Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

Posts

Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#1

Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

A little bit ago, whilst perusing ebay, I came across an old moulding plane. See link. English plane, made by 'I. Sym'. Unless there was some posthumous use of John Sym's mark (does anyone know if there was?), this plane was made late in the 18th century.

This thing arrived yesterday from overseas. It's about perfect. Well, for one thing, it's an odd profile that there's not much call for I suppose. But still, it's quite amazing, and the iron matches the sole perfectly. The sole is pristine.

How could this thing have been made 210+ years ago? That seems so long.

But there is another way to look at time. Which will be familiar to anyone who ever searched their family's genealogy. Generations. How much is a generation? 30 years? If so, the plane was made 7 generations back, more or less. If I count back through my mother's line, and count myself as the first generation, then that plane was made during the adult years of one Col. Wm. Farr, who is 6 generations back from me, or 7 generations from my son. When I was growing up, I met the wife of Col. Farr's grandson.

All those people used what I now know to be archaic expressions..... like 'yonder', as in 'look over yonder, what is that?' They were unhomogenized. So they expressed cultural traits that went back who knows how far in time. If I think about it like that, 200+ years is not so long. Technology changes a lot faster than cultural memory. But it is still astonishing to me that you can buy an antique like this for 35 GBP plus shipping. That is not even half of a trip to the grocery store. How could that be? What stands now in the place where I. Sym's shop stood on Dean Street, Westminster?

Wiley .... mulling over this I. Sym plane


Plane I bought

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#2

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hope to bring you back down to earth just a bit. First, $60 is about half a grocery bill, and probably a lot bigger portion for a lot of hungry people these days; so probably there was a lot less competition for your plane this week than there might have been.

Second, how was it made? Probably by hand just like it would almost have to be today. Here I think that we're all interested in wood, real wood; but that's almost an outdated technology. I hope I'm wrong, but it seems that plastic and metal and glass are used more than wood today. This may change if we start growing trees again to ameliorate greenhouse gasses. So it's true that we of the hand tool users are much closer to the 18th century mentally than we are to the current world. OK, that doesn't really bring anyone back to earth. :)

And this topic is part of why I. Sym made woodworking tools of quality, so he could gain just a touch of immortality. Congrats, I. Sym.

Pam

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I am leary

Jim in Burlington

>I am always leary of these stamps and when a plane looks so nice and new. Most of the english planes are kept in damp shops and sheds. Well used planes have some use marks example thumb grooves worn in them. In Jim Kingshotts video of special planes he had over 100 and you can marvel at the colour on them.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#4

Re: I am leary

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jim,

I doubt anyone can make fake moulding planes for a living. Also, this one isn't remarked, because that would shorten the chamferring. The front end construction marks, plus embossed owner's stamp is there.

On the other hand, there are many examples of maker's marks living on beyond the maker. For example, I recall John Jennion's wife ran his plane-making business for some years beyond his death. Something similar could have happened with John Sym. This plane is 9-1/2" long, which probably places some kind of age limit on it; also, the chamfers are rounded. The wedge finial is not the olde English circle, but rather later than the circle.

I would be curious if anyone knows about late 'I. Sym' marked planes. I might have bought it at the correct price.

Wiley

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Re: I am not leary

Stephen Shepherd

>I doubt that anyone would or could make a fake molding plane and sell it for that price. I have a couple of 18th century planes, English that are in similar condition.

I am sure that the mark could have and probably did survive the life of the maker, but at that price together with a laid steel/iron blade you got the real thing.

Stephen

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#6

Re: I am not leary *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I agree with Stephen. No one in their right mind would spend their time so poorly, that is, to build such a plane that requires quite advanced skills for such a little return. What would they get if their name was Larry Williams or Phil Edwards?

A few months back I won a large woodie smoother/short jack (!) on eBay. I bid on it for emotional reasons, and I suspected it might be a "fake" because of its pristine condition. On receiving it I recognise that it was likely made in the last 10 years, possibly the last 10 months, rather than 50 years ago. (But I don't care). If so, it was not deliberate because it is worth a whole lot more than I paid (pennies).

Wylie, that is one beautiful plane, and I wish you much pleasure in using it.

Regards from Perth

Derek


See what I mean ...

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#7

wear

paul womack

>I am always leary of these stamps and when a plane looks so nice and new.

Moulding planes are used (almost uniquely) lightly. I think the condition is entirely credible.

BugBear

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#8

Agree...

John in NM

>There's way easier ways of cheating someone out of 35 pounds, dollars, euros, etc. I'd be more leary of getting sold a craftsman made plane with a famous maker's stamp on it, though at the price Wiley mentioned, I don't think he paid a premium for the stamp.

And even if it were a "fake", Wiley's getting his money's worth in musings!

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#9

I am not leary either

Bob Hackett

>Up here English planes sell for less and are usually in better condition than the US makers.Most of the English planes I see are either an unusual profile or a specialty plane and that alone could account for the lack of wear and better condition.

