Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

Posts

Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#1

Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>as if cows on Panther saws weren't enough, now someone's carving on the wood parts of old tools. Sigh.

In the background of the pictures, you can see Bedrock, Bridge City?, Veritas, and Record planes - so this is not someone unfamiliar with hand tools. I guess, to be fair, I should just acknowledge that this is someone whose perspective on the value of old tools as tools differs from mine; or maybe this level was hopelessly out of level. Or, since the carving is on the show side, not the edge that would be placed against the stock being tested, maybe it's still a useful level that's been enhanced.

Marv, if you ever get tired of wheat carving, here's a whole new venue for you.


The spirit of plumb and level, I guess

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#2

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw

steve mackay

>But, but, . . . it'll look FABULOUS in that Manhatan penthouse !

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#4

Different strokes.....

Marv

>Bill,

I've seen this guy's work on eBay many times. In fact I bought a screwdriver that he carved. I admire his work. The old tools I've seen that he carves are basically common old tools. Seems He'll carve anything, even a shovel handle. If it's wood, he carves it. I think it is referred to as "spirit" carving. It's not as if there's a shortage of the kind of tools he carves.

I would greatly object to someone carving on a Panther head saw though. Did you see the Panther Head that just sold on eBay a couple days ago for over a thousand dollars? And it wasn't even one of the earlier ones. It was wheat carved, similar to more common saws instead of the scroll type carving that was done on the original Panther Head handles.

Most of the saws I carve are saws that no one seems to care about or I'll wheat carve a younger Disston D-8 because they are so common, nothing collectible about them. Or I'll carve a saw if a customer requests it. I have cringed while carving some saws per request but only after I make the customer aware of it's value. I have one customer who wants me to carve every saw he sends me regardless of what it is. He even sent me a Disston No.9 once. I carved it, but was cringing.

The picture is of a 1950,s era Disston D-8 that I totally reshaped and wheat carved. The saw sold on eBay for $127.00 The saws of that time period are really junky.

Marv


img

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#5

Before picture

Marv

>This is a before picture of the above saw.

If I had tried to sell this saw in this condition on eBay, probably wouldn't have gotten a bid on it.

Marv


img

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#6

Re: Different strokes.....

Marv

>This is the tool I bought from that guy on eBay. It's a carving tool, not a screwdriver.

Marv


img

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#7

Sorry, but...

McKay

>I think that a tool should be beautiful as well as useful. As long as the original USE was not compromised then no harm no foul....

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#8

Not the same guy I was thinking of....

Marv

>Bill,

I don't think the seller did the carving. I think it was done by some other guy who will usually have lots of carved items up for auction.

The seller has lots of other items listed, but the level is the only carved item.

Marv

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#9

I like it

David Miller from Iowa

>Not to demean any old tool, but would we even notice an uncarved Sargent level sell for $10

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#10

Why bother being fair?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#11

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw

James Watriss

>So, where's the line between carving the wood parts, and engraving the metal parts? Catharine Kennedy does great work, but nobody complains...

Why is it embellishment to carve up a beatiful new tool that's worth $300, but it's sacrilege to carve up a (to be fair) ugly old tool that wasn't worth $10 before?

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#12

Both sides...

John in NM

>In all fairness, that's not a bad carving, though not to my taste personally. I prefer to see this sort of thing than "restorations" that are stealthy - at least the buyer knows what they're getting and can pay accordingly if they feel its worth it. I suppose the grey area here comes in with how old the carving is.

While its the height of foolishness to modify a valuable antique, there are an abundance of common old tools to "improve". In some cases, user modifications have historical value and could conceivably add to the value of the object - though the usual hucksterism on ebay makes even this debatable now days.

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#13

scott grandstaff

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw

scott grandstaff

>I vandalize old tools all the time. I have done it for 30 years.

I'll sometimes take part of one old tool and make a new part to go with. On like that.

Nobody even noticed until there was a serious tool collecting community.


I'd have loved the level shown if it was carved any kind of originally and not so "stencilled" looking.

Yet another -wood spirit- carving I would pay handsomely to avoid!

I really liked the wheat carved Disston saw shown. I love any real attempt to improve most any tool. In fact I suppose I should quit picking on wood spirit carvings since they are probably the best the carver can do.

But I just don't care for copy over and over work. Something nice takes longer but seems infinitely more worthwhile, to me.

I think if the carver would have done an original design, something elegant and flowing maybe, it could have been a museum piece we would all have enjoyed terrific.

yours Scott

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#14

totally understand but slightly disagree

Roy Anderson

>There is a special place in the lowest levels of hell for people who paint cows on a panther saw, but for the millions of old but not collectible tools out there that have little value, who cares? The difference is whether the artist knows what he is arting up and what effect carving a gnome on it will have on the value.

I've got a level that works just fine but is totally valueless to anyone but a Neanderwonk like us, and anytime we might need one, we can get it easily, with or without gnome. So I don't take offense at this.

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#15

Disagree with myself, some

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I calmed down after this post - it is not as significant as wrecking a good saw.

Re: Another eBay rant - beyond the painted saw *LINK*

#16

Look at it this way...

Bob Hackett

>Painting the panther saw would keep it from rusting.

Think of it as a really odd form of preservation.

MB-Who doesn`t think ducking and running would help this time.