We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I have been using McCloskey's Man of War Marine Spar Varnish with good results. But now that the price is over $60.00 a gallon I am looking for another commercially produced non-urethane varnish of similar quality.
Anyone have experience with 'Tried and True'? Or are there others on the market that compare?
The Tried and True varnish oil is a nice product, but does not behave like the spar varnish you are used to. You have to apply VERY THIN coats of the T&T products and they do take a lot of time to cure if you don't. Addition of driers can help, but thin coats are still best with T&T.
Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ, near Philadelphia
Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ, near Philadelphia
Guest
Re: Varnish question
Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ, near Philadelphia
>Steven,
T&T is a modified BLO. It is not used nor will it behave like a conventional modern day varnish. I'm not sure why they describe it the way that they do, but I can't tell that it has "other resins" added.
Having said that its a nice product but not at all similar to McCloskey's MOW.
>The varnish oil does have aresin in it, apparently a natural resin. I swear by it (instant old look to cherry), but I also add tung oil to it (about 25%) for extra resistance. I refinish all my mid-century Danish "antiques" that I like to buy, including my kitchen table, and I find it more resistant than any varnish under heavy use (again, with the tung oil). However, I also think it'll be more ezxpensive than $60 a gallon...at least where I buy it. I add pure tung oil, but if you want it to dry more quickly, I'm sure you could add polymerized tung oil.
>Fine Woodworking compared exterior varnishes earlier this year (May/June Issue). The clear favorite I recall was Epiphanes High Gloss Marine Varnish. However, I suspect is cost even more that what your currently using.
>Historically, varnish was a mixture of a hard resin-copal, amber, etc.- and oil such as linseed. The portion of hard resin to soft oil determined it use. Lots of oil resulted in a soft flexible finish good for outdoors while more resin resulted in a hard finish that could be rubbed out.
Now days the resin is a synthetic polymer. I don't recall ever seeing pine rosin used in a recipe.
Yes, violin makers use rosin to make violin varnish, at least some of them do. I understand there are various recipes, but here are two of the more common ones. I've included here a link from the firm WoodFinishing Enterprises. They have it as information on their finishing products website. Disclaimer: I have purchased from them in the past and I like their service and products. Other than that, I have no affiliation.
There are other rosin-based recipes, but you have to ask a violin maker directly and hope for a direct answer!
>My reason for asking is because a friend uses at least 10 gallons of McCloskey's a year and the increase in price was a concern. I have since found out from folks here that sixty dollars is probably not a bad price.
I like the McCloskey's gloss spar varnish for mixing with asphaltum for japanning as it is handy and mixes well and it is already made up.
I myself have been making my own varnish for the past several years and have made copal varnish, a sandarac and amber varnish and even turpentine varnish among others. I recently found a recipe for the legendary 'Vernice Martin' and hope to mix some of that up soon.
My early varnishes were quite thin but worked with several coats, lately I have been using thickened linseed oil and have been fusing my resins, so the varnish has a much thicker consistency.
I also use spirit varnish (they contain no oil) from various old recipes and they work for light duty applications.