Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Speakin' of Planes....

Posts

Speakin' of Planes....

#1

Speakin' of Planes....

John L Blue

>I got one at an antique store the other day. A smoothing plane, it only has "Made In USA", U in a circle, and the number 3 on it for identification. Appreciate in advance if anyone could tell me who in the USA made it, and it's value. Thanks.

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#2

scott grandstaff

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

scott grandstaff

>Almost surely Union

Union ventured into a lot of kinds of tools over time.

I have a couple of Union marked framing chisels that are top grade.

Slightly less value on the collector market, all things equal (condition etc), compared to a Stanley.

Scarcer, but the demand is just not there.

yours Scott

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#3

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

Tom MacGregor

>Peck, Stowe & Wilcox manufactured a line of economy grade planes between 1925 and 1945 with those markings which they sold under their Pexto brand and also labled for a variety of other vendors. They have a stamped steel frog rather than cast iron. Because the steel frog lacks the mass, rigidity and precision fit of a quality cast iron example they are generally avoided by most users. If your plane is of the stamped frog type its primary value is in using it to practice tuning, adjusting, sharpening and etc. before investing in a higher value plane.

They are also well suited for lending to ham-fisted neighbors who want to borrow a plane to attack the edge of an old door with twelve layers of battleship grade paint and a half dozen burried nails.

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#4

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

woodburnbob

>U is a common casting mark on extraordinary cheap and worthless mass market unnamed planes, usually with tin looking, stamped lateral adjusters, grossly defective functional design, extremely shoddy craftsmanship and a blockish looking tote that feels bad in your hand.

The dead give away of these no-name prizes is the frog advance knob that looks like a wavy flower, stamped out of pot metal. I always imagined the U stood for unknown, ugly, or useless. Rap on one in various places with a screwdriver handle and they will twang in your hand. The frog is impossible to fit to it's boss on the bed, so these planes never work. Tuning is futile; the worst thing a novice can do is mess with them. Their purpose was to frustrate the home handyman and increase the consumption of alcoholic beverages. Actually, one slightly better example of a bad plane in this class is called the Stanley "Handyman". At one time I spent many months working to get one of these no-names to work as well as a Bailey, simply as a challenge in fettling, an exercise in hubris. Can't be done. Their only value is to show you what never to buy or try to improve.

A true Union has the same heft and (relative) upscale features as a Bailey. It says Union on the bed and often on the lever cap. They have very beautiful reddish blond totes. At one time Unions commanded a premium over Baileys among collectors. That fashion has largely passed but a Union #2 or #1 will still bring big bucks. Yes, no doubt at some point in their history there were some versions with a Union stamp; I'm no Union expert, but they never looked like a U plane. BTW, Union was eaten by Stanley I think when Stanley was eating anything it perceived as competition. I got it all in a book around here somewhere, but I've forgotten the details and don't care enough to look it up.

Here's a nice looking little Union #3 that has had the wood messed with I think.

Ebay Union

Does your plane look like this? Note the nice brass frog advance knob with knurling.

Take a picture of what you bought and post it. I'd love for your sake if you have a Union and not a U.

I did find some Ebay examples of the U casting mark on no-name loosers just now. It only took a couple minutes. But this plane below is the best example of a classic U plane. Be sure to enlarge the images and study them all.

Ebay Disaster

This one even has the cheesy stamped lever cap. The seller wants $20 and $20 shipping. Total $40. The seller should pay the buyer to take it. This offer is basically an IQ test.

Oh! Lots of great Stanley Bailey, Sargent (if you like Sargent), Miller Falls, so on and so forth are going for peanuts these days on Ebay. The key is what somebody is charging for shipping. It is a total buyers market mostly. In my opinion the very last place to find a plane you'd want to have would be in an antique store.

And, I'm not trying to beat you up, I'm only saying this because I too bought a U thinking it might be a Union, up till then having never actually seen a Union myself, but hoping for a shrewd unearned score. Now the challenge for you is not giving up on tool purchases until you bank account is empty and you have lots of tools of all sorts of quality and value.

