Tiger Oak Finish?
David Miller from Iowa
>I'm making a table out of some fantastic tiger oak - what are your suggestions for the optimum finish/stain to accentuate the grain?
thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tiger Oak Finish?
David Miller from Iowa
>I'm making a table out of some fantastic tiger oak - what are your suggestions for the optimum finish/stain to accentuate the grain?
thanks
Re: Tiger Oak Finish? *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi David,
Congratulations on the project!
Some years ago, when I was making and finishing a bookcase in quartered white oak (see link), I followed Jeff Jewitt's overall logic. The way he presented it, there are two main decisions you will be making. One is the color you select to set the undertone; the second decision is how much or how little you want to fill the pores of the wood. Now if you go for a one-step pigmented stain (think Minwax stain for example), you combine these steps--the one product sets the color tone and also fills the pores with whatever pigment is in it.
Jeff Jewitt's approach was to separate the colorant from the pore-filling, and I found this to be good advice. For example, my own preference was for light pore-filling; but you might prefer darker pores. Jewitt's procedure is to start with a dye--not a stain, a dye. The dye will have no pigment in it, and you adjust the dilution to control the amount of color you want. The adjustment is done by making experiments on test scraps of your project wood. I used Jeff's water soluble Transtint dyes--there are alcohol-based dyes also, but if you want to use shellac as a sealant, you want water-based. I started with the medium brown, and then adjusted that with a little green, in order to get the most neutral tone I could in a medium brown. You might prefer warmer or cooler, so experiment to find what you like. I find you have more control with the dye if you apply in multiple dilute coats.
After the dye dries, seal it with shellac, wiped on. An option is to apply BLO after the dye and before the shellac--test this to see if it adds depth to your finish. The shellac seals in the dye, but it also acts as a resist layer for the next step, which is to apply (or not apply) a glaze or gel stain to fill the pores. A glaze or gel stain is just pigment in oil--Stickley used a dark wax for this step. So, for example, if you apply two coats of 1-lb shellac, it will partially fill the pores; but you use 4 coats, that will leave little unfilled pore capacity to take up the pigment in the gel stain. That's how you use shellac to control the pore-filling, and you experiment to find your own preference. As I say, I preferred the clarity of light pore-filling, but distinctive dark pores are probably more period correct. What I preferred was not to use a gel stain or glaze at all, but rather to put on about 4 coats of shellac, then use a medium dark wax on 0000 steel wool to both cut back the gloss of the shellac and at the same time, darken the pores slightly. By proceeding cautiously, you can add exactly as much pore-darkening you want in this manner.
But the key idea is to separate the coloring and the pore-filling, so that you can control each step independently.
Here is a link to Jewitt's current advice, which shows a range of effects you can achieve. There is an older link that is more detailed (less cookbook), and I will post it as soon as the Wayback machine gets back up from maintenance. Note that Jeff is recommending a patented sealer--his previous recommendation was shellac, which most everyone has, so you don't need to buy his stuff to follow his procedure. Same thing with his recommended gel stain--there are plenty of gel stains and glazes, or waxes that you can use.
For a table, I assume you will use a varnish for your final step.
Jeff Jewitt's current article on Mission Oak finishing:
http://www.homesteadfinishingproducts.com/pdf/mission_oak_rev3-2009.pdf
Wiley.....not pushing Jewitt's products, but I do like his overall approach.
QSWO Bookcase
Thanks Wiley
David Miller from Iowa
>
David, here's that earlier article *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>I mentioned, from the Wayback Machine. It shows a couple different looks, and Jeff was talking about shellac in those days rather than the patented product:
http://web.archive.org/web/20030407121833/www.homesteadfinishing.com/htdocs/mission_oak.htm
Wiley
Jewitt article (old)
Hi Dave, take a trip over to the...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>Turning side of this place and ask or do a search for Bill Grumbine and what he used to the table he made a while back.
Also, Chris Schwarz and Chico Hakman
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>several years ago showed on this forum (the archives don't go back that far) a Morris chair he had recently completed.
His finish was great. So I would suggest drop a note to Chris, unless perhaps he drops by here.......
Chico Hakman has done some outstanding QSWO finishing as well--main Messages board.
Wiley
Use Tiger Butter, maybe?
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>