Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Curved Veneering

Posts

Curved Veneering

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Curved Veneering

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I've never done any veneering. I wish to attach a piece of storebought(Rockler)birdseye maple veneer to the curved top surface of a mantle clock.The body of the clock will be layers of 3/4" hardwood glued into a block ,laid on edge with the end grain on either side (right and left)and the curve cut out of the top edge.The curve that the veneer has to adhere to will be 180 degrees of a 5" circle with a return,opposite curve on both ends.Will grain orientation be an issue? What can I use for glue? I'm thinking of making a caul to the shape of the curve and use it with clamps to hold the veneer on til the glue dries. Does this sound practical? Any hints,don'ts,tips?

Direction to an online tutorial or magazine article might be helpful. I have several years of PW and FW.Thanks---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#2

May I suggest...

David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast

>Softening-conditioning your veneer, then hot hide glue with the veneer pressed in place by hand, ironing any loose areas until everything's right. Very forgiving on small curved objects. If you don't have HHG on hand, you can use unflavored gelatin (Knox). Mix in some water, let soak for a few minutes, then microwave in short increments until it drips like syrup. Try not to overheat. Not ideal gram strength but it'll do in a pinch.

Before you begin, take a look at this product. It's simply amazing. I've used it on all manner of small cylindrical and curvy projects. Get the spray bottle (better than similar looking spray bottles).

Re: Curved Veneering

#4

Random thoughts

James Watriss

>Hi Jack,

I can't really put a comprehensive process together, but I had the following thoughts, anyway...

-Hot hide glue might be a good option for a few reasons. Reversibility is one, simply because this sounds like a project where there's a learning curve, and it'll be easier to undo than redo anything that goes awry. The other reason is that you're veneering to plywood, and you're going to have alternating patches of end grain and face grain. Sizing everything first will help fill the end grain and get you a better bond, than if you laid up the glue, and some of it soaked into the end grain, resulting in an uneven bond. My best guess is that it might not really be an issue. But better safe than sorry.

-I like the caul idea, but you'd really need to be precise with the radius. A little too small, you're not clamping the ends, a little too big, and you won't get the bottom of the radius. One improvised fix for this issue is to make it undersized, and pad it with a few layers of rags. The rags will conform to any parts of the caul that aren't 100% super-perfect, and still give you the pressure you need. Add a layer of wax paper between the rags and the work, to help keep things clean.

-I think doing a practice piece would be a good idea, just the radius cut in a small block of plywood. It's a hassle, but it'll give you a better idea of how the process will work for you, and give you the luxury of being able to work the kinks out before you do any damage to the rest of the piece.

My .02

-J

PS... I want pictures!!!

Re: Curved Veneering

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Curved Veneering

Stephen Shepherd

>Making a caul can be a good idea, especially if you want to make more than one clock the same shape. Heated sandbags (washed sand in a tightly woven canvas) can also provide pressure where is needed.

You can buy those 'conditioners' or you can make your own with distilled water and glycerin. If you use a caul, then treat the veneer with water and glycerin and place on the clock and put the caul over and clamp and allow to dry. It is now in the proper shape for gluing. Or you can add glycerin to hide glue (hot or liquid), when you put it on the veneer allow it to soften, which is does as soon as it is wet then put it in the caul.

Orient the grain from end to end was the traditional method of aligning veneer on most old clocks of this style. Properly prepared veneer will easily conform to this shape.

I would just hammer veneer the clock. No cauls and when it has dried if there are any air bubbles they can be removed by a hot iron.

You can also put a thin coat of hide glue on both the clock and the veneer and allow them to dry. Then you can apply heat and iron it down, however this might be difficult on these curves.

Stephen

Re: Curved Veneering

#6

Re: Curved Veneering

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jack,

I haven't done this particular veneer job before. But do have experience using hot hide glue to fix small complicated pieces into place.

With that in mind, I would like to second David Barnett's suggestion of (a) hot hide glue, and (b) use fingers.

In the first place, you will need to use your fingers even if you were going to apply a caul--cause the veneer will have to be dead flush to the substrate before the caul goes on. The caul won't make wavy veneer flat, just press creases into it. So you'll have to use fingers to get the veneer flush. But if you're using hot hide glue, by the time you get it finger-flat, it's beginning to set up, and you're done! It takes about a minute of contact, and after that you can go make a cup of tea while it dries, and in 20-30 minutes you can scrape off the gelled excess and work it.

If you happen to have Old Brown Glue on hand, I suspect it would work without cauls on pre-softened veneer--cause where is the veneer gonna go? If you don't want to try hot hide, that would be a safe second choice. There is plenty of work time.

Regarding any hide glue: Have a wet towel on hand to use for getting the glue off your fingers. From time to time you need to do that, otherwise your fingers turn into 10 sticky things that pick stuff up randomly and don't let it go. [Have you ever seen that W. C. Fields short piece called 'The Golfer'? It's hilarious.]

The problem with cauls and hot hide glue is that (a) it takes time to get the caul in place, (b) you have to get it finger flat in the first place, and (c) the minute you put the caul on there, you are out of the loop. This last point is important, because if the caul itself adds a crease, you can't see it anymore--so you'll take the caul off and there is a ruined piece of work. But if you use your fingers, you can smooth the veneer continuously until the glue gets a grip (which won't be long).