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#5

Unmarked Unions

Tom MacGregor

>Union planes can be found without any markings except the model number on the bed and the logo on the blade. Their best feature and the reason they were superior to Stanley's planes was the extra thick blade. I have a #4 Union with an original blade 1/32" thicker than a modern premium replacement by Hock.

Antique stores, BTW, can be an excellent place to sell tools*. I often get far more for tools at a consignment shop on a tourist route than they would ever bring on ebay.

*To make money to buy more tools.

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#6

More Union stuff

Todd Hughes

>Most union planes that you see were probably actually made by Stanley, Stanley absorbed the plane making divison of Union Manufacturing company in 1921, they had been involved in the company for over 50 years already. They continued to make Union planes under the "Union Plane company" name. I have old original Stanley catalogs that show Union planes too along side the Stanleys, they are priced cheaper then a regular Stanley

...Unions are nice planes, IMO not quite as well finished as a Stanley but still good. Most sell today for less then an equal Stanley. The exception are the union "X" model planes. These planes have a horizontile brass nut blade adjuster and are uncommon and will bring a premium.

I don't think the OP plane is a Union......Todd

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#7

Re: Unmarked Unions

woodburnbob

>"Antique stores, BTW, can be an excellent place to sell tools*. I often get far more for tools at a consignment shop on a tourist route than they would ever bring on ebay."

I got a kick out of reading that, Tom. Thanks for amplifying the idea that there will be very few wise bargains to be found in an antique store.

At one time I used to treat antique stores as any other used tool place. If I saw a $5 chisel marked at $18.99, I'd offer $5 to the clerk. You can imagine how many tools I scored at a fair price.

I've gotten a number of Pexto chisels, BTW. They aren't bad. Some are great.

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#8

Antique Shops

Todd Hughes

>"..."Antique stores, BTW, can be an excellent place to sell tools*. I often get far more for tools at a consignment shop on a tourist route than they would ever bring on ebay."

I got a kick out of reading that, Tom. Thanks for amplifying the idea that there will be very few wise bargains to be found in an antique store...."

I sell some tools that I couldn't sell on ebay for much in a small local antique shop and do very well with them too. I think that most people that buy them are not very tool knowledgable, I don't price them on the moon but still do very well with items after all I couldn't sell otherwise.

This sure doesn't mean that you can't find a good deal in an antique shop though! I stop in antique shops every week and it is the rare one that I don't find something. Some of the best tools I have bought have come out of antique shops and often they were very much underpriced. Things like a Stanley 85 scraper plane for $25 , Everlast chisels for $2 [labled "screwdrivers"!] lots of good saws for under $10...Remember lots of antique dealers will overprice something because they don't know about what they are selling...but they are likely to under price things for the same reason too......Todd

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#9

Antique Stores vs ebay

TomMacGregor

>A while ago the owner of the antiques consignment shop I mentioned above called me up begging for more old tools. I bought a batch of stuff cheap on ebay, did a little cleaning and labeling and sold them to him outright. Less than a week later some guy walked in and bought the whole pile - and posted them on ebay. Having now been marked up for at least the third time not one single piece sold.

He was from around here somewhere. I'm hoping to find him selling them cheap at a yard sale or flea market to cut his losses so I can buy them and sell them back to the consignment shop again.

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#10

You write beautiful stuff!

woodburnbob

>

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#11

dealers

paul womack

>There's a joke in the UK Antique trade.

If you put a load of antique dealers on a desert island, they'll be in a lot of trouble.

But if you put a load of antique dealers and a wardrobe, on a desert island, they'll all make a living.

;-)

BugBear

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

#12

Re: Speakin' of Planes....

John L Blue

>appreciate all the info! It's got the flowery knob, but the thing sure smoothed out a board pretty good. I believe I got my 20 bucks worth. Blue