Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Egg Braters revisited

Posts

Egg Braters revisited

#1

Egg Braters revisited

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am an enthusiastic advocate of egg beater drills for the control they provide for precise small hole drilling (particularly pilot holes). Mated with a set of number drills one should never have anything less than a perfect pilot hole for brad, nail or screw.

In a post below the virtues of a Goodell-Pratt eggbeater are mentioned. I have a variety of Millers Falls and old Craftsman-equivalent egg beaters in sizes 5 and 77,which is what I can find at local flee markets. In spite of the same number on the handle some are 2" shorter than others. I prefer the shorter ones.

Is the Goodell-Pratt. even smaller (which would be handy for some things)?

Are these new tools or is this some old brand I never ran across?

Any other useful information for someone that never heard of this brand?

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#3

A little about Goodell-Pratt *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Because of the company's merger with Millers-Falls, the best information I've seen on their eggbeaters is in the Millers-Falls drill listings.

The link below gives you a thumbnail history, with links to other useful sites.


http://oldtoolheaven.com/related/goodell-pratt.htm

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#4

Re: Egg Braters revisited

Marv

>Bill,

Goodell-Pratt was one of the three major eggbeater/breast drill makers. Millers Falls bought them out at some point. Goodell-Pratt competed in all the various sizes of drills. Yankee North Brothers and Millers Falls became the two major drill makers of their time.

Your best source for these old drills will be on eBay and tool meets. I have found a few at flea markets, rarely at a yard sale or estate sale.

There are some German and British made drills that are equal to the American made drills, so don't hesitate to buy them if you ever see them. The German drills will usually be green in color and the UK drills will often be blue with the brand name, Footprint. As far as I know, the UK Footprint drills are presently being made.

You can learn a lot about all these drills by doing some Googling.

Marv

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

A further question

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I hope you don't mind me putting this here but it applies,I think.

I've seen brand new eggbeater style drills in catalogs.Garrett Wade comes to mind. Has anyone tried these? How do they compare to old Millers Falls,etc.?---Jack

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#6

Ebay *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

When I mentioned 'the Goodell Pratt store' yesterday, I was referring to ebay.

Search link for 'Goodell + Pratt':

http://shop.ebay.com/?_from=R40&_trksid=p3907.m38.l1313&_nkw=goodell+pratt&_sacat=See-All-Categories

I bought one yesterday. See link below.

Wiley


The one I bought

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#7

Nice *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've got one of those on which the little "finger" that holds the gear wheel close to the driven gears has a groove worn in it from constant rubbing by the gear wheel. I've been wondering to myself whether it would be better to build it up somehow, add a shim, or make a new one.

Since the auction has closed now, eBay offers all kinds of enticing other offers, including the "Goodell Pratt Stomach Held Hand Drill" linked. This, clearly, from someone who uses the tool pressure technique perfected by generations of jack hammer operators.


this is NOT a breast drill; the seller says so

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#8

Will someone compare and contrast....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the Goodell-Pratt with the Millers Falls 77 or 5 . In other words, for a user of these things is there any advantage to owning the Goodell-Pratt if you already have plenty of Millers Falls egg beaters? size, chuck, smoothness of operation, other? From the picture Wiley linked to they look the same to me, yet there was enthusiastic recommendation only of the Goodell-Pratt in the post below.

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#9

Re: Will someone compare and contrast....

Marv

>Bill,

In my opinion, in general, the Millers Falls are a little more robust to some degree. But really all you have are some gears and a crank and s few handles. As for chucks, I prefer the Millers Falls. But the Yankee chucks are even better. The larger Yankee breast drills have chucks similar to what you see on their braces, only without ball bearings. Some of the handles on the Goodell-Pratt have a little more flare in design, functionally, not any better.

The purpose of the thick main drive gear on the M-F No.5 is so it can be turned easily with your fingers directly on the gear instead of using the crank when drilling with the real small drills, 1/16" and smaller.

There's a German eggbeater also with that thicker gear.

Marv

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#10

Data on Millers Falls and Goodell-Pratt offerings

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

I'm all ears, too, waiting for an answer to what's the difference between these eggbeater drills.

Millers Falls. The long-standing reference on all things Millers Falls is Randy Roeder's 'Old Tool Heaven' site. Here is where he details all the hand drills (there are other sections on braces, breast drills, etc):

http://oldtoolheaven.com/hand_drills/drill.htm

In regard to the No. 5 series, which endured over many years, the chuck capacity in all of them is 3/16", but inspection of the various models indicates that they vary in length from 11-1/2" to 13". As you observed in your post.

Goodell Pratt. Rose Antiques has published GP's Catalog 16 here (you have to download a .pdf):

http://www.roseantiquetools.com/id70.html

Just a cursory inspection of the catalog indicates that GP's real small brace (No. 4-1/2) was 10-1/4" long, somewhat shorter than the comparable MF drill. I can't make out the chuck capacity from the copy provided.

The drill I bought is a mid-size one, being 14-5/8" long, and looks to be perhaps the GP No. 5-1/2, with a 3/8" chuck capacity.

BIll Houghton was most kind to dig into his herd of eggbeaters and come up with an extra (can you imagine?) Yankee 1530.

Wiley

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#11

Re: Will someone compare and contrast....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I bought the Garrett Wade version and it works fine; but it's the only one I have, so no comparison available.

I'm a little confused by the your recommendation of a fairly big egg beater for muntins. Seems to me the chucks would be way too large for such a job, the egg beater too unwieldy, and that you'd need a small chuck for brad sized drilling. Also, I've found several egg beaters that are much smaller, say 8" long vs 14.5".

So, given that you know just about everything (I really mean this), what am I missing?

Pam

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#12

Re: Data on Millers Falls and Goodell-Pratt offeri

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>If you go to the Millers Fall page you will see write ups on the various GP and MF designs. That's the best way to constrast these drills; on an individual basis. As MF made Goodell Pratt from 1931 on, I believe the two probably exhibited fewer differences as time went on. I believe the GP drills continued to be made in the same factory for a while after MF bought them. Long story short, they're both good drills with different bells and whistles, price points and purposes which leads back to my original statement; compare them on an individual basis. The MF page makes this very easy to do.

Re: Egg Braters revisited

#13

Footprint drills *LINK*

Nathan

>I looked up the brand new UK Footprint drills. They sell them on the British Amazon (see link).


New UK Footprint drills on Amazon.co.uk