Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Varnish question

Posts

Varnish question

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Varnish question

Stephen Shepherd

>I have been using McCloskey's Man of War Marine Spar Varnish with good results. But now that the price is over $60.00 a gallon I am looking for another commercially produced non-urethane varnish of similar quality.

Anyone have experience with 'Tried and True'? Or are there others on the market that compare?

Stephen

Re: Varnish question

#2

Re: Varnish question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I find Benjamin Moore varnish to be a good furniture varnish. It is interior varnish.

Re: Varnish question

#3

Visit your local boatyard

Bob Hackett

>That $60 per gallon may look cheap by comparison.;^)

Do you use spar varnish for either the UV protection or it`s flexibility after curing(resistance to cracking) or both?

MB

Re: Varnish question

#4

Re: Varnish question

John Aniano, in NJ...

>Stephen,

The Tried and True varnish oil is a nice product, but does not behave like the spar varnish you are used to. You have to apply VERY THIN coats of the T&T products and they do take a lot of time to cure if you don't. Addition of driers can help, but thin coats are still best with T&T.

John

Re: Varnish question

#5

Re: Varnish question

Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ, near Philadelphia

>Steven,

T&T is a modified BLO. It is not used nor will it behave like a conventional modern day varnish. I'm not sure why they describe it the way that they do, but I can't tell that it has "other resins" added.

Having said that its a nice product but not at all similar to McCloskey's MOW.

Mike

Re: Varnish question

#6

T&T Varnish Oil

Frank D. in Montreal

>The varnish oil does have aresin in it, apparently a natural resin. I swear by it (instant old look to cherry), but I also add tung oil to it (about 25%) for extra resistance. I refinish all my mid-century Danish "antiques" that I like to buy, including my kitchen table, and I find it more resistant than any varnish under heavy use (again, with the tung oil). However, I also think it'll be more ezxpensive than $60 a gallon...at least where I buy it. I add pure tung oil, but if you want it to dry more quickly, I'm sure you could add polymerized tung oil.

Re: Varnish question

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Correction......

Jesper, Denmark

>It WILL look cheap by comparison.

Re: Varnish question

#8

Re: T&T Varnish Oil

Gibbons in Texas

>I believe it has pine resin and it is how varnish used to be made. At least that's what I believe I read somewhere.

Re: Varnish question

#9

Bart Goldberg

Re: Varnish question

Bart Goldberg

>Fine Woodworking compared exterior varnishes earlier this year (May/June Issue). The clear favorite I recall was Epiphanes High Gloss Marine Varnish. However, I suspect is cost even more that what your currently using.

Happy Holiday's

Bart

Re: Varnish question

#10

Historical meaning of varnish

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Historically, varnish was a mixture of a hard resin-copal, amber, etc.- and oil such as linseed. The portion of hard resin to soft oil determined it use. Lots of oil resulted in a soft flexible finish good for outdoors while more resin resulted in a hard finish that could be rubbed out.

Now days the resin is a synthetic polymer. I don't recall ever seeing pine rosin used in a recipe.

Re: Varnish question

#11

Re: Historical meaning of varnish

Bob Hackett

>Isn`t copal a resin from a type of conifer found mostly in Mexico?

MB

Re: Varnish question

#13

Bill, I was quoting Tried & True site *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Here's the link. See for yourself.


http://www.triedandtruewoodfinish.com/varnish.htm

Re: Varnish question

#14

Re: Historical... - rosin-based varnish recipes *LINK*

John Aniano in NJ...

>Bill, et al.,

Yes, violin makers use rosin to make violin varnish, at least some of them do. I understand there are various recipes, but here are two of the more common ones. I've included here a link from the firm WoodFinishing Enterprises. They have it as information on their finishing products website. Disclaimer: I have purchased from them in the past and I like their service and products. Other than that, I have no affiliation.

There are other rosin-based recipes, but you have to ask a violin maker directly and hope for a direct answer!

John


Michelman metal rosinate and "Formula 411" varnish

Re: Varnish question

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Varnish question, thanks

Stephen Shepherd

>My reason for asking is because a friend uses at least 10 gallons of McCloskey's a year and the increase in price was a concern. I have since found out from folks here that sixty dollars is probably not a bad price.

I like the McCloskey's gloss spar varnish for mixing with asphaltum for japanning as it is handy and mixes well and it is already made up.

I myself have been making my own varnish for the past several years and have made copal varnish, a sandarac and amber varnish and even turpentine varnish among others. I recently found a recipe for the legendary 'Vernice Martin' and hope to mix some of that up soon.

My early varnishes were quite thin but worked with several coats, lately I have been using thickened linseed oil and have been fusing my resins, so the varnish has a much thicker consistency.

I also use spirit varnish (they contain no oil) from various old recipes and they work for light duty applications.

Thanks all for your comments.

Stephen

Re: Varnish question

#16

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Varnish question, thanks  *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

>


Making Varnish