We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>If this topic has been discussed I missed it. It seems obvious how the typical Japanese water stone works- the same way as a soft bond grinding wheel. The bond is soft so it wears away quickly thereby exposing fresh sharp abrasive particles. But the Norton stones are said to not wear away, yet they are also said to cut fast. As fast as a traditional water stone?
If they don't wear yet cut fast they must have some ability to expose or create fresh sharp edges on the abrasive particles. Maybe they are made from the so called seeded gel ceramic particles like what is in their SG or 3X wheels.
Anybody know for sure? For sharpening kitchen knives where flatness is unimportant are they going to have any advantage over a less expensive water stone? (the knife discussion got me thinking about giving my sons-in-law some sort of sharping stone)
>Bill, I don't know the composition of Norton stones. All I know is that I received a sample set of stones from Norton very early on in their product development, over 10 years ago, and the stones were uneven, in the sense that some grits cut fast and others didn't. Toshio Odate did a lot of product development with them for two or three years and I understand that the result was a much improved uniformity of wear, but I haven't personally looked back.
For the money, and for a mass produced product, they're probably a bargain, especially as a gift for someone who is not likely to be too discerning about the cutting rate or wearing rate of the stones.
>I have a couple of Norton stones. These stones wear just like any other stones. If I'm sharpening small blades, it's pretty easy to accidentally dish these stones as they do wear under use. A few strokes with a rough grit diamond plate puts them back to flat in no time. Flattening the stones is the only time I use the diamond plate, so it will last me forever.
Are you thinking instead about Shapton stones? Those do not wear down as quickly as a waterstone or a Norton. I have no experience with Shaptons myself as I'm satisfied with my Nortons and waterstones.
>Bill, if Norton claims their stones don't wear quickly it's news to me. I have a Norton 8000 which I like, and I'd compare it to a grinding wheel with a very soft bond. It cuts pretty quickly and forms a slurry and I flatten it like any other waterstone. If I recall correctly Toshio Odate suggests that hard steels sharpen best with soft stones, and the Norton stone has a very soft feel.
Shapton stones wear away much more slowly and don't form as much of a slurry. I asked Harrison Stanley about what kind of abrasive they contain and he said Shapton wouldn't even tell him that information. They have a harder feel than the Nortons. I've used a number of grits of Shapton stones and I really like some and dislike others. The lime green one (3000x?) seems to cut way faster than any of the others for its grit size and if all the others worked as well I'd probably only use Shaptons. I dislike the 8000x and like the 15,000.
After using a variety of types of stones on a whole range of different alloys I'm convinced that some stones work better than others with a given blade, but I just have to try them out and see what works--I can't predict.
THe claim (or statement) that Norton stones wear slowly came in the context that they were brought to market after King stones, which are noticeably softer than Nortons. Shaptons came out after Nortons with the same claim (to last longer without flattening).
I use mostly Nortons and see no reason to change (even though I also have a few Shaptons in grits that aren't available in Nortons). I love that smooth soft feel, and the fact that I can flatten them very easily (reminds me of the knife discussion going on, ease of sharpening and hard enough vs very hard but hard to sharpen). Kings, on th eother hand, I find way too soft. The 4000 stone wears slightly more quickly than the 1000 and 8000 stone, but it's still a great stone.
If I was to give someone a stone(s) for sharpening knives, I'd give them Norton oil stones.
>When I compare all my waterstones the 800 king wears very fast compare to the Norton 1000 neither stay flat for long. Norton 4000 wears quicker than the king 4000. The norton 4000 is ready to snap any day now and I can't wait it will be some fun making it into different shapes for carving chisels. The 8000 stone is still by far the thickest stone of the bunch. Mine are about 5 years old.
>I seem to remember reading that the Norton 4000 is (or was) out sourced by Norton. I know that I've had problems with that stone. As a matter of fact I have 3 or 4 of them in my sharpening drawer from looking for one that was good. The first one I bought wore faster than other stones, but seemed to be well made. Subsequent 4000s though were not as good. They tended to seem softer in the center than the edges. Just to test this I poured a bit of coffee on one of them and let it sit for 20 minutes. Then I started a flattening ritual with LV's lapping grit. After taking 3/16" off the stone there was still an oval ring of coffee stain in the center of the stone.
Technically speaking, Shaptons differ from the traditional waterstone in that they are held together with a ceramic binding rather than clay. They still wear, and wear more than you realise, but do so much less than any other waterstone I know. I flatten them quite frequently (about once every blade or so), but with less paranoia than my old Kings. I used to use a DMT Extra Coarse (275 grit) to flatten them, and then picked up a new Shapton diamond plate at a deceased estate for a decent price about a year ago.
