Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Things I think about

Posts

Things I think about

#1

Things I think about

Larry Williams

>This is sort of in reference to Wiley's post about his I Sym plane.

In the last few years, I've come across a number of references to how we idealize 18th Century cabinet making and tend to overlook the way things really were. One example often given is the surface quality of the old work and it's often stated that the old finishes were dull oil or wax finishes that didn't accentuate surface flaws so the 18th Century cabinet makers just didn't worry about surface quality.

While many of the finishes were probably oil or wax, I don't think it was the case when it came to better quality work. The trade of cabinet maker emerged from the joiners trade early in the 18th Century and the specialty of the cabinet maker was case work designed such that it could be veneered. The work of the cabinet maker was all about surfaces and it's evident there was a culture of craftsmanship encouraging improvements and refinements. When the work centered around surfaces, I can't imagine cabinet makers not caring about the quality of those surfaces.

I look at the tools of the period and the trade practice connected to them, it's evident a considerable investment was made in tools designed to produce high quality surfaces. One example is the photo of a jointer plane that appears in Jeffery Green's American Furniture of the 18th Century. That jointer is clearly bedded at 60� or more and it's intent wouldn't have been for making long edge joints, it would have been for accurately and cleanly leveling large surfaces. The main reason I can think of for that plane was to prepare a large surface for a gloss film kind of finish. I know of another similar plane but it's a trying plane with a 60� bed angle.

We also know they had varnishes made of various resins dissolved in solvents that would have been used for surface film finishes. These kinds of finishes have been in constant use since at least the Roman Empire.

The strongest evidence, though, comes directly from the period. There are portraits and paintings from the 18th Century that clearly show high gloss film finishes on furniture.

Here are links to a couple of good examples:

http://collections.tepapa.govt.nz/ObjectDetails.aspx?oid=41241

http://resources.metapress.com/pdf-preview.axd?code=yl07522443wk2u60&size=largest

The trying plane I mentioned earlier was made by E. Taft working in rural Mendon, MA. This culture of craftsmanship didn't just exist in high style areas like London or Philadelphia, it penetrated into back-water areas of the colonies. I think the evidence shows a pursuit and understanding of superior craftsmanship in cabinet making was pretty universal in the 18th Century Western World.

Re: Things I think about

#2

Re: Things I think about

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I try for an extremely fine surface from jointer or trying plane. But when you actually make furniture by hand, a tried up board can get scuffed or slightly soiled from handling during mortising, dovetailing, carving, fitting, clamping, et cetera. And it can sit around while one is working on other parts. So it is nice to use a smoothing plane for taking a one shaving layer off the surface and freshen things up. That is why Peter Nicholson says that the smoothing plane "is chiefly used in cleaning off finished work." If the trying plane or jointer leaves a surface that needs remedial work with the smoothing plane, the overall quality of the work suffers.

Re: Things I think about

#3

Re: Things I think about

Dean J in MN

>I agree Larry and Warren. I view my smoother as the final tiny tweak to an already smooth surface. My try plane leaves a good finish (and is pitched at 50 degrees), and that is were I leave the inside surfaces. There will be scallops of course (very small and only visible in raking light, not much camber on my try plane) so the show surfaces get hit by a smoother as late in the process as possible to account for the issues Warren mentions.

The smoother is the least used plane in my toolchest, despite using it on all show parts, the fore and try do the great bulk of the work and the try leaves nearly a show finish on all but the most recalcitrant stuff.

-D