Hard to say why they sell for less.One seller that I bought afew double irons from told me he was selling them cheaper(by half) because there was less demand because you had to provide a clearance groove in both the bed and the wedge for the screw.US irons didn`t use the brass button on the cap iron and the screw set flush or below thus making wedge fitting easier.I bought them anyway.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#10

I agree

Todd Hughes

>I see LOTS of molding planes and while they might not be 210 years old many are 175 years old or older it is not rare at all to see them in the condition you describe.

Most of these molding planes saw very minimal use esp. if they cut a specialised profile like your sounds like. That and many were stored in wooden chests which protected them very well. Important too a plane like this wasn't like a jack plane, chisel or a saw a tool that a regular person might have a use for and would be removed out of the chest by a carpenter or home owner to use and abuse.

As to price in my experance there just isn't much interest in most older English molding planes, I'm sort of surprised you had to pay $60 though I imagine it's profile had to do more with the price then the planes age or maker. I've been to tool shows and seen 18th century English Molding planes setting next to a rather common Stanley plane from the 1930s which is priced at double what the old molding plane was.

Things can change very much now when you start talking about 18th century American planes....if your plane had been made by certain American makers from the same time period it could be worth 100 times what you paid. While I doubt if people are faking $60 18th century English planes you would have to be pretty naive to think it doesn't happen with high dollar American ones. Rather then make the entire plane unmarked planes of the period which are common and cheap are "enhanced" by stamping the stamp of a desirable maker to catch the fish.....Todd

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#11

Thanks for the warning, Todd.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#12

Fake Stamps

Steve Elliott

>My most recent plane purchase was a small Mathieson infill that has a faint original Mathieson stamp on the toe plus a much crisper fake Mathieson stamp near it. When I checked the stamp on another plane it was the identical fake stamp. Both planes are equally well made and obviously old but from now on I won't assume that the stamp is proof of the manufacturer.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#13

Re: Fake Stamps

Joel

>Do you know for a fake the stamp is fake? Is it possible when made there was a mis - stamp and the planemaker just stamped it prominently again. Als unless you got both planes from the same seller It makes no sense to me why anyone would bother to forge a stamp. Mathieson planes aren't particularly valuable except for the styles which were peculiar to Mathieson - which of course stamp or not are MAthieson.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#14

I don't quite follow that, Steve

woodburnbob

>What told you that either the faint mark or the strong mark were fake?

I think I've read that back when Spiers, Mathieson, Norris and the other Ayr planemakers were in ascent, there was lots of trading back and forth of parts and whole planes. Spiers built planes stamped as Mathieson and vice versa. I think they both built for Norris at times. I guess I'll have to get out the books and revisit this...one of these days.

A few years ago I noticed what for all the world looked like a typical Mathieson on Ebay. The text said it was unmarked and might be craftsman made. Astonishingly no one bid on it. This was when the throughput of infill on Ebay was robust and Murland had 4 to 8 new offerings per week. So I took it for $200. This was when a similar Mathieson marked plane (lever cap and toe) was bringing Murland $375 and Ebay $350 to $450 and more.

It came in the mail and was very nice. Everything about it said Mathieson. The toe was a bit bruised and had a couple user stamps in there too. I got out my best magnifier and found the very faintest hint of about half a Mathieson stamp.

I emailed the seller and gave him my thanks and mentioned what I thought. He replied that's what he thought too, but hadn't found the faint Mathieson stamp himself and thus, wrote it up as unmarked, not even hinting what it "might be". Very nice guy, who said he was happy someone got it that appreciated what it was, even though he lost a bit of potential money.

I do have some infills that are completely unmarked but are clearly vintage and put together by mainstream infill builders of the era. Maybe I'm a complete sucker and dumb as a cloud. But the difference in the price between what I buy that's marked or not is negligible if anything. Counterfeiting might make sense with a really mint Scottish mitre plane, but even then I don't see many experienced folks being fooled.

I'm a big fan of the TV shows that chronicle the art forgers, especially where a few deft smears of charcoal or water color and the right looking signature bring $150,000 in profit on $0.39 of raw material from folks with money to throw away. But even infill kits are priced at a substantial premium to vintage Scottish infills. I'll have to find a tool & die maker and look into what it would even cost to have a passable stamp made. I'm not going to start counterfeiting, so don't anybody turn me in for a reward.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#15

On the other hand...

woodburnbob

>I just travelled over to thebesthingsdotcom to see what examples of unmarked infills one might inspect there. I noticed this:

"BM91052 Mathieson, Glasgow This is a rare and interesting plane. It is the first pattern Spiers 13 1/2" panel plane. It is marked, only on the wood, Mathieson, Glasgow, but it is clearly a Spiers plane. I guarantee that the mark is right and is not the spurious Mathieson mark that is so commonly seen these days."

Clearly one of the more prominent infill dealers agrees with you, Steve.

It's quite a rich stable of infills there so I got off the site quick. I swim in a school of fish that reside two escalator rides below those planes.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#16

Joel and Bob . . . *LINK*

Steve Elliott

>My reason for believing the stamp to be fake is that on the plane with two stamps, the shape the second stamp is different. (Same curved design as the typical stamp, but the size and curves are slightly different.) Also, the faint stamp looks like it is underneath all the finish and wear, while the presumably fake stamp looks like it has cut into a brittle clear finsh coat. The edges of the letters seem too crisp to be that old.