If you watch Harrelson hone a blade, you will be surprised just how much water he uses. I use a lot less water than Kings (or Nortons) but still more than just a dash, and add a spritz every now-and-then. One of the advantages of these stones is that water does not need to soak into pores, and so there is no pre-use soak, as with traditional stones.
The stones benefit from a little liquid soap in the water to aid in lubrication. This helps prevent "stiction", which occurs when the surface begins to glaze over with steel swarf. More water would have the same effect (which is what Harrelson does).
One of the advantages of the hard surface is that you can hone narrow blades with less danger of doing damage than you could on a softer surface.
I have the Profession version. My favourites are the 1000 and 12/15000. Bote work very fast. I also have the 5000 and 8000, but I find that I can jump from 1000 to 12/15000 very easily if honing microbevels (even on A2). These stones work well on A2 (removing one of the objections of many to the harder composition).
>The Belgian coticule water stone is famous for being able to cut aggressively and also to give a fine polish depending on the slurry and the pressure exerted. Japanese water stones also have this quality. Optimum speed of cutting requires a critical amount of pressure and water. Too much pressure and the abrasive particles are crushed and do not cut as well. I wonder if those who use micro bevels can get a feel for this. Let the stone dry up a bit and the slurry breaks down into smaller particles and gives more of a polishing action. For this reason, an 8000 grit stone can get a considerably finer polish in skilled hands than by a beginner.
The Shapton stones are said to cut more aggressively. This could depend on whose hands are using them. I think they have harder binder and perhaps harder or tougher particles as well. I suspect that an 8000 Shapton does not have the range of cutting abilities of the Japanese water stones and will not polish as well. Thus the helpfulness of the 15K and 30K grits. It could be that the Shaptons are better for micro bevel and jig users.
When the Norton stones first came out, they claimed to have slightly different binder and to be somewhat harder, specially formulated for the American worker. At the time, I took this to mean unskilled worker. They may be different today.
>About 5 years ago I was dumb enough to spend way too much money on stones I didn't need at the time, in the hopes that each one would live up to the 'better than the rest' reputation that they had in the glossy pages. Arkansas stones, Nortons, King, Shapton, diamond paste, and on and on...
But if you're looking for something to sharpen kitchen knives, my choice was to go with King stones. Because flatness isn't as much of an issue, and because I'm not pounding my kitchen knives into anything hard, the need to sharpen them isn't as pronounced. So, I saw no need to go too crazy on stones. For the record, I'm also using Kershaw Shun kitchen knives out of VG-10, so they stay sharp for quite a while to begin with, and a good sharpening steel also makes a big difference between sharpenings, too.
None of the above has any bearing on the ability of your sons in law to sharpen... or of their knives to take an edge. That said, I've found these things to be useful in the kitchen, too:
http://www.dmtsharp.com/products/diafold.htm
I have a set of two, one has red and blue handles, and has course and medium, and the other has green and white, for fine and ceramic. For most slicing, dicing, and chopping, the average kitchen knife should be sharp, but I don't think it has to have a hair-popping polished edge. I use these sharpeners on the fiancee's knives, and on some of the knives I beat up with more frequency.
I also like to carry the DMT things in my back pocket when I have a family member who calls with a need for knife sharpening. Most of them don't have knives that would benefit from a serious sharpening. More likely, they'd cut well for a few strokes and then fold over... especially my sister's knives, since she uses them on a textured glass 'cutting board.' (her description)
Last but not least, I think if the S-I-L's knew how to sharpen, they'd be likely to already have stones of their own. If they have stones, or sharpening skill, the Norton stones would be a nice gift. I can say from experience that the 4000/8000 combo will be likely to cover most of their needs... the 4000 cuts very fast, and when I do use my Nortons, I only resort to the 1000 if I've really done some serious damage to a tool. I usually go to the 4000 following the bench grinder on my non-japanese tools.
If the young men in question don't have either stones or sharpening ability, something like the folding DMT things will be less likely to get trashed when they get chucked into the kitchen junk drawer by someone who probably doesn't know any better.
>I am a fanatic when it comes to kitchen knives. I use the King 1000 followed by a few laps on the strop. If a knife won't breach a tomato skin effortlessly it gets sharpened.
>I think you have the correct explanation Bill. I have never really believed the slury explanation that involves the idea that the paste is sorta like a lap. My stones are always squeegeed off by the passing blade. But without some serious bucks to investigate what is really going on it is all pretty conjectural.