Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

New DT Saws

Posts

New DT Saws

#1

New DT Saws

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Every couple of years I get an order for a �long range tackle box�. This is a fishing tackle box for fishermen who take long fishing trips (generally out of San Diego) to Mexico and Central America. These trips last anywhere from 6-30 days and the fisherman has to bring everything he/she might need as there are no tackle shops along the way.

The box on which I�ve been working has 15 small drawers ranging in size from 2.5h x 6w x 14d up to 5h x 14w x 14d. All of the drawer fronts are 3/8� thick and the sides are �� thick.

I�ve been putting the drawers off but upon receiving my two new DT saws from Lee Valley I decided to put in a couple of hours last evening.

I first tried the 20 tpi saw. All I can say is WOW! Thin, straight kerfs with virtually no tear out on the back side. I rarely go straight from the saw to assembly but after the first couple of drawers I decided to give it a try. With just a few minor adjustments I was able to assemble the next drawer with almost no trimming � the extra stroke needed on each cut (due to high tooth count) was way more than compensated by the absence of fitting and fussing.

I was so thrilled with the 20 tpi saw I just had to make a few cuts with the 14 tpi. Same deal. Straight, thin kerfs and no tear out.

Derek has more than adequately covered the technical points on these saws in his fine reviews. My additional 2 cents is in the way of saying �� you were right, these are really good tools worth a lot more than their very reasonable cost.� Thank you Derek for your excellent review; this was the push I needed to acquire these saws and I couldn�t be happier. The 14 degree rake sure makes a difference with ease of starting the cut.

If anyone is looking for a new saw I recommend both of these without reservation.

In case you�re wondering about the tackle box: they typically weigh about 65-75 #s unloaded and as much as 200#s loaded. They take anywhere from 100 to 150 hours to build. I look forward to receiving an order for one of these, but I wouldn�t want to build more than one every year or so � everything is so fussy that one little lapse of concentration can cause a lot of extra work (for instance: all of the drawer fronts are cut from one, wide cocobolo board and the grain is continuous from top to bottom and side to side so one bunged up drawer front can be quite a challenge to correct).

RJ

Re: New DT Saws

#2

How about a picture

Dan Donaldson

>That sounds like a very interesting project.

Re: New DT Saws

#3

Re: How about a picture

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Dan ... I probably have another 90 hours to put in between now and late February (other jobs are higher on the list), but I'll post a picture when I'm done ... rj

Re: New DT Saws

#4

Compared to Japanese Saws?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I've heard good things about the new Veritas saws. How would you say they compare to a decent Japanese saw? Just curious...thanks

Tom

Re: New DT Saws

#5

Photo of tackle box PLEASE

Ron

>

Re: New DT Saws

#6

Re: Compared to Japanese Saws?

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Tom .... I'm not the right person to compare them.

I used Japanese saws for about 10 years, when my grandfathers saw was down to about 3/4" of blade at the toe and 1" at the heel and before good saws started to become available. I went to an IT saw when I started seeing good comments on the "Porch" website.

I never became entirely comfortable with Japanese saw (having used a good western saw for over 30 years). I think the folks who like Japanese saws either started out with them, or they have a lot better "hand-eye coordination" and "muscle memory" than I do.

Compared to the IT saw I have to give the nod to the Veritas, mostly because of ease of starting and a bit more smooth cutting. The IT is a bit faster, but I'm getting to be an old man and I'm not fast at anything anymore.

RJ

Re: New DT Saws

#7

Thanks

Dan Donaldson

>Waiting patiently......

Re: New DT Saws

#8

Re: New DT Saws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>RJ, which saw do you recommend for these drawers? It sounds like they do an equally good job.

Pam

Re: New DT Saws

#9

Re: New DT Saws

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Pam,

When I built the first 4 drawers I used the 20tpi saw and it worked beautifully.

