

The postage calculator on ebay auctions doesn't have to represent actual postage costs...the seller can set it up to reflect his "Handling Charges" If he charges $3 handling charges and the actual postage is $10 the calculator will show postage to be $13

I charge actual postage, always have....and I still have 4.8 stars for postage charges...go figure....guess some people expect me to pay for postage out of my pocket which was what Ebay suggested I do last time i talked to somebody from there.

Very infrequently I might be slightly off if the item is on the cusp so to speak...but not very often as I weigh everything pretty good. Just as likely to not charge enough as I am to charge to much

I have gotten a negative because I over charged by 48 cents once!...a friend got one because she over charged by 50 cents

....Now that I have to pay paypal fees and be responsiable for insurance I am really thinking about start charging a couple bucks for a "handling fee" to try to make up for it all....Todd

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#21

What I've learned from this thread

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks for explaining all that, Todd. Both yours and Dale's descriptions make a big difference to me, in the way I look at the seller's situation. And particularly the seller's new situation with respect to Ebay and Paypal. There are additional fees to be paid, plus they make you responsible to the doorstep--at some point, that responsibility will jump up and cost you a refund. It's a real cost.

So I kinda understand now. I don't think I will give that guy a '3' on reasonable charges. It's not that big of a deal, and his costs are up.

Just to give you a data point, my threshhold for even noticing something's up is $4. If it's $2 over actual postage, that is under the radar.

Wiley

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#22

Re: Ebay and postage charges

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"Funny, I have almost no tolerance for the average "flea market" seller trying to recoup all shipping costs, s/he's just trying to unload some stuff s/he no longer needs and should be happy to sell it at all :); whereas for the professional seller with a business I can let it go a bit."

I have a slightly different take. The unit cost of packing materials for a small seller is likely to be higher than for a major seller - so it may cost him/her more in materials to prepare the package for shipping. And, if s/he doesn't have a "shipping room," labor time to prepare is likely to be higher too (I don't sell on eBay, but I do ship stuff from time to time, and my shipping room is the dining room table, which means setup and cleanup after - more time than if I had a permanent setup).

Ridiculously high shipping charges* are a problem for me, regardless of who proposes to charge them; but whether someone's a vest-pocket or a multinational corporation, I have no issue with reasonable ones.

Naturally, I prefer no charges...

*There was a recent eBay posting for three planes that could easily be packed in a flat rate priority mail box, roughly $15. The seller indicated an intent to mail by priority mail and listed a shipping charge of $30. That's a bit much, in my opinion. The final price was almost 50% shipping charge.

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#23

Why does shipping cost percentage matter?

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

If I did my math correctly with your eBay example, with the $30 shipping cost, the final price would be $60 for three planes, shipped to your door, or $20 per plane. In the final analysis, shouldn't the final cost to you be all that matters?

As an admittedly silly example of where I'm coming from, suppose I post a mint condition Stanley #1 on eBay with a Buy It Now price of $30, with a shipping fee of $170. Would my ridiculous shipping cost prevent you from getting a mint Stanley #1 for $200?

Again, my feeling is that the shipping cost is irrelevant. What matters is the total cost of the thing you're buying, shipping included. Of course, if there's a free shipping sale, I'll be happy to take advantage of that. :@)

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#24

Re: Why does shipping cost percentage matter?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, sure, total cost to me is a big deal; but if I thought I could reduce that cost by complaining about shipping costs, I used to complain. Now I just don't bid.

I bought two things today (actually 4, will explain in a minute). The first was that wooden saw vise that Marv put us on to. The seller kept raising the price after it didn't sell once or twice and the shipping cost was about $14, probably not that far off actual given its size. Finally I emailed him/her and asked if s/he'd sell it for $30 total, including shipping. Agreement, so it's on its way.

Second case was actually 3 Buy Now items from eastwesttools, a Hiroki hammer, hishiki saw, and a sliding t-bevel with a notch for plane blades for testing plane soles. The first item had $0 shipping, each of the next two $3; but the seller gave back the $6 shipping. Pretty nice.

So I'm a bit of a happy camper this week. Also found two Vespas ('78 P200E and '80 100/100 Sport), both in great condition, for a total of $600. So I can sell the little one to cover everything I might have to do for the big one, including giving it a sidecar so I can take Baldric to the park in it. Cool.

Pam

Re: Ebay and postage charges

#25

It doesn't except emotionally

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I suspect I'm not alone in being conditioned to think of shipping charges as being a small fraction of total costs.

Yes, I looked at those planes - one was quite pretty, but not essential to my life - and decided against a bid because of the projected total cost.