Wiley

Re: Curved Veneering

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: May I suggest...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>That's an interesting product David. If I decide to do more veneering I'll give it a try.---Jak

Re: Curved Veneering

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

no plywood

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I'm not using plywood. I was thinking of lining the caul with some sheet cork gasket material.I can get the caul pretty close to exact by cutting the center filler board out of a wide board and using the cutoff as the caul.---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Curved Veneering

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I'm not quite ready for hot hide glue yet.My last experience with it was a mess.I'm going to experiment a bit. I have some liquid hide glue. ---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

conditioner

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Stephen,could you elaborate a little on this stuff. How much of each part and where does one find glycerin? Does it need to be heated?---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#11

Re: conditioner

Dan Donaldson

>We can get glycerin at the local drug store. Also, if you have kids or grandkids, glycerin is an ingredient in bubble solution for blowing bubbles. ;-)

Re: Curved Veneering

#12

Stephen Shepherd

Re: conditioner

Stephen Shepherd

>Jack,

It is used cold, I use 5% glycerin to distilled water, a friend that does a lot more veneering than I do uses 10%, but he buys it by the gallon and liquid hide glue in 5 gallon buckets.

Stephen

Re: Curved Veneering

#13

Re: Curved Veneering

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jack,

In that case, your cork lined caul should do great, because you'll have plenty of time to get the veneer laying just so, before applying it.

We'd love to see photos of this clock when you're done.

Wiley

Re: Curved Veneering

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Curved Veneering

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Looks likes I'm going to be doing some experimenting. I'll post a picture when I get it right.---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#15

Re: Curved Veneering

Alan S

>If I recall correctly, the guy who sells old brown glue developed it specifically for hammer veneering curved surfaces. He wanted a longer working time than for hot hide glue for putting veneer on round columns. There was a FW article about this, though I can't seem to find it on their website, possibly because it's too old.

Re: Curved Veneering

#16

Jack Guzman from Maine

Old Brown Glue--same as Titebond?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I keep hearing about this stuff. I use Titebond liquid hide glue on a regular basis.It's great for assembling small parts.Is there a difference between these two products? Or is it the same stuff,different manufacturer? If it's a better product I want to use it,but I always assumed that Titebond was the same stuff and it's available at any hardware store.---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#17

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Old Brown Glue--same as Titebond?

Stephen Shepherd

>They are the same in that they are both liquid hide glue, but there the similarities end. I use both and fish glue, here are the differences between Franklin/Titebond and Partick Edwards Old Brown Glue.

Old Brown Glue has a higher viscosity, it is thicker and therefore becomes difficult to get out of the bottle at lower temperatures. It is lighter in color and looks and behaves more like hot hide glue. The open times are about the same. Old Brown Glue has a more agressive initial tack than Franklin and that is good for hammer veneering and rub joints. I use Franklin for most work but on the important stuff I use Old Brown Glue. That reminds me I need to get some more.

Stephen

Re: Curved Veneering

#18

Another difference *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>When you buy the Old Brown Glue, you get to talk to the nice lady who picks up the phone at the other end, and who will brighten your day considerably, no matter what else is going on.

Wiley


Patrick Edwards' Old Brown Glue

Re: Curved Veneering

#19

Re: Another difference

Alan S

>Thanks for the link. On his site I found a citation for his FW article on veneering columns. It was issue 173 Dec 2004. Not that long ago. I wonder why the FW website search didn't find it?

Part of that article is reprinted on the website:

http://www.wpatrickedwards.com/articleMC.htm

Re: Curved Veneering

#20

Jack Guzman from Maine

Very important detail

Jack Guzman from Maine

>

Re: Curved Veneering

#21

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Another difference

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Thanks, I have that issue.---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#22

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Old Brown Glue--same as Titebond?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>That answered my question. I need that stuff. Thanks ---Jack

Re: Curved Veneering

#23

different opinion of Old Brown Glue

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I must be the only person in the world who doesn't like Old Brown Glue. Personally I like the Titebond liquid hide glue (LHG) much more.

The Old Brown Glue behaves much more like hot hide glue - you have to heat it up to use it (or else I live in the artic where it is too cold to use this stuff). My shop isn't too cold, but isn't too warm either, and the Old Brown Glue sets up way too quick. I completely disagree that the open time is the same as Titebond LHG. From the one bottle of Old Brown Glue that I've used, I would say the open time is "minutes", whereas the Titebond LHG has an open time of probably "10 to 15 minutes".

My opinions:

Old Brown Glue = good liquid hide glue with short open time compared to PVA. Needs to be mildly heated to be liquid. Smells nicer than Titebond LHG. Have to mail-order this stuff.

Titebond = good liquid hide glue with long open time compared to PVA or Old Brown Glue. Needs to be heated occasionally to be liquid. Can buy locally, but watch the expiry dates; most of the stuff on the shelf is well past the expiry date.

Hot hide glue = great glue for hammer veneering. Very short open time. Both wood and glue need to be heated in order to make nice tight fitting edge glue joints. The shop has to be HOT, and you have to be fast. Hot hide glue is fun to use for veneering, but is not a good general purpose glue for me.

For me the Titebond liquid hide glue offers all the convenience of PVA with the all the benefits of hide glue over PVA. Titebond LHG is a different animal than the Old Brown Glue.

However, I did enjoy chatting with the helpful lady who sells the Old Brown Glue much more than the useless farts who barely know what glue is at the hardware store, much-less understand that some glues have a shelf-life.

So short story is to keep your expectations of Old Brown Glue reasonable. It has plusses and minuses.

Re: Curved Veneering

#24

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I find the different views on products helpful, especially when I have not had an opportunity to form a first hand impression myself (not set in my ways, yet, but getting shorter "open time" by the day).

The sum of all the posts would encourage me to try both products.