When I tried out the 14tpi saw it was with a scrap of 3/4" material; I also made a few cuts with the 20tpi - they both worked well, but the 20tpi was definitely a bit slower (maybe 1-2 more strokes to reach a depth of 3/4").

Were I to buy just one saw, I'd probably go with the 20tpi for it's advantage in thinner material and just put up with the slower cutting rate in thicker material. This is a personal preference based on the fact that I am using thinner material for drawers these days: for someone working in, primarily, 1/2"+ material I'd probably go with the 14tpi.

I should say that I did not try the 14tpi saw in 1/4" and 3/8" material - with it's 14 degrees of rake, it might work just fine. My IT definitely struggled a bit with thin material. In fact I'd been using my grandfather's saw lately, which has been sharpened and jointed so many times over the years that it can barely reach 3/4" depth now - this saw is 15tpi and has some rake (not sure how much, as this spec is new to me and I had never previously considered it's affect on ease of starting and smoothness of cut - I didn't even know it was called "rake").

RJ

Re: New DT Saws

#10

Re: Compared to Japanese Saws?

Alex Grigoriev

>At a recent WW show, at LV booth, I tried rip Dozuki and it was very pleasant to use for DT. One can't go wrong with either LV saw, or Dozuki. Or both.

Re: New DT Saws

#11

Re: Compared to Japanese Saws?

ThomD

>Japanese saws are way better on the same basis that comparing a given American car, to all Japanese cars would be a tough comparison.

I like several things about the Veritas saw. The handle is very comfortable to me, and the composite back is very nice on those days when the starting temp in the shop is 33 degrees. Blade is very good also, I really like the IT blade because it is so fast, but that is just a temperament thing, there aren't going to be any real points in it. Whether one says "for the price..." or leaves that out, the Veritas saw is the real deal. Now if it just came with a Sharkskin handle...

On a more serious note, I don't think sawing dovetails is all that tough a tool test, not on cabinets. I can cut them with hacksaws, Sandvick tool pail saws etc... I am not saying it is all so easy, but they are very short cuts. Where the Japanese saws come into their own is on high ratio cuts. Consider a cut where the ratio between the kerf size, set, blade width, and the length of cut is all against you. That is where 500 dollars + of hand tensioning will pay you dividends - if for some reason you can't cut it some other way. And I use the bandsaw for that stuff for the most part. It is cheaper to own an Italian bandsaw than a couple of the better hand saws.

Also. I can't think of any category where Japanese tools (saws planes chisels) aren't still the leaders, but when all this comparison started, maybe in the 70s, the western tools we had were all junk, pretty much 100% down the line. Ah yes, the good old days, when you had to hand lap a cast iron plane on your coffee table to get it to work... Before Rob took over at LV, and yet when email was in all our offices, I emailed Leonard Lee, and said, your catalog offerings are fantastic, but there is not a single plane, hand saw, or chisel you offer that is of tolerable quality (no LV planes, dropped japanese chisels at the time, and the german planes). It was some kind of black hole I suppose in the late 90s (I have all my emails since Win.'97 so before that). He emailed back and said they were on it and getting some new stuff in Japan. Now look where we are. There are lots of lines of tools that anyone could use to do good work. It is amazing.

Re: New DT Saws

#12

Veritas DT saw versus Veritas dozuki

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Here is a picture (one of several) I did not post in the review of the 20 tpi dovetail saw I recently published.

It compares the Veritas 20 tpi dovetail saw with the Veritas rip dozuki.


What you see here is that the thinner-bladed dozuki (18 tpi, 0.015") was more likely to follow the grain than the Western saw (20 tpi, 0.020"). The dozuki cut FAST .. wow! It is a very nice saw. I have had this one a long time. My precautionary note is that it is excellent for thin boards cutting dovetails where the rip is no longer than 1".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New DT Saws

#13

Re: New DT Saws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, RJ, added the 20 tpi to my running LV shopping cart. And thanks to Derek for such a great review.

Pam