Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Old hand Plane-need advice

Posts

Old hand Plane-need advice

#1

Old hand Plane-need advice

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi gang,

I just acquired this hand plane from my grandparent's estate and was wondering if anyone could help figure out what it's worth? It has a makers stamp of Ohio Tool Co. Columbus OH and the stam of I assume the owner T. Shilton and then in much larger stamp below his name the letter "y" in lower case. Shilton's name appears on both ends and the fence of the plane. Any help about this old plane that appears to be a rabbeting or dado plane would be really great. Thanks!

Jennifer


img

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#2

..another picture..

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Another view of it.


img

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#3

scott grandstaff

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

scott grandstaff

>Depends on what you need

If you want to sell it in 5 minutes, 35 dollars.

If you can wait a week or more and spend the time to list it, even poorly 40-50

Of if you work harder and take detailed pictures and write about 4 paragraphs that are decently witty and clear material,

65-75.... maybe.

yours Scott

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#4

scott grandstaff

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

scott grandstaff

>oops typo

25 you can have in 5 minutes.

S

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#5

scott grandstaff

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

scott grandstaff

>addendum

If you want to wait forever, and fully prepared to wait forever, you can set any price you like,

and many do.

But if you have to move it, or pay space rent for it, or even dust it, no matter how much extra you get, you aren't making much by-the-hour

:)

yours finally Scott

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#6

Stephen Shepherd

It is a Plough Plane

Stephen Shepherd

>

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#7

Screw-arm plow plane

Bob Hackett

>The plane looks to be in decent shape.The threads on the arms that adjust the fence usually show the most damage.Not sure by looking at the pics but are the 2 screws that go into the fence to repair damage from splitting?

If it were mine I`d look on Ebay at the completed auctions to better get an idea as to what it`s worth.

BTW-The iron needs to be flipped around.That V groove in the iron wants to be mated to the edge of the skate.

MB

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#8

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice-

Tony Sade (Charleston, WV)

>Jennifer--You don't indicate what your plans might be for the plane, but if I got my hands on a tool like that from my grandfather (all I wound up with was one of those cheap plastic set of drawers to hold screws, nails, and stuff) I'd sure keep it in the family.

Cheers,

Tony

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#9

Yes, for sure

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Another vote to keep it in the family, Jennifer

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#10

Re: ..another picture..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jennifer,

As others have said, it is a screw-arm plough, unhandled. Ohio Tool Co. had a long history of plane-making, beginning in 1851 when it employed 200 hands. (All data from American Wooden Planes, Emil and Martyl Pollak, 4thEd.). The Ohio factory was destroyed by flood in 1913, and operations moved to Charlestown, W. Va. Operations ended in 1920.

Your plane body, fence, and wedge (I think) are made of beech--note the distinctive ray fleck on the side of the second photo. The fence arms and wooden screws and nuts are boxwood. Note that the fence has a boxwood wear strip ('boxing') on its inner bottom edge--this is an upgrade. This plough would have been sold with 4 irons or 8 irons. You can still obtain irons, which is something I would suggest you think about (more below). On the front end of the plane, if you look hard, you can probably find a model number, maybe in the high 90's or low 100's, if I recall correctly.

Some partial dating can be established if you provide a little more detail on the plane's mark. For example, does the mark read 'Ohio Tool Co.' on one line, and 'Columbus' on a second line below? Or does it actually have 'Ohio' in the mark, as a third line--and in this case, is the Columbus and Ohio part of the mark embossed? Also, the exact shape of the wedge can help--does the back of the finial have a scooped-out (concave) indentation, or is it rounded where the finial returns to meet the back of the wedge?

Value is all about materials used, condition, and particularly how close it is to the original condition. Plus your ability to spiff it up, but not to where it looks spiffed up. As far as materials go, your Granddad's plane is middle of the quality range, neither all beech nor all-boxwood. As for condition, the plane is quite good, given a cleaning in steel wool and solvent to remove the accumulated dirt. As was mentioned by someone else, the threads look pretty much intact (a big plus); the wedge is very good, but not excellent since it is chewed up a little; it is clearly an original wedge which is important; don't see many dings; the two screws through the back of the fence are a considerable drawback to value, especially since there are cracks emanating from the near one; those two flats on the wooden nuts I'm not sure about--maybe someone else more familiar than I with the Ohio Tool line can say whether those flats are original or user added. I can't recall seeing them before, but they look pretty convincing.

All in all, I agree with Scott Grandstaff's valuations.

However. If you have never used a screw-arm plough before, let me tell you that they work great! Tight as a drum and rock steady. I can tell by looking at yours that it is in excellent operating condition. As was said, the V-groove on the bottom side of the iron mates with the matching V on the upper surface of the back skate. Put the wedge in behind the iron (if it's a matching iron) and it locks it up tight and there is zero wiggle under planing pressure. The depth stop usually will work well--try turning the brass knob on top and see whether it moves the depth stop without a lot of muscle. It's a kick to use one of these old planes, and they really do work well.

This plane is an excellent inheritance. My suggestion would be for you to get yourself some steel wool (0 or 00 is good; 000 is getting a little fine for the purpose, but use it if you have it), and a solvent such as toluene (found also in Briwax) or else for high-strength a methylene chloride based paint thinner per Bill Tindall's recommendation to me. Get some rubber gloves--whatever you have, because this is a mess. Remove the wooden screws and nuts and pull the fence arms out of the plane body. Then go to work with the steel wool and solvent. Enough of that dirt will come off there, that the plane will take on a nice look and feel, like it belongs at your bench. You will need to do this, even if you want to sell it.

Irons. Is the iron that is in the plane an Ohio Tool marked iron? Or if not, does it fit well when you turn it 'upside right' (as my son used to say when he was a toddler). The plane probably originally had irons marked 1 through 8, roughly from 1/8" through 5/8" by sixteenths, (excepting 9/16"). I like to hollow grind them, and hone at 25 to 30 degrees.

Congratulations!

Wiley

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#11

You don't need it.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Trust me....it's just a paperweight to a turner. I suggest you give it to a furniture maker. Preferrably one within a 2 hour driving radius of you. ;-)

T.

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#12

Above - my vote for response of the week!

Rob Lee

>

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#13

Thank You!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Wiley and Everyone,

Thank you so much for all of this great information. I had no clue what this plane was all about and you've given me some great information to dig even further.

Again thanks so much for the time and effort put into your responses.

Jennifer

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#14

Please post the "after" pictures and ID stuff

victor Parisian

>curious minds need to see and know.

Victor

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#15

Re: Above - my vote for response of the week!

victor Parisian

>I'll drink to that.

Victor

Re: Old hand Plane-need advice

#16

Re: ..another picture..

Todd Hughes

>A common nothing special plane that is in avarage condition.

This is one of those tools whoes worth really depends on where you sell it, unlike many tools these common plow planes do not sell that well on the ebay because of...well they are common

I've seen them sell time and again at local auctions for double what I would expect to be able to get on the ebay for them...Get some slow head Farmers or Antique Dealers and they take off. One of those tools I guess that just looks expensive to many people that don't know no better I guess....same with a Stanley 113 circular plane.

When ever I get a plow like this I clean it up real clean clean, put a price on it about double what I think it is worth, write "RARE ! 1800's Plow Plane" on the tag and put it in a little antique shop I sell junk in that I can't sell on the ebay....and they sell in about a week or two to people I guess that think it is rare and vauable plane!....Todd