Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

knive advice

Posts

knive advice

#1

knive advice

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>At the risk of turning this forum into the "Knife Forum" I have a question/need. It seems there is a wealth of knife knowledge here. I searched Ebay for "stockman knife" and to my astonishment got over 1000 hits!!! Many seemed targeted to collectors and I am not interested in paying a collectors premium for a user. I was boggled/overwhelmed and realized I know little about knives. ,

The need: Two bladed knife. One short blade that must be stiff and kept somewhat dull. It will be the fulcrum over which small leg bones can be broken without bending/flexing the blade or cutting the fingers that provide bending force to break the bones. Second blade longer (3-4") , pointed and very sharp for piercing and cutting flesh and skin. Stainless somewhat preferred due to corrosive nature of blood but not essential.

Suggestions for a specific brand, style and source? Used(ebay) is acceptable. Thanks in advance

Re: knive advice

#2

Re: knive advice

ThomD

>I think these guys might be your kind of company?

http://www.wrcase.com/knives/

Not sure I would want to do what you describe with a folder, day in and day out. But if you have been doing it for the last 50 years without me, keep up the good work. :)

Re: knive advice

#3

Bill, take a look at these stockmans

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>A sheepsfoot blade would possibly be good for the bone breaking and a clip or spear would work for the cutting.

Re: knive advice

#5

Re: Bill, take a look at these stockmans *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Also look at the Mooremaker regular production line in the link below. Their the "economy" knives at the bottom of the page. Not stainless but good users.


http://www.collectorknives.net/mooremaker.html

Re: knive advice

#7

Sorry, at the bottom of the page

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: knive advice

#8

Re: Bill, take a look at these stockmans

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The section of the page that first came up had three figures before the decimal point and my heart skipped a beat, but at the bottom of the page I see affordable knives that will work nicely. I like the Rc 58 hardness.

I have what I thought would be a good knife but I can "sharpen" it with a file. Indeed! It must be useful for something but I don't know what, sharpening practice maybe. I bought it from a place back home, Utica Cutlery, where the lady at the outlet store said it was a good knife.

thanks

Re: knive advice

#9

scott grandstaff

Re: knive advice

scott grandstaff

>Well, I thought it was getting to be too much and we would move to another subject by now. So here is the last from me.

Lets see, to pull in another thread, Utica was in business for a long time and made several lines (qualities) of goods. If you can cut the blade easy with an old used file, it was made for guys who would be prying out nails more than thin slicing. A knife for everyone.

Advise from the clerk at a retail outlet who mostly sells socks?? heeheheheheeh

"Stockman" means square bolsters and three blades, usually always one of them a spey blade. This pattern has some leeway, (they all do), but basically its the square bolsters on the handle and spey that make it a stock knife.

If rounded bolsters would be acceptable and 2 blades?? Well that is a jack knife and just look at the pattern myriad of jack knives!! Anything you could want.

Todd is nobody's fool, not by a long shot. The names Cattraugus and New York knife are some of the top names of all time. Vintage knives by these names, among a very few others, will be right at the best cutlery man has ever produced in a factory setting. Nothing, and I mean nothing at all, currently being produced, compares.

"The Quill" they used to say.

Retail offerings is where we all start. Until we find better. Much better and for less money if you're sharp.

Custom knifemakers of course are willing to put more time into it, so the highest grades of all, will always be custom.

Bernard Levine wrote the best knife book I ever read, hands down. He did about 4 editions before his publisher ripped him off and fired him from off his own book!! (never considered such a thing possible but it happened) and someone else was hired to take it over.

Forget the price lists in the later editions. Get an earlier volume.

For the very beginner, just making handles, try this guy

http://stores.ebay.com/PremiumKnifeSupply.

If you camp out on his listings you can get a blade for under 10 bucks that will make a decent knife. There are lots of better blades available, but nothing I've seen cheaper that you can still be proud of to "cut your teeth on".

There is a knife club somewhere around you. Knife collectors could swallow tool collectors in numbers. There are clubs and books and meetings and conventions, newsletters, auctions.. all of it. All told considerably more members than tool guys. Start looking around even a little and the world opens up very wide indeed.

yours Scott