Were they making spoked wheels this early? *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Seller says they're positively for sure for real spokeshaves - 27 of the little puppies.
EBay - always interesting, sometimes right
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Were they making spoked wheels this early? *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Seller says they're positively for sure for real spokeshaves - 27 of the little puppies.
EBay - always interesting, sometimes right
?? Think the link is wrong
Dan Donaldson
>If it is, then put up the correct one and I will get rid of this one.
Wait, that's the link that Chichi was looking for
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>in the first place. Or did I miss something?
Wiley
Re: Wait, that's the link that Chichi was looking
Dan Donaldson
>I think it is, but is not the one for an ebay sale '-)
Yep, sorry; corrected now
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>
No but they made Bows
Todd Hughes
>I used a spoke shave about everyday for many years and don't think I ever made a spoke wheel....that doesn't mean they weren't spoke shaves
I am no expert on stone tools and don't know if they should be called spokeshaves or what but if you were making something like a bow or spear shafy etc. I can see where you would use tools like this sort of in the same way as a spoke shave.....Todd
Wonder what
Dan Donaldson
>I wonder what inspection under a microscope has to do with anything.
Arrow shaft scraper
Stephen Shepherd
>Which is a paleo version of of a spoke shave, but with a much sharper edge. Much sharper doesn't really tell the story, they are sharper than anything else! They still use knapped stone scalpels for delicate brain surgery.
I like Todd's account of using a spokeshave and never making a spoke.
Dan, microscopic examination could have determined if they were in fact used for scrapers and not just geofacts. However the seller didn't go into detail.
Stephen
Don Crabtree
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>who was one of the heavy duty researchers in flintknapping in the early 20th century actually made the obsidian blades that were used in his own cataract surgery. They were MUCH sharper than anything else. Reportedly, the incisions heal substantially quicker than even a scalpel cut.
Bruce, an erstwhile anthropologist.
Re: Wonder what
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>He doesn't establish that he has the experience to determine the use, but trained archaeologists can tell from fracture lines the approximate use of artifacts. They will make their own implements, use them in a controlled manner and then examine them for the fracture and wear patterns.
How can we be sure they were inspected
Bob Hackett
>There`s no place to put the little official paper that says "Inspected by #----.
MB-Ducking and running(serpentine-serpentine!)
What they really are (OT-nonsense)
Adam Cherubini, NJ
>As an old tool expert, I can uncategorically say that these are NOT spoke shaves, but rather paleo-lithic toothbrushes, They were used to scrape the rot from one's tooth. Did you ever wonder about the original of the term "toothbrush"? Ever wonder why it's not called a teethbrush? This is why. It's pretty clear that each tool was carefully sized for the tooth of the owner.
This is also where we get the term "long in the tooth". As we all know, we older folks do things better and more carefully. 10,000 years ago, we older folks spent a lot more time cleaning our tooth so the term came to be synonomous with "old".
Next week, I'll discuss the deriviation of another ancient dental related tool, the "Old Widow's Tooth" router.
Adam
Re: Were they making spoked wheels this early?
ThomD
>Possibly in the same sense of precision in which one uses a spokeshave to make a chair. Hands up anyone who has used a spokeshave to make spokes. Never appealed to me. I think if I even make a non-modern spinning wheel I will turn it.
Re: Also...
ThomD
>There must have been some stage when a particular culture came into contact with the wheel and yet held onto their stone tools before they were able to grab the bounty of metal tools also available.
And, how does one determine the date of a stone tool?
And, I did a search and eventually found glass scalpels for sale. Mostly I just see references to them on knapping sites.
Re: Arrow shaft scraper
Dean J in MN
>I was under the impression knapped blades aren�t approved by the FDA, or have they backtracked and changed the rules?
Re: Were they making spoked wheels this early?
Greg Forster
>I did a quick Google and "spokeshave" is the correct term used for these pieces of flint
I can't speak for Stephen's examples, but
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>Crabtree's cataract surgery was more than 50 years ago.
Re: No but they made Bows
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Yeah, same here, think I'd call them special case scrapers, and maybe beaders, reeders, and flutes.
Pam
Re: Don Crabtree
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Yes, the natives didn't adopt steel tools for sharpness, but its ability to hold an edge. Apparently obsidian chips easily. :)
Pam
Just the facts
Dale Stansbery
>Todd's closest to being correct. Though bow and arrows aren't believed to have been invented in the Americas before about 2000 years ago, they were using spears and darts using an atlatl as a throwing device as long as 12,000 years ago or more. They all had to be shaped. The seller indicates that these are thought to be paleo which would make them more than 10,000 years old.
A microscope is used to see usage wear patterns. Archaeologists knap new blades and subject them to different uses, such as scraping wood or hides, then compare the wear patterns under a microscope from their new stuff to old stuff to find a match.
Flint plane blades for wood are not uncommon as well, and surprise, the desired bevel angle is abouut 45
Addy Protocol: I'm not a professional archaeologist, though I have played one in the movies.
Re: Also...
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>And, how does one determine the date of a stone tool?
Normally by determining the strata and its dates.
Pam
Ah. Interesting
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I thought the seller was using an incorrect term for lack of knowing the correct one. I sit corrected.
Re: 'nother fact on wheels, spoked or otherwise
Dale Stansbery
>There were no wheels in the Americas prior to the European invasion, with one exception. Pre 1942 Toys have been found in Mesoamerica with wheels, but the concept was never anything larger. Source, "1491" by Charles Mann.
one of the thrills of my life
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>was to be at a Folsom site in ND, discovered when a lake had to be drained. It was an incredible experience to pick up a Folsom point made from a piece of Knife River flint that was approx 11,000 years old.
There was a funny story associated with that site, for me personally. I am an anthropologist by education and at the time worked in a congressional office. Members of the state's congressional staff visited the site with the Corps of Engineers (IIRC) and I knew some of the archeologists working the site from my alma mater. I walked up to some of the staff I didn't know and introduced myself. They said they knew of me by reputation. I made the assumption that it was because of my congressional work, but they told me it wasn't. Turns out, I was the only anthropologist they knew of outside academia who had a full-time job with benefits :-)))
Bruce
I`ve figured it out,I think
Bob Hackett
>Did you mean 1492 and then post 1942?
I remember seeing pics of cannons with spoked wheels at Gettysburg and elsewhere during the civil war is why I ask.
Your reference to "1491" was a clue.
MB