Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

Posts

Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#1

Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

David Cockey

>LIe-Nielsen tools are vanishing from the Woodcraft website. Looks like Woodcraft will no longer be carrying them.

But they will have Wood River.

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#2

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

Neal in San Jose

>My understanding is that Lie-Nielsen is pretty much pulling all sales back in-house. A small independent (Sawdust in Santa Clara) used to also carry LN, but they won't sell to him any more. It may be the same for all the non-LN vendors. LN will still sell thru WoodCraft, but the margin has been cut so much that WoodCraft doesn't make enough to make it worth their while. The WoodCraft I do business with will still do special orders, but is emptying their LN display case.

I bought a Wood River #4, and have been very happy with it's performance. I teach hand plane classes, and I like being able to recommend a modestly priced plane to newbees. I hope they expand their line to include BU.

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#3

A bit more on the big board *LINK*

woodburnbob

>I remembered this from last month.


Power tool thread

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#4

Re: A bit more on the big board

David Cockey

>Thanks for the link. I only read the Hand Tools board and very occasionally the Turning board.

Last year in Berea I though Tom Lie-Nielsen made a comment about wanting to drop most of the wholesale business, and WoodCraft has been more to their house brands of Pinnacle and Wood River.

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#5

the economics

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>LN used to sell to retailers for about 50% of retail list. Some of these retailers in turn wholesaled to other retailers for about 70% list. As a result there were many retailers for LN tools.

LN motivation may be two fold. One could be to eliminate the myriad of places selling LN stuff, like we used to, for example. Manufacturers of high toned stuff seem to like to have good control over its retail to keep up brand value. Second, they can capture 50% of the retail price by selling direct. The trick will be to keep up sales volume. I would bet that some significant fraction of potential customers are going to buy some alternative as a result of the contraction of retail outlets. Additionally, I am sure the competition is putting pressure on them to hold down prices. Perhaps this will be easier if half the sales price is not given to another retailer.

Their survival depends on having established brand recognition. They are certainly well known on this Forum but I am less sure they will be with new woodworkers. With less shows where are people going to see these tools other than in our shops?

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#6

Re: the economics

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>If they give me some I'll show them to anyone who comes by my shop. And that's a promise.

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#7

Re: the economics

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Woodcraft Austin kept the LN stuff in a locked case. You could ask to handle one, but not use/test it; so I'd expect the actual sales impact to be negligible.

Pam

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#8

Re: the economics

wilbur

>Same locked case for the Woodcrafts in my area, too.

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#9

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

Scott in Montana

>The following was relayed to me by a very reliable industry expert whom is highly regarded here on the forum. I hesitate to mention his name as I don't know if he would appreciate it. Our conversation took place Thanksgiving weekend.

The information was this. November 15th was the last official day that Woodcraft was a Lie-Nielsen dealer. In his opinion, both parties have their faults. They had worked together on the possibility of creating a high-end Woodcraft exclusive line of handplanes. Whether or not this would be branded under the Pinnacle line, I don't know. Somewhere along the line a disagreement erupted and the project, as a partnership, disolved. Supposedly Woodcraft is continuing the developement without Lie-Nielsen. I may br wrong, but I believe Woodcraft has 47 or so stores which would make them a force in the industry.

I have heard from other sources that a law suit has been filed, but I have no details.

We'll see if competition is good for us all.

Happy Holidays,

Scott in Montana

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Same here

Jack Guzman from Maine

>They have the same situation in the Newington,NH store. Add to that the fact that most of their employees don't know much about them.---Jack

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#11

Woodcraft

woodburnbob

>This thread got me wondering: who owns Woodcraft? I know the individual little shops are franchises, but who is King of Woodcraft?

The franchise site, as opposed to the retail site, has a nice overview of Woodcraft history, from which I'll quote just two elements:

"In 1998, Woodcraft's 1st franchise store opened. During the late 1990's, Woodcraft added eighteen franchised and three corporate stores, which caused an increase in warehouse space to almost two acres. In 2000, the Hawaii store opened and Woodcraft moved its administrative offices to its present location. By the end of 2001, there were 55 Woodcraft stores."

"In 2006, Woodcraft's parent company, SBR, Inc. merged with Fortune Brands, but Woodcraft remained under the ownership of Sam Ross. Woodcraft changed its name from Woodcraft Supply Corp. and Woodcraft Franchise Corporation to Woodcraft Supply, LLC and Woodcraft Franchise, LLC respectively."

Within the site, one can inspect the basic requirements, stats and dough needed to be a franchisee.

"Franchising Since: 1997

Franchised Units: 83

Company Owned Units: 4

Initial Franchise Fee: $50,000

Royalty/Service Fee: 5% of gross revenues

Est. Total Initial Investment: $505,300 to $650,000 which includes the franchisee fee

Minimum Market Population Required: 350,000"

I then wondered about the "merged" sentence and who and what is : Fortune Brands? Have a look:

If you are curious here are some of the "Home & Hardware" Famous Brands

I thought the Annual Report was informative. The company appears to be led by happy looking decision-makers:


img

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#12

P.S. L-N is coming to Austin

wilbur

>You probably know this already, Pam, but Lie-Nielsen is coming to Austin on Jan. 8-9, presumably to taunt the Austin Woodcraft and their locked cases.

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#13

They did a similar show in Houston this year

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#14

Re: P.S. L-N is coming to Austin

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Wilbur, and no, I didn't know but will certainly try to attend.

Pam

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#15

Lie-Nielsen and Woodcraft Versions *LINK*

David Cockey

>Ethan who blogs at Grey Stone Green talked with Patrick Johnson at Lie-Nielsen about their decision to pull their line from Woodcraft stores. His report is at the link below. He also received a note from Woodcraft that LN had decided to pull the line.


Blog on conversation with LN

Re: Woodcraft & Lie-Nielsen

#16

Re: Lie-Nielsen and Woodcraft Versions

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Interesting, thanks. I wonder why Thomas or someone else from LN didn't hit the woodworking boards [sic] and explain this earlier.

Pam