Below is a link to a current listing on The Best Things website that includes in its description "I guarantee that the mark is right and is not the spurious Mathieson mark that is so commonly seen these days."

I'm glad I bought these planes and believe their workmanship indicates they were indeed made by Spiers, Mathieson, or whatever other maker they may have been involved with. I also believe there's a fake Mathieson stamp out there that's being used to make unmarked planes more salable.


Listing with reference to fake stamp

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#17

Re: Joel and Bob . . .

Joel

>Leaving aside TBT statement that there is a fake stamp out there I can't argue with your conclusion.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#18

Re: Joel and Bob . . .

woodburnbob

>Steve, I've always thought of you as one of the most careful and circumspect guys around. That's why I was asking for tips on recognizing what's real and what's fake.

Do you think it is possible to capture this difference on your infills in a digital image?

I think I'll get down all the relevant examples I have ... of what might be real or fake ... and see if I can get anything into pixels, simply out of curiosity.

I agree completely that if one can tell a good infill from a bad one, the maker is irrelevant, and a fake mark simply adds to the historical character --- adding a bit of villainy to all the inadvertent bumps, scratches, etc., etc., the ugliest being those horrid owner names put into the steel with the little vibratory etchers that buzz.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#19

Logo Scan

Steve Elliott

>Bob,

Luckily I saved the scans I made several years ago when I bought the plane with both stamps. Since then my scanner has stopped working.

First is the plane with remnants of the original logo. The smaller crescent and star are all that can be seen in the scan, but looking closely at the toe of the plane I can make out part of the curved lettering as well.

The second scan of the fake logo (from a different plane) is clearer so I'll post it in a second message.


img

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#20

Better Scan of Fake Logo

Steve Elliott

>This is a clearer scan. Having looked at several Mathieson stamps, the way I now pick out the fake one is by how closely the left point of the crescent moon comes to the star. I have another plane with a stamp that has "Glasgow & Edinburgh" at the bottom and the star on it is well centered between the points of the crescent. I believe that stamp to be genuine.

Ironiclly, the plane this scan was made from is one I bought from The Best Things about seven years ago. It's my favorite user plane and the original blade has a number stamp that matches one on the plane bed. Just think how easy that would be to fake!


img

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#21

Looks like I have one, too *PICS*

woodburnbob

>The pictures are thumbnails. Click to enlarge.

Here are eight putative Mathiesons. A quick look tells which to start with as suspect #1 for having a deceptive toe stamp. Note the lathe cut spire (tit) in the middle of the lever cap screw head to help you pick which of the seven I focused on.

Photobucket

Here are the two with the best contrast of clear stamps that I could make.

Photobucket

This is the stamp of the one on the left. It has a lever stamp and the right screw appearance.

Photobucket

The one on the right. No other marks and what seems to be an old Spiers screw.

Photobucket

As I spent some time looking, several other features than what Steve mentioned make clear that two different stamps are used here. The typography and font spacing are different. I see a difference in the location of the period after "A." with respect to "M". I find easily find Steve's observation about the star and cresent alignment, and would add that the line connecting the star point at 2 o'clock with the point at 10 o'clock in the "fake" is off horizontal with the stamp XY axis. This imaginary line is horizontal on the 3 "non-fakes" I think I have.

Here are two other presumably bona fide stamps.

Photobucket

Photobucket

For those of you following along. This is pretty minor stuff and mostly a curiosity. If you are looking to buy your first Mathieson, and have doubts, you can shop until you find one with a lever cap stamp like these.

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

I say all this with great caution, since I fully expect a real expert to step in and contradict everything I've said. That's what's great about forums. Nearly every dumb conclusion I voice becomes swiftly rectified and I go away slightly smart without having to pay anyone even a thin dime.

Bob

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#22

Re: Looks like I have one, too *PICS*

Joel

>MAthieson was a huge company that existed for over a century. There are a lot of genuine Mathieson stamps.

I am not sure you can say these are fake stamps. The planes they are on certainly look like Mathisons and have not evidence of another mark being removed.

So in my mind anyway the jury is still out.

Re: Old planes and stuff I think about.... *LINK*

#23

Re: Looks like I have one, too *PICS*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Agree. Not enough evidence. You guys may be right, and it would be worth finding out what Lee Richmond meant by his statement. As a dealer, he would be totally alert to the risk of buying a phony article and then reselling it.

Two or three or four different stamps on what appear otherwise to be the genuine article, only suggests to me that Alex. Mathieson & Sons used different stamps according to time and place. It's the simplest explanation that fits the facts. Much stronger evidence of a fake stamp, would be a clearly non-conforming part with a Mathieson stamp on it. Bob's lever screw w/spire still doesn't quite do it: Even assuming that is not a Mathieson screw, i.e., a replacement screw, the lever itself which is the marked part, could still be bona fide.

Wonder if anyone in the UK has ever done a typology on Alex. Mathieson planes?

